Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
"New rugs and curtains" change – I can see that. I think my own concern with Tahoe was actually predicated on that; Tahoe itself wasn't really a "new design" in the sense of a makeover – the ingredients were already largely carried over from Sequoia, and all the more dramatic changes struck me as the result of someone thinking "this is supposed to be a new design, but it's not changed enough." The result seemed like more changes for no serious reason. And that seemed dangerous, markedly the instinct of other companies when they're confused; not of Apple.

The keynote's spotlight wasn't on this, but it looks like Liquid Glass – the impressive virtual material itself – might fulfil its role in Golden Gate, actually appearing and animating in controls and moving and morphing there as in iOS. That's potentially visually cool and aims to mean something specific and consistent.
From my perspective, this is what makes it so frustrating, and pretty much a waste of time. We could have had something great, but now we just another iteration of the same flat, boring interface, but now with some shiny buttons!

Incidentally, I think having strong feelings about the Mac isn't something to apologize for. It's pretty remarkable how we're all here, seriously digging into discussions, because we all care so much about these details and have articulable thoughts about them.
I like that perspective. I stand by my opinions, I just regret the manner in which I delivered them. It's good that we keep discussing it, at least we all care!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Starfia
But I wouldn't exactly call it a magic bullet fix
Yes but think how many years developing LG and nudging and iterating LG UI into place until one day, Tahoe everyone!

Years of work, is not going to be undone overnight, but at least some of it was.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tagbert
It seems to affect other elements a little more, but frankly moving the slider to the right needs to make it even more opaque.

Compared to the Tahoe, moving the slider all the way to the right doesn't seem any more opaque than the Tahoe "tinted" mode, though the blur does seems to be a touch greater in Golden Gate.

So basically, in Golden Gate you can get less opaque than Tahoe, but not more opaque.

I also understood why there's an invisible drawer of blurriness in which the control center widgets live.

View attachment 2638373View attachment 2638374View attachment 2638376
View attachment 2638372View attachment 2638371
For me, this illustrates how poorly-implemented the tinted mode was on last year’s release. The new tinted mode is so pretty. Actually looks like glass.
 
Please just add the option for us to have solid toolbars 🙏

Looking at the shot below, I'm gaining nothing but visual clutter by having blurred colors/shapes sliding under my toolbars.

4b103e58a08893ff.jpeg


Here are dark/light mode shots 👇 from an older version of Reeder I still run.
This would be great please (solid toolbar, no need for "capsules" around every button)

View attachment 2637087View attachment 2637089
This. I noticed that the new LG slider only impacts those button islands and not the rest of the toolbar container background which looks unnecessarily odd. Yes, give us a solid window toolbar or allow the slider to control that too, Apple.
 
This. I noticed that the new LG slider only impacts those button islands and not the rest of the toolbar container background which looks unnecessarily odd. Yes, give us a solid window toolbar or allow the slider to control that too, Apple.
It’s interesting because I was admiring how pretty all the controls look in that photo. My Mac is stuck on Sequoia, but I can’t wait until they fix the glass on iOS and iPadOS so I get this glass.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.