Just a FYI but Youtube supports 4K HDR with ATV4K gen 2. Otherwise you got a good deal.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
2021 Apple TV 4K vs. 2017 Apple TV 4K: Is It Worth Upgrading?
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It is very disappointing as I think Apple has a really good opportunity to seize on the fact that nobody can buy PS5s and grab some of that market. It's not going to steal "hardcore" console gamers, but probably a few kids.
I don't even have a 4K tv... yet! lol
If your TV supports HDMI 2.1 with Quick Media Switching the frame-rate and dynamic range switching should be nearly instantaneous.
The internal changes that aren’t user obvious might also be a reason to upgrade. With one of my TVs, when I connected an older model Apple TV 4K to it the TV would, after a while, stop accepting input from the Apple TV 4K at all, just showing a black screen with no audio and a message saying there was no input. This was the case with 3 different Apple TV 4Ks. It worked fine with an older model Apple TV HD. This would occur at least once or twice every day. So far with the new model Apple TV 4K this has not happened (yet).
Is it faster because you’re on a fresh install? The A12 is slightly faster than a A10X. In gaming the A10X actually does more GFLOPS in benchmarks. I have both and did a fresh reset on the older model. The performance appears identical to me.
I found that remote latency/range made me perceive that the old model was lagging.
Since I needed an AppleTV for the bedroom I bought the latest. The remote is the biggest upgrade for me.
One really glaring error in the new remote is the inability for it to LEARN IR signals for volume control (when controled only by IR). Me and many others in apple and reddit forums have experienced the same issue whereby the new remote appears to 'learn' an IR signal from another remote (like the one that controls a soundbar), but in actuality, it does nothing to control it.
Anyone else experienced this? I bought the remote as a stand alone to replace my old ATV remote. The old remote still controls the volume, the new one doesn't. :-(
Anyone else experienced this? I bought the remote as a stand alone to replace my old ATV remote. The old remote still controls the volume, the new one doesn't. :-(
Library tab still doesn’t work. Still a dumpster fire. Even with more memory and A12 chip.
Hardware doesn’t matter at all if the software is so buggy it stops basic functionality. Apple needs to learn from the fall of Sony—amazing hardware that the software couldn’t keep up with.
What’s so amazing is this functionality works elsewhere in the Purchase tabs in the Movies and TV apps and it works in AppleTV app on smart TVs. It’s just a code branch that doesn’t work on Apple’s own hardware.
Clearly nobody at Apple and on the AppleTV team cares about quality and customers who buy lots of content to play onApple hardware.
Hardware doesn’t matter at all if the software is so buggy it stops basic functionality. Apple needs to learn from the fall of Sony—amazing hardware that the software couldn’t keep up with.
What’s so amazing is this functionality works elsewhere in the Purchase tabs in the Movies and TV apps and it works in AppleTV app on smart TVs. It’s just a code branch that doesn’t work on Apple’s own hardware.
Clearly nobody at Apple and on the AppleTV team cares about quality and customers who buy lots of content to play onApple hardware.
Just returned mine today. I have the 1st gen 4K Apple TV, I couldn’t notice a noticable difference. The new one was slightly faster. My 4K tv does not support HDMI 2.1 and I was using the Ethernet connection, so I dont really benefit that much with the newer model. Got the new remote and I’m happy. If the pricing was lower or I find a deal locally then I’ll definitely pickup the newer model down the line.
I'd give real money if these reviewers would simply present the facts rather than telling me what my opinion should be.
Perhaps, the old version does A, B, & C while the new version does those same things and this better. The price and x number of differences, does this make it worth enough of an upgrade, you decide. But in. culture where no one can seemingly make their own decision, this is annoying. Oh well..
Perhaps, the old version does A, B, & C while the new version does those same things and this better. The price and x number of differences, does this make it worth enough of an upgrade, you decide. But in. culture where no one can seemingly make their own decision, this is annoying. Oh well..
Mine stutters opening apps, to the point where it effects the sound effects (2017 Apple TV 4K 64GB with little on it)
I'm keeping my 2017 4K ATV. No reason to upgrade that I can see. I don't play games and all I do is watch purchases and my own downloaded content from the net on it. I don't even use external speakers. I can't even tell what's 4K or not because I don't wear my glasses other than to drive.
I would have to say it is definitely worth upgrading if you use the Photos from the computer feature at all. It is significantly faster and more reliable. That alone is well worth the upgrade. Albums that would sit there or not work reliably do now.
As far as the overall speed of the UI, that is noticeable also.
I upgraded both of our Apple TVs and am quite happy that we did.
As far as the overall speed of the UI, that is noticeable also.
I upgraded both of our Apple TVs and am quite happy that we did.
I had a A1427 3rd Generation Apple TV. This was a giant upgrade for me. It works great.
Now I need to upgrade my receiver and TV to 4K
Now I need to upgrade my receiver and TV to 4K
I wonder why they just didn’t put the current A14 in the ATV 4K…. After all, it‘s the currently produced phone chip and is a lot faster. Cost likely the main driving factor?
Having a thread router is the biggest plus for me. That and eARC support.
I bought one of the new 4K models to add to the collection of older ATVs, two previous 4K models and a gen 3. The older ATVs have all been deprecated down one notch, with the gen 3 going into a room where it will rarely get used. Since I use a Harmony Elite on my primary setup, I was able to take the new remote and pair it with the old 4K model for use in the bedroom instead. No buyers remorse over the upgrade, especially since it will probably be another 2-3 years until the next ATV model and the new remote is nice as well.
I am SO glad I upgraded to the new 4K. I enjoy playing games on my Apple TV, have the Nimbus controller, the whole bit. What a difference in graphics and speed. I thought it would just make stuff load a bit faster. I had no idea it would look so much better. Gaming is still a hugely untapped resource for Apple. I have a high-end gaming PC, a Switch, and an XBOX and I have only played on the Apple TV the past month or so. I feel strange even saying it.. but it's true.
I didn't upgrade from my OG 4K Apple TV. I didn't see anything feature wise that would be a clear benefit. I did get the remote. I am happy my current Apple TV. It does a fine job streaming the content I watch.
Without removing the software limit of 2 Bluetooth devices, it's still a failed device for cyclists who use fitness apps. this is actually a fairly significant user base of buyers who come to find out the can't use all their sensors on an ATV (but can on an ipad and iphone - but are unable to put on the big screen since no iOS devices have video out)
I upgraded the bedroom Apple TV HD (got from the developer program back in 2015 for $1). I did it for one feature – the ability to have two sets of AirPods connected at once. Now bass heavy ’splosions don’t wake the kids when we watch late at night and I can understand the dialogue.
That's going to require an entirely new product. Not something you just "add lol face palm".
1. The Apple TV is something you bury, not something you put on display. Even if it weirdly had a webcam crammed into it, placement would be a nightmare.
2. It would also then need very high quality beam forming mic array, and again, placement, in order for the audio to work.
3. No such product fits into the ideal home theater setup. Their best bet is to build it all into a Soundbar, so that it is something that people would be willing to put up front where it would need to be.