Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

All in favor for a Mac Pro case redesign or not... IT'S TIME TO VOTE

Do you think the Mac Pro case should be redesigned for the next update

  • Yes, even though it looks good it's starting to look outdated

    Votes: 51 31.3%

  • No, it's perfect the way it is.

    Votes: 112 68.7%
  • Total voters
    163
ildondeigiocchi

ildondeigiocchi

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Dec 30, 2007
695
0
Montreal
As I'm contemplating about whether or not I'll be buying a new Mac Pro in 2010, I think it will mainly come down to how significant a performance increase there will be and whether or not apple designs a new Mac Pro case which will make my jaw drop. I love the case the way it is size and all.... but if Apple does something amazing ...:D So how many of you guys are in favor of a Mac Pro case redesign. :D
 
edesignuk said:
What doesn't it have/do that you want?
Click to expand...

It should offer more HDD space along with SSD mounts and since the inside of the case cannot do so at the moment then Apple will have to redesign it. Also needs more pci power connectors so people can finally run multiple power hungry graphics cards without having to reroute power from the ODD's. Don't get me wrong it's really great but a 5 year old design should be changed at the next Mac Pro update.... :rolleyes: Just my 0.02$
 
Well I hope that the basic external design of the case doesn't change (at least not any time soon) because I really like the look of it.
 
Who says it's time to vote? You?

If you are basing your buying decision on the looks of the case you need to rethink a little. The case has no bearing on the speed of the computer.

Another stupid, specious thread merely designed around your need for people to hear your opinion.

So here's a tip - if you feel so strongly that the MacPro case needs redesigning in 2010 - go and tell Apple using their feedback forms - they wont listen to any ridiculous poll you start here.
 
stuarthatto said:
Who says it's time to vote? You?

If you are basing your buying decision on the looks of the case you need to rethink a little. The case has no bearing on the speed of the computer.

Another stupid, specious thread merely designed around your need for people to hear your opinion.

So here's a tip - if you feel so strongly that the MacPro case needs redesigning in 2010 - go and tell Apple using their feedback forms - they wont listen to any ridiculous poll you start here.
Click to expand...

Personally, I believe your a bit a harsh and should really think before you talk since this is not the only thread on the mac pro design... aka the on the Mac pro case being too big. I like the basic design of it... but inside there are components which must be added for it to keep up with the competition who offer much more HDD space. That's just my opinion and if you don't want to hear it then don't subscribe to the thread. The whole point of this thread is for people to express their opinion... I don't see what's wrong with that:confused:
 
iBlue said:
Well I hope that the basic external design of the case doesn't change (at least not any time soon) because I really like the look of it.
Click to expand...

Same here. I'm yet to see a more professional looking, yet functional tower. The internals can always be rejigged, but the outside is close to perfect.
 
Personally, I think there's too much aluminum color. But, I'll never own one, so I don't care.
 
I love the Mac Pro case design. The only thing I see from all these kind of posts is the lack of HDD space. Double the HDD space and all would be grand IMO.
 
I voted yes... The case should get... BIGGER. I really don't understand those asking for the case to become smaller. That is the exact opposite as to what I would prefer. How about a second row of HDDs? And a couple more PCI-E slots and power connectors to add multiple power hungry cards. Leave the cheese grater look alone, unless a different size hole will allow for better airflow/noise reduction. Oh, it should get wider too and have room for 12 DIMMS of DDR3 RAM, so that triple channel can actually be taken advantage of.

Also, I know it seems as if everyone wants an xMac, but just ask for that, not for the Mac Pro to get smaller...
 
Question is not good so i cant vote.

If you ask me do i want a new Apple’s design whether it will be changed
inside or outside of the case. Than i would vote yes, yes for better cooling,
reorganizing stuff to boost performance, etc.
If that is the case it is not important wether or not that will affect the way
how MP would look like from outside.

I’m one of the ppl who believes that esthetics come out from a function. ;)
 
Trev311 said:
I voted yes... The case should get... BIGGER. I really don't understand those asking for the case to become smaller. That is the exact opposite as to what I would prefer. How about a second row of HDDs? And a couple more PCI-E slots and power connectors to add multiple power hungry cards. Leave the cheese grater look alone, unless a different size hole will allow for better airflow/noise reduction. Oh, it should get wider too and have room for 12 DIMMS of DDR3 RAM, so that triple channel can actually be taken advantage of.

Also, I know it seems as if everyone wants an xMac, but just ask for that, not for the Mac Pro to get smaller...
Click to expand...

Totally agree with all your points. I don't see how anyone can say it is perfect when because of the case size the system has limited features. Sadly I expect them to keep it the same year on year.
 
ildondeigiocchi - I don't think I am being harsh at all - your poll talks about the looks, you talk about the looks and how if they become jaw-dropping you will buy - and THEN when questioned you suggested that perhaps some more real estate INSIDE the case would be a good thing.

So, is this a poll about the looks or the internal case design? And whether I am harsh or not, Apple wont give a monkeys armpit for your poll or the opinions here.

I stick by the fact its another useless, meaningless thread, similar in weight and importance to all the SL is faster, no it isn't drivel.
 
ildondeigiocchi said:
As I'm contemplating about whether or not I'll be buying a new Mac Pro in 2010, I think it will mainly come down to how significant a performance increase there will be and whether or not apple designs a new Mac Pro case which will make my jaw drop. I love the case the way it is size and all.... but if Apple does something amazing ...:D So how many of you guys are in favor of a Mac Pro case redesign. :D
Click to expand...

Let me get this straight, you HAVE a 2009 Mac Pro, Intel 2.66GHZ Octocore, and you are considering buying a 2010 based on:

1) Specs (I can respect that but WTF do you do that you need a new Mac Pro every year)
2) Looks?????!!!!?? Just WTF!

You apparently have more money than sense!
 
stuarthatto said:
ildondeigiocchi - I don't think I am being harsh at all - your poll talks about the looks, you talk about the looks and how if they become jaw-dropping you will buy - and THEN when questioned you suggested that perhaps some more real estate INSIDE the case would be a good thing.

So, is this a poll about the looks or the internal case design? And whether I am harsh or not, Apple wont give a monkeys armpit for your poll or the opinions here.

I stick by the fact its another useless, meaningless thread, similar in weight and importance to all the SL is faster, no it isn't drivel.
Click to expand...

I think s/he is talking about a total redesign inside and out.

If the thread is useless and meaningless to you, then bypass it. Others may find it an enjoyable topic. It's a simple concept.
 
I'm just amazed that someone who thinks this thread is stupid and a waste of time takes the time to post twice!
I would like to see it accomodate a blu-Ray drive as I really need it. Also room for a few more hdds would be good. Like the look if it though
 
I think the present design is amazing and should only be tweaked as required (to handle different port configurations, etc.). I've got a 2008 model and have no complaints whatsoever.

However, I would be in favor of Apple offering a smaller tower with less expandability than the MacPro and a lower price. There really should be something between the MacMini and the MacPro that isn't a laptop or an all-in-one.
 
I hope you didn't spend the whole afternoon figuring out what to write in the poll with the massive 2 ways to vote...

It's quite silly heh.

Personally I think the design is good but perfect is first obtained once there is not a single thing you want to change. So there it is, nothing is perfect.
 
I can see small changes being made to the exterior, but I hope it's nothing drastic. It's as simple and perfect as you can get. Internally I don't care as long as it gets better and not worse. More drives would be great. At least an additional bay for one or two SDDs.
 
One strong argument in favor of the existing case, is that it ensures strong resale values on previous Mac Pro's. If, when they update the case, all previous Mac Pro's will look instantly dated and resale values will likely drop off significantly.
 
Keep it the way it is.

If you do have to change it, make it 10-20% bigger (room for more hard drives) and make the logo black. Nothing else.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back