Now, is it the iPhone or AT&T's network? It's up for depate... Compared to Verizon IN MY AREA, AT&T isn't even a competitor IMHO.
Just too bad that the iPhone is so sweet I have to put up with it. Trust me, I have already complained to both Apple and AT&T.
I'm in the same boat here in central Virginia. It sounds like AT&T's coverage is pretty good for some people in other areas, but around here, it's not even worth mentioning compared to Verizon.
At home, I'm in the middle of a "Good" service area according to their map (second best rating), bordering on "Best." That said, I drop calls at least every other day when at home and get a MAXIMUM of 2 bars, usually 1. Doesn't matter whether I'm on 3G, EDGE, or whatever else.
Go about 20 miles west of my house, and there's no coverage whatsoever. Can't even make a 911 call! And this is along
major state routes, not even in the middle of nowhere. If you're on the interstate, you'll have a signal... stray more than a mile off the interstate, and you've got no bars, no signal.
AT&T has
enormous holes in Virginia, whereas Verizon blankets all but the most rural and remote parts of the state.
I came to the iPhone from Verizon and sincerely wish I never had to switch. That's how much I love the iPhone -- I'm willing to put up with marginal to non-existent service. In the meantime, I'm seriously considering getting a minimal account with Verizon just so I have SOME kind of service when I travel around the state.
(And don't get me wrong, Verizon has plenty of issues of its own. But its network in this area is bar none best-in-class.)