Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'm getting 404'd when I try checking the article's source...

edit: now it comes up.

The sample size (only 482 users) strikes me as too small to be reliable. I feel the demographic of those surveyed may have been very limited compared to that of all 4S owners.

Personally, I never use it. I want to use it for more complicated commands (things that are easier said than tapped, like "Add to my school calendar that I have finals in 105 shillman at 12:30 on April 5th." Instead, it puts down an event named "Final" at 1:05 on April 5th on my work calendar.

Calendar: Should have been School, instead it's Work.
Name: Final, that's right.
Location: 105 Shillman, instead that's ignored.
Time: 12:30, instead it puts down 1:05
Date: April 5th, that's right.

3 out of 5 pieces of information are incorrectly used. The effort to verify if it understood me and manually correct it is roughly equal to the effort of just tapping it all out in the first place, not to mention the fact I had to also say the command to Siri. Thus, Siri is a waste of my time. She's good for laughs and not much else.

(Other commands I've found she's less than helpful for: "What's a good restaurant for a romantic anniversary?" - She simply lists nearby restaurants with no effort to determine which ones are romantic. "Create a contact for..." - She says she can't.)
 
Last edited:
For me it's nearly useless. I try it every other week to see if it works better but more often then not I just type manually as it ends up just frustrating me. I have no accen so in the end she just bums me out from lack of functionality.
 
I haven't used the actual clock app to set a timer or an alarm since I got my 4S. But I haven't used Siri for anything else yet either.
 
I'd use Siri more, but Canadians ain't getting any Siri love :mad: C'mon Cupertino how about getting location based data for Siri operational up here!? I do use Siri for texting and voice dialing, but I'd really like to take advantage of all she has to offer. I know I know, it says Beta, be patient. Beta this! I'll "be patient" ya...eh! :D
 
Wonder how well Siri will run when the new iPhones are released?

I don't like how every action is server reliant.

They need to change that asap
 
I never touch the thing.

I can do tasks much faster by hand than by talking and waiting and confirming, etc. Plus most things I do on my phone are personal, I don't need those around me hearing what I'm doing/saying lol
 
As a student, I regularly set reminders and calendar events on my 4 for meetings. I played with my cousin's 4S and I would definitely use it. The disappointing thing is that it can't search for places in Canada which removes 40% of the function.
 
It's a gimmick. Thats why the numbers are low, and the numbers prove that. Feel free to downrank this comment because it doesnt jive well with Apple.
 
I keep finding things that Siri is good for. Whenever I think that something would be a pain to type in (like a long message or a note), I simply ask Siri to do it for me. I'm amazed at how often Siri gets some hard things correct. I am equally amazed at how often Siri gets some easy things wrong. For example, I have an daughter whose name Siri struggles with, but if Siri was smart enough to look at my address book you think it would realize that her name is in there and match the words up.

Anyway, Siri continues to be amazing and disappointing all at the same time. I can't wait for them to work out the kinks and expand the functionality for creating contacts, checking movie times, making dinner reservations, booking hotel rooms, launching apps, navigating to a location, and integrating to third-party app functions, etc, etc.....
 
Voice Mail

I still don't get why Siri can't do anything with voicemail. I mean, I was quite shocked when I requested "play my last voicemail" and Siri wanted to play a song named "my last voice mail" that it/she couldn't find in my catalog of songs.

I actually use Siri a LOT with my Jawbone Icon. I just leave it plugged in in my car and then I never have to take my phone out of my pocket. (Unless I want to listen to voice mail...)
 
I am excited that ESPN is supposedly working with Apple to bring sports information. That was a big piece of information that I always though was missing from Siri.
 
It's just a start.

People have trouble adjusting to such a leap. I remember having trouble going to iTunes and OSX back around 1999/2000. If this is the first account of use, it will only improve with time, as SIRI becomes more precise thus useful. At the moment it is mere beta.

Also, this will be an extremely-extremely valuable property within the decade as we will eventually speak to all our machines. Then the robots will blossom out of that ability to comprehend and serve when responding to a human voice.
 
In the beginning I used Siri just as a fun novelty. But over time I have found it more useful and accurate. I mostly use it for Dictation, directions, and looking up information.
 
Siri is great as a concept and I hope they keep improving. Currently I have it off mostly, for many months now, here's why;

1 - Getting messages on the go, Using a BT headset, "Read me my messages", answer, "sorry, you have to unlock your phone first", are you kidding?, it's in my pocket and my hands are not available... Fail My RIP win6 smartphone was great at this

2 - Dialing on the go, 20-30% or more of the time, it just can't get things right with voice dialing (and these are the most critical times where voice recognition is needed), plus the system delay isn't great. I shut Siri off and use the built-in voice control, it's 90% accurate and 200% faster. The built-in Voice command should be avail always, and a Siri question should be able to be invoked when you need to know the calories in a bananna. Example, if you use "Siri" at the beginning of a request, the phone would only use Siri.

3 - If you turn off Siri, guess what? , they dump everything that was learned about you, fail!

All that said, it's great in a quiet place, without a headset. Which sadly is somewhere I don't frequent.
 
Siri is great as a concept and I hope they keep improving. Currently I have it off mostly, for many months now, here's why;

1 - Getting messages on the go, Using a BT headset, "Read me my messages", answer, "sorry, you have to unlock your phone first", are you kidding?, it's in my pocket and my hands are not available... Fail My RIP win6 smartphone was great at this

2 - Dialing on the go, 20-30% or more of the time, it just can't get things right with voice dialing (and these are the most critical times where voice recognition is needed), plus the system delay isn't great. I shut Siri off and use the built-in voice control, it's 90% accurate and 200% faster. The built-in Voice command should be avail always, and a Siri question should be able to be invoked when you need to know the calories in a bananna. Example, if you use "Siri" at the beginning of a request, the phone would only use Siri.

3 - If you turn off Siri, guess what? , they dump everything that was learned about you, fail!

All that said, it's great in a quiet place, without a headset. Which sadly is somewhere I don't frequent.

You make some great points about the Siri UI. Let's hope the ideas get rolled into the next iOS.
 
I'm really looking forward to the next iPhone, and Siri is a large part of that. One of these days I'm going to drive my truck off the road trying to text someone back while driving.

Siri has a lot of great uses but most people I know rely on Siri mostly for speech texting, appointment setting, alarm clock setting, and direction finding. It would be nice if Siri were expanded to encompass all of the basic iOS operations, not being able to create contacts with Siri is a common complaint.
 
For my wife, SIRI was a step backwards.

On her 3GS, she could use the 'Call [XXX]' feature even with little or no data connection.

Now with her 4S, since SIRI even forces those simple commands to be interpreted on the SIRI servers, she cannot voice command a call to be made while driving on country roads with little connectivity.

This is VERY frustrating for her. Why oh WHY cannot SIRI let those simple voice commands be handled on the phone? There is plenty of CPU and memory power to do it.

If she is so frustrated why is Siri left on? When it is turned off the phone reverts to the, in my opinion crappy, voice control.

If she is leaving Siri on intentionally there must be some benefit or else she would just turn it off.



Michael
 
German Siri is close to useless.

It's good for 'call this or that person' but it utterly fails for any kind of dictation or even setting an appointment since it constantly gets half the words wrong. I'm using accent-free and clear language, mind you.

It's also very annoying that it sometimes takes up to 30 seconds to execute even the most basic tasks since it always requires a server query.
As others have mentioned, directions don't work outside the US. Wolfram Alpha doesn't work either.

This is truly a very beta product and not even remotely 'revolutionary' at the current stage. It very much reminds me of the Newton handwriting recognition. Always good for a joke, but otherwise useless and frustrating.
 
Seems to me that once a month is basically people wondering "does it work yet?".

I love the idea of Siri, and expect it to be the start of something good. Personally I just haven't found a good use for it-- it doesn't have the information I need, I have no way of telling it which contacts to exclude from search so it constantly tries to call people I don't want it to, and it's just generally slow.

That's not a complaint, really, it's mostly expected for a technology this new. And for those of us that feel that way, checking in once a month to see if it's improved is about right.
 
I am sad to hear this. I use Siri ALL THE TIME. Replying to text messages and emails, setting timers and alarm clocks, asking for directions, weather, etc. It's another feature I can't live without. I even Jailbroke it to add an app that allows me to open apps with it. It's so good! Oh well...

I seriously with my Mac also had dictation... I'd probably use it 10 times a day!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.