27" iMac is dead....again.

+1
Apple's obsession with form over function has just gone too far.

I think in the modern idea of engineering as a process to optimize the end solution for a few variables such as function, longevity/reliability, robustness, form, etc, there is now a heavy biased towards form, and more specifically, aesthetics. One could argue that function, reliability/longevity and so on are more objective ideals for an engineer, while aesthetics is more subjective.

I think that quite a lot of the products today (Apple or not) are starting to favor more on form, for whatever reason (and there are plenty, some shallow, some very deep). I would think that, as long as one doesn't sacrifice something objective and accomplishes that in a package that is aesthetically pleasing, the trade-off is a meaningful one. Often times though, the aesthetic-driven solution makes sacrifices in areas like expandability and upgradeability (and general service-friendliness) because the object becomes too complicated to service (that the user needs to be more and more skilled to work with it).

I suppose one day, some products will become state of the art in both function and form, and then you might require both engineering and arts degrees to service them, i.e., the mind of an engineer and the hands of an artist!
 
My G5 monitor developed a dead pixel, how annoying! That has pretty much been my apple issues. Besides the fact that they intentionally broke the G5 by not giving it 10.8, now I'm waiting for Debian 8. Oh, and that my MBP optical drive failed.
 
Hmmm...I thought I had submitted my reply but it's not here.:confused:
My iMac that received a new graphics card, logic board and hard drive with a fresh copy of ML has only been home 2 days and the display issue has reared its ugly head again.:mad:
Diane
 
The iMac was collected as arranged. Got a call from Amsys today advising me that the hard drive on the iMac has failed and will have to be replaced. It will be returned next Wednesday!

So far, the video card, a logic board and now the hard drive will have been replaced to cure this problem. :confused:

I collected the iMac from Amsys two days ago. (I would have had to wait another two days for them to deliver.) New Hard Drive fitted so had to do a full restore from Time Machine and all seems well.:)

My old USB2 Time Machine drive is now full so I have just bought a 3TB Thunderbolt LaCie drive which will become my new Time Machine.
 
I collected the iMac from Amsys two days ago. (I would have had to wait another two days for them to deliver.) New Hard Drive fitted so had to do a full restore from Time Machine and all seems well.:)

My old USB2 Time Machine drive is now full so I have just bought a 3TB Thunderbolt LaCie drive which will become my new Time Machine.

Keeping my fingers crossed for you because replacement of graphics card, logic board and hard drive has still not fixed my display issue.
Diane
 
Wow, you have been drinking the Kool-Aid haven't you?

"Precision Engineering" is a relative term, but engineering in the service of marketing gimmicks (like making your computer a quarter inch thinner, a feature which, in most cases, only the installer will see, and then for just a moment) is misguided if it sacrifices function, reliability and serviceability. Anything that puts you data at risk needlessly is a bad idea.

How many moving parts do you think are in a Mac now versus a decade ago? Do you think those old PowerMacs had rods and pistons? And how many catastrophic optical drive failures have you seen?

Fortunately I use Mac Pros for everything except my checkbook, any indication that the new one has heating issues means it's Windows time.

Totally!

Currently, thinness in a desktop sacrifices reliability, robustness and performance.... and what do Apple do? Make it thinner.

:confused:

Aesthetics should marry functionality, not overpower and distort it like a bully.

Elegant design therefore, the current iMac is not.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Back
Top