Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Does anyone (and this includes these new Ring cameras) have a home camera solution that is actually SENSIBLY hooked into Apple Focus?
Specifically: when I sleep (or, for that matter, drive) I don't want generic notifications that something moved (which is sometimes animals, and often random electrical nonsense like lights next door going on and off). But I do want notifications that a human is doing something sketchy.

This is not just a request for "AI" and "face detection"; its a request for a TOTAL package that is designed based on real functionality, not checkboxes. So, for example
- if you have face detection (but it's trivially defeated by someone wearing a mask) that counts as you don't know what you're doing
- if you have face detection (but don't have a way to deliver ONLY the person-detection notifications when I am sleeping) then that counts as you don't know what you're doing

Conceptually what users want is just not that hard! We want
- recording of MINOR issues -- because why not?
- notification of MORE SERIOUS issues -- like animal motion, because lots of us like to see animals wandering around the garden at night. But those need to be LOW PRIORITY notifications.
- notifications of SERIOUS issues -- ie human like behavior in places where humans should not be -- that can punch through Sleep or Driving Focus.

Ring, for example, apart from anything else, scores zero because they insist on treating Neighbors notifications, all of them as super-duper-highest priority. And while I like to see occasional reports of coyotes in the street or helicopters overhead, if these are waking me up, well, Ring, that shows that you and I have fundamental differences as to whether you deserve my dollars or not...
 
Does anyone (and this includes these new Ring cameras) have a home camera solution that is actually SENSIBLY hooked into Apple Focus?
Specifically: when I sleep (or, for that matter, drive) I don't want generic notifications that something moved (which is sometimes animals, and often random electrical nonsense like lights next door going on and off). But I do want notifications that a human is doing something sketchy.
You can set up Homekit Secure Video to only record and notify you of specific events (options are currently persons, animals, vehicles, packet deliveries). Then allow the Home app to send you notifications in your Focus mode and that's pretty much what you're asking for.
 
Even if these devices aren’t recording, tracking and sending back all manner of data about everyone in your household to Amazon (they are) you can bet that at least one of them will be hacked within a year to send back data to someone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mr_jomo
So Amazon wants me to pay them $1500 to buy a spy robot that will follow my family and I around the house all day?

NOPE.

what they’ll spy dude? How many beers u drink and the music ur female listen to? Im sure jeff is busy with something more interesting
 
  • Like
Reactions: name99
That is some seriously creepy stuff. Privacy out the window for users of it.:confused:

The cats vs. robots videos are going to be off the hook.

anybody remember this form the 80’s? Was this their inspiration?!

 
Even if these devices aren’t recording, tracking and sending back all manner of data about everyone in your household to Amazon (they are) you can bet that at least one of them will be hacked within a year to send back data to someone else.

Apple does the same. (They do).
 
That Astro robot has got to be a joke. How can it “remotely care for elderly relatives”? Wouldn’t a phone call or video chat be considered remote care? Or giving them an Apple Watch so you can monitor abnormalities, falls, etc.?

Remote care is possible, to a degree, with devices we already have — all without introducing a creepy robot! And I seriously doubt the robot would ever “feel like part of the family”. Good grief, is it April?

Would it go like this…

Me — “Hi Mom, I’ll be over to take you to your doctor and pick up your prescriptions”

Mom — “Astro recommended a different medication, and it is being sent to me via Amazon”

Me — “Ok, how about a walk?”

Mom — “Astro recommends an indoor Halo workout”

Me — “Fine, how about having lunch together?”

Mom — “Astro isn’t hungry”
Check back if Fate is unkind and you decide to provide care for your parents as they die at home from cancer rather than out-sourcing to a long-term care facility. I made this choice twice. As soon as I saw that robot, my immediate thought was how grateful we would have been. But sure hate Amazon unless you end up hating Fate more. Being at home can be vitally important to those suffering, yet what to do if you cannot be there 24x7.
 
A robot by Amazon (or Alphabet or Facebook)? It's dystopian. No. Way

But if it's a robot by Apple and looked like Wall-E? People would be "OMG! How Cute! I want one."
Not me.

the ONLy robot I’ve ever wanted, aside from the original Robocop and reboot of Ed-209 guns and all, was the original Sony Aibo (that predates the more famous Aibo dog series). That thing had real promise.

Sony donated stock to California K-grade schools and found that even though the original Aibo could be pushed down and automatically stand itself up, kids 5 and under helped it stand up, treated it without any teacher influence as if it was another child. Even held its hand or consoled when feeling sad or hurt!!

that’s what’s up!
 
  • Like
Reactions: saudade
Amazon is the captain of surveillance but I must admit that the robot is awesome. I am very conflicted here.
 
that looks like a combo toy straight out of GI Joe 80’s original cartoon (Cobra H.I.S.S.) & something out of Battlestar Galáctica - Lorne Greene’s BSG!

must’ve missed that as I was a kid then too.
ha! that really does resemble it! wish i had gi joes then too — would've been a much more fun gameplay :)
 
  • Love
Reactions: DeepIn2U
Check back if Fate is unkind and you decide to provide care for your parents as they die at home from cancer rather than out-sourcing to a long-term care facility. I made this choice twice. As soon as I saw that robot, my immediate thought was how grateful we would have been. But sure hate Amazon unless you end up hating Fate more. Being at home can be vitally important to those suffering, yet what to do if you cannot be there 24x7.
Sorry to hear that you went through that painful experience. There is just no way I would ever put this damn robot in the home of a loved one to care for them. I would be there, or I would hire a full time caretaker. This robot would be worse than a nursing home.
 
that robot is probably the most real life dystopian thing I've ever seen. no. way. not. ever.
Second season, first short episode of Love Death & Robots is exactly a death match between an old lady and a deathly all purpose house robot like that one. That episode will definitely cement your mind even more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: happydude
The Echo Show 15 looks pretty interesting to me. However, with widgets on the iPad, I think it would be possible to duplicate much of that functionality in a wall mounted iPad. Photos widget, calendar widget, weather widget, news widget, notes widget. That should cover most of it, while keeping someone fully in the Apple ecosystem. I Thoughts?
 
ha! that really does resemble it! wish i had gi joes then too — would've been a much more fun gameplay :)
oh yeah.

search on youtube Dave2D Transformers ... some robotics company got license from Hasbro to make a fully voice-controlled & app-controlled Optimus Prime (like 15" tall)! He even voiced an action scene (Prime) and did some action shooting motion and the entire body jittered as if recoil kickback happened.

I completely nerded-out! Just like Dave did. And I'm in my late-40s! Amazon aint got nothing on that.

update: Made by Robosen. Licensed by Hasbro!
Limited Edition.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: alexandr
oh yeah.

search on youtube Dave2D Transformers ... some robotics company got license from Hasbro to make a fully voice-controlled & app-controlled Optimus Prime (like 15" tall)! He even voiced an action scene (Prime) and did some action shooting motion and the entire body jittered as if recoil kickback happened.

I completely nerded-out! Just like Dave did. And I'm in my late-40s! Amazon aint got nothing on that.

update: Made by Robosen. Licensed by Hasbro!
Limited Edition.
that's sick. i can't top this :))) video games ain't s-t :)
 
One of my all time favorite toys (though I think mine was grey)! Did you have the trailer too?
there was a trailer??? nope :( mine was identical, although i think the decals were blueish rather than what's in the picture. an i'm pretty sure my laser was red as opposed to blue.
 
I have watched the YouTube ad and I will still ask the same question as the woman at the beginning of the video: "What are we gonna do with a robot?"

It looks nice and seems to do nice things, sure. But I am not convinced. For talking to someone else via video, you can use your smartphone or tablet or laptop. You do not need a robot following you around the house when you can just carry around a device. If someone breaks into your house, they will just destroy the robot or turn it off and take it with them. And it will certainly not pick up a beer from the fridge and handle it to you.

And the robot seems to work fine on the video. But we do not really know yet if it will fall from the stairs or stumble in a carpet.

I am more interested in the Echo Show 15, which looks more useful and less of a gimmick. But it still does not work with YouTube, which is a huge letdown.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.