Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
but you're not saying how the App Library fine despite the obvious UX problems I pointed out.

typically someone would respond "Well I disagree, App Library works fine in the way you described because (reason)". You're simply repeating "well it's fine, and your way is tacky" with nothing new to support it.

I'm moving on.

Those are issues for you. I do wish we could edit them but for the lost part 9 out of 10 I have no issue with App Library.

For the longest time I mainly only used app Livfseh because I despised the ideas of android like widgets on iOS but I don’t hate widgets as much nowadays. Or I tolerate them now.

For example I was flying back from Tokyo. I literally went to App Library and took a moment to browse through what games or streaming app I had. Some I forgot but was thankful for App Library reminding me about.

I also can use search in tandem with App Library. More control would be nice but
Infinite scroll is a nightmare and let it stay with android. As I said, I and many others are fine with iOS as it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Surf Monkey
No, grandma wouldn’t be using widgets at all. Where did you get that idea?

To be fair, people in their 60s now were in their 20s and 30s when the tech revolution hit. There’s no reason why a grandmother wouldn’t know how to place widgets on their phone. Getting older doesn‘t mean getting stupider. I know. Massive news.
 
  • Love
Reactions: turbineseaplane
I don't think it's going to happen. On VisionOS it makes sense because the interface has to use virtual materials that adapt to surrounding light so you remain spatially aware. Other OSes also have translucent "materials" but they're only used in places where maintaining similar spatial awareness in the 2D interface is important. You don't want to feel like the app you're in has closed when you open the Control Center, and that's why you can see through the material that your app is "below". Something like this doesn't align with the philosophies Apple has about it and they tend to stick to those.

Plus it looks like low-hanging fruit, the type of fan mockup someone does as a concept for a "VisionOS-style iOS redesign", it's not creative.
 
Infinite scroll has been a notorious RAM killer on browser,
That's more of a browser/developer limitation than anything else. This type of feature is not inherently memory-intensive.

infinite scroll gives no visual clue of “something ends here”
As I mentioned above, it couldn't truly be "infinite scrolling" since you would presumably have a finite number of apps installed on your device.
 
To be fair, people in their 60s now were in their 20s and 30s when the tech revolution hit. There’s no reason why a grandmother wouldn’t know how to place widgets on their phone. Getting older doesn‘t mean getting stupider. I know. Massive news.
It’s not “stupid” to not live tech.

I have both my parents (early/mid 60’s) on iPads because they’ve never been “computer people”. Neither will ever use a widget, as they have no need. It’s web browser, email, and a few fire department scanner apps, and much to my dismay a couple social media apps between the both of them and that’s all they need 🤷‍♂️

For comparison, I have to go over to their house every 90 days to walk my mom through changing her work computer password and there’s a VPN involved. It doesn’t matter that it’s the same process ever. single. time. The concept of “computers” simply doesn’t click in some people’s minds.

Even what we think of as basic terminology is beyond people who have no interest in tech.

I just had a talk with my manager yesterday when he suggested that we inform users to pin our VPN to the taskbar. I had to explain to him how often I’m met with blank stares when I say “taskbar” or “tray icons”.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gk_brown
pagination and infinite scrolling works effectively the same way for visual recall

first two pages of visual recall = top of scroll and one full swipe down on infinite scrolling

anymore than that, it's a bust.

at least with infinite scrolling, you can use widgets as visual bookmarks and have apps nearby those widgets. and finding that widget is just the matter of inertia scrolling. way better than 5 swipes or a very careful swipe on the dots.
you clearly have more time to spend organizing your phone's screen than I do.
 
you clearly have more time to spend organizing your phone's screen than I do.
Work apps in one folder, commonly used on a page, rest can live in the App Library.

I’ve never personally been app-heavy. I think I have like 20 third party ones installed, and half are for work?

I stopped customization around the same time I stopped jailbreaking and tweaking, don’t have the time or interest anymore.
 
It’s not “stupid” to not live tech.

I have both my parents (early/mid 60’s) on iPads because they’ve never been “computer people”. Neither will ever use a widget, as they have no need. It’s web browser, email, and a few fire department scanner apps, and much to my dismay a couple social media apps between the both of them and that’s all they need 🤷‍♂️

For comparison, I have to go over to their house every 90 days to walk my mom through changing her work computer password and there’s a VPN involved. It doesn’t matter that it’s the same process ever. single. time. The concept of “computers” simply doesn’t click in some people’s minds.

Even what we think of as basic terminology is beyond people who have no interest in tech.

I just had a talk with my manager yesterday when he suggested that we inform users to pin our VPN to the taskbar. I had to explain to him how often I’m met with blank stares when I say “taskbar” or “tray icons”.

There are plenty of tech savvy 60 year olds.
 
So basically. this could or could not be iOS 18 based on confirmed and non confirmed rumors from current and former employees and it could or could not release this year..

got it..
This more or less is a repeat of the same rumor discussion regarding VisionOS would serve as a model for the future for other OS's. Except it's not practical to implement and much harder to relearn every time Apple adds features or changes the interface. ;)
 
There are plenty of tech savvy 60 year olds.
No one claimed there wasn’t. In fact age has nothing to do with it, I know plenty of millennials and younger that USE tech every day, but couldn’t tell you what RAM is.

There’s tech people, and then the vast majority of humanity are not. They have other interests.
 
Visual recall is literally a form of remembering to which you argued is a plus on pagination. LOL

I'm moving on. This is ridiculous.

It kinda is since infinite scrolling is generally accepted as a dumb feature for a smart phone Home Screen. Pages of apps, the App Library, folders, whatever. They may not be ideal for everyone but the consensus is strongly against infinite scrolling.
 
I'm not opposed to a visual overhaul, but I wish they would just make better use of the existing space.

My Pixel 5 had a slightly smaller screen than my 15 Pro (6" vs 6.1") and yet it felt more spacious in so many ways.

More icons, more rows, widgets being more flexible in terms of scaleability etc

I like iOS in many ways, but it just feels rigid and inflexible in some ways that are no longer necessary. In more ways than one, Apple just needs to ease up on trying to control everything.
Android 12 sent all that extra stuff to **** to be fair, I hope you're saying this because you tried the pixel 5 when on android 11.. currently iOS is 10 times more space efficient than android in representing data.
 
App Library is absolutely useless
here's a NICE example:

Ring (security cam app) is in my "Utilities" category
Wyze (another security cam app) is in my "Others" category


Pop quiz: where is Stocks app? Finance, right? NOPE, it's currently in my Information&Reading category

So App Library is absolutely out of the question.

Spotlight? I use it all the time. And you can continue using Spotlight in infinite scrolling.

Your only argument is "it's tacky", and we agree to disagree on that.
Agreed. Spotlight is super useful. Pulls up needed results in 2-3 characters. App library is a complete mess and utter failure. There needs to be some sort of customization for what goes where.
 
  • Like
Reactions: truthsteve
Android 12 sent all that extra stuff to **** to be fair, I hope you're saying this because you tried the pixel 5 when on android 11.. currently iOS is 10 times more space efficient than android in representing data.
I'm not sure where you're getting that from. There's a ton of empty space in ios. Most notably, the space above the dock. You van just change launchers or customize your current launcher in android. Jam as much or as little crap in there as you want.
 
With a little luck, there won’t be the “beauty” difference that there is between iOS 6 and 7. The former is beautiful, the latter... well, tolerable. I’d go back to a skeuomorphic design tomorrow if I could.

Interestingly, I doubt I’d update anyway, but I would probably want to infinitely more than I do now.
 
Visual recall is literally a form of remembering to which you argued is a plus on pagination. LOL

I'm moving on. This is ridiculous.
you are confusing remembering with reminding.


Anyway as I said you loose SPATIAL location with infinite scroll. This is a HUGE part of Apple UI. If you have infinte scroll things move. There for things you need to click on are, at different times, in different places. (and you need to perform different actions to locate them == inconsistant behaviour) This is TERRIBLE UI. Paginated pages do not move the content, it is always in the same spatial location. This is a HUGE deal. You may not see it or appreciate it, but that does not mean everybody else is as ignorant.
 
I'm not sure where you're getting that from. There's a ton of empty space in ios. Most notably, the space above the dock. You van just change launchers or customize your current launcher in android. Jam as much or as little crap in there as you want.
I'm getting that from the extended QS panel with barely 8 buttons despite covering the entire screen, when on iOS you get ~20 buttons. the entire UI is extremely goofy, I hope you can see that. android 11 and earlies used to be wayy better in this regard. one button on stock android is three in iOS, it's as if it was done for people with a vision impairment
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.