Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is so ridiculous. We’ve been through this before and that’s why storage interfaces became standardized.

Good on these people for taking the obvious opportunity, but it’s sad that Apple didn’t just use the standard interface.

As I’ve said before, just give me one M.2 nvme slot. Why even bother with this half measure?
Because Apple Silicon processor acts as a storage controller, and it interfaces directly with NANDs.

It's an interesting design decision, but painful for end users because there are no standard M.2-like interface for NAND access.
 
It takes away one of your ports, it doesn't look as nice (additional item on your desk), performance is worse, and it's certainly not what users of $2000+ computers should spend their time on.
You don't want to see my desk then! 3 monitors, a Mac Mini, a Thunderbolt dock, an amp, a headphone amp/DAC, a microphone, about 1000 cables, headphones, remotes (for the amps), a UPS, a MacBook Pro, an iPad, and a Windows desktop computer. No, I don't have a problem...
 
I think this is good, but people should realize this will most likely void your warranty.
I think this is the most important part we're overlooking with these 3rd-party hacks (yes it is a hack, while clever the machine is definitely not intended to be user-upgradable).

Yes you get more storage at a lower price (some may argue 2 TB for 400€ isn't exactly cheap, only cheaper than what Apple charges), but in case of any sort of problem Apple will deny your tech support claim.

I personally wouldn't risk it and use fast external storage instead, but to each their own.
 
Isn’t the best solution on a Mac Studio to get what you need at time of purchase and then augment with super fast external Thunderbolt 3/4 storage? Cheaper as well. You can’t buy the Mac Studio without the storage, and the external storage, even the fastest, is still cheaper than this offering.
Studio has one empty slot, so why not?
 
I think this is good, but people should realize this will most likely void your warranty.
There's a reason why I remove my BMW engine's flash tune before I bring it in for service.

This is a major win for consumers. Take your 15 year old flash drive prices somewhere else Apple!

So how long before Apple modifies the Mac Studio internally to block this modification and also add firmware update to undo any modification? And also send the lawyers to sue the company? Because this is probably dead on arrival as Apple is super protective and this is security disaster waiting to happen.

Pretty sure all the encryption is handled by the M1/M2/M3/M4 chips. The NAND chips handle no part of the encryption. Also, this is one of those times where the EU's consumer friendly laws should help. We'll see if the EU courts are friendly towards Apple's anti consumer behavior when it comes to storage upgrades.
 
Isn’t the best solution on a Mac Studio to get what you need at time of purchase and then augment with super fast external Thunderbolt 3/4 storage? Cheaper as well. You can’t buy the Mac Studio without the storage, and the external storage, even the fastest, is still cheaper than this offering.
No. In most cases, nothing beats internal storage. In some cases, apps won't use external storage for certain things (for example, After Effects for cache - you cannot force it to use an external drive for it).
 
What do you do if your biggest drive hogs are Mail and Photos and you need cloud syncing? Can't do that with the apps on external drives, right?
You absolutely can. I have my TV, Photos and Music libraries all on an external drive and it works perfectly. All of those apps officially support moving their content libraries to whatever local drive you want -- while still doing iCloud syncing.

I don't know about Mail, but I have a hunch you could do that as well if you did a bit of work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drrich2
This is pretty cool for hardware hackers and enthusiasts. I can’t see my dad upgrading storage this way but for those of us handy with a screwdriver this will be an awesome to extend the life of a Mac.

Wish there was a way to do this with laptops. I find I struggle with storage more so than ram. The only thing pushing me to upgrade my M1Pro MBP is that my 1TB drive is up to 800GB full with stuff I like to keep with me. RAM and CPU are fine. I’d love to stick in a bigger SSD.
But then he can pay someone $50 to do it for him - it's not that hard to unscrew a few bolts and restore the system. It's a half an hour job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CalMin
If it's anything like my VW Golf R, they'll know. lol. Had a $7k repair on my transmission, took the tune off.. their system instantly caught it.
Unlike flashing your car's ECU/DME, swapping the module does not involve any flashing of the logic board's firmware. Just keep the original modules and swap them back in if your studio starts having problems.
 
Isn’t the best solution on a Mac Studio to get what you need at time of purchase and then augment with super fast external Thunderbolt 3/4 storage? Cheaper as well. You can’t buy the Mac Studio without the storage, and the external storage, even the fastest, is still cheaper than this offering.
How about Apple not screw their customer base on storage upgrades? A 8 TB Western Digital SN850X nvme drive went for $550 on Black Friday. Apple charges $2,200 to upgrade to 8 TB. Disgusting. I really wish apple’s customer base would call them out on this.
 
Affordable? Relative to Apple but poor value per GB. 🤣
It's not really that far off from top m.2 SSD's. You pay around 200-300 euros extra for the plate, which is kinda fairplay.
 
How about Apple not screw their customer base on storage upgrades? A 8 TB Western Digital SN850X nvme drive went for $550 on Black Friday. Apple charges $2,200 to upgrade to 8 TB. Disgusting. I really wish apple’s customer base would call them out on this.
We do all the time. Only shareholders and Applestans defend this greedy practice. Even the press have started calling out against Apple's 8gb RAM base models. Thanks to the Ai hype/bubble, they finaly relented and gave us 16gb base.
 
We do all the time. Only shareholders and Applestans defend this greedy practice. Even the press have started calling out against Apple's 8gb RAM base models. Thanks to the Ai hype/bubble, they finaly relented and gave us 16gb base.
I see these cases all the time. People think that if they buy a device from a certain brand they can't criticize them, and suddenly they become huge defenders of that corporation. Not only can you, but you should criticize the bad practices of a company even if you own those devices.
 
Because Apple Silicon processor acts as a storage controller, and it interfaces directly with NANDs.

It's an interesting design decision, but painful for end users because there are no standard M.2-like interface for NAND access.

And yet it provides basically no benefit other than massive profits for them

Apple should be getting raked over the coals publicly for not using standard interfaces for storage
 
And with Thunderbolt 5 already in the Mac Mini, surely an ultra fast, ultra small thumb drive can be made available for a lot cheaper than this, with virtually identical performance than internal storage.

I just bought a new Mini with TB5, 512GB disk and plan on going that route in due time.
Yes - but for the Mini there is a case of having everything in one package (as it is easily transportable).
Also I didn't want my wife to struggle with external disks and cables - so I took the 8TB (still shaking from the price).
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimthing and raybo
You absolutely can. I have my TV, Photos and Music libraries all on an external drive and it works perfectly. All of those apps officially support moving their content libraries to whatever local drive you want -- while still doing iCloud syncing.

I don't know about Mail, but I have a hunch you could do that as well if you did a bit of work.
It has a number of drawbacks. The biggest one I ran into was with Time Machine. If you try to move to a new mac with a split system like that then your new system must have the same external drive configuration to do a restore, you can’t just say “restore all this to the new drive that has more space than the prior two combined” or “I only want to restore the OS drive and not the secondary.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: joecomo
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.