Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

lumpen

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 1, 2010
16
0
OK... here's a quick comparison between SGP Steinheil AF and Powersupport (PS) antiglare.

I put both of SGP AF and PS antiglare on a single iPad - on the left is the SGP AF, right side is the PS antiglare.

--------------------------

attachment.php


--------------------------

attachment.php


100% zoom in on an icon. See the difference in the text. With PS antiglare (on the right) you can still see the pixels, SGP AF just blurs them away. You can imagine how much difference this will make, especially you're reading a PDF/ebook.

I think PS antiglare is the winner here.
 

Attachments

  • DSC_22220.JPG
    DSC_22220.JPG
    30.9 KB · Views: 6,615
  • DSC_2222.JPG
    DSC_2222.JPG
    34 KB · Views: 6,522

greg555

macrumors 6502a
Mar 24, 2005
644
7
Canada
Can you reflect a lamp off of a dark screen and get a photo to show us? I'd like to see the difference in the specular (mirror) reflection.

Thanks - Greg
 

lumpen

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 1, 2010
16
0
Can you reflect a lamp off of a dark screen and get a photo to show us? I'd like to see the difference in the specular (mirror) reflection.

Thanks - Greg

Sorry but I've already removed the SGP AF and covered my iPad with PS antiglare, so no more pictures will be available.

I checked the glare though, when I had them side-by-side. Both do suppress the reflection quite well, but the PS antiglare shows a bit sharper reflection than the SGP AF. SGP AF does a real good job at suppressing reflection - by sacrificing clarity.
 

Chip NoVaMac

macrumors G3
Dec 25, 2003
8,888
31
Northern Virginia
Sorry but I've already removed the SGP AF and covered my iPad with PS antiglare, so no more pictures will be available.

I checked the glare though, when I had them side-by-side. Both do suppress the reflection quite well, but the PS antiglare shows a bit sharper reflection than the SGP AF. SGP AF does a real good job at suppressing reflection - by sacrificing clarity.

Guessing here that the SGP SQ is the replacement for the PS?

Did not see the PS at the sgpstore.com
 

greg555

macrumors 6502a
Mar 24, 2005
644
7
Canada
Sorry but I've already removed the SGP AF and covered my iPad with PS antiglare, so no more pictures will be available.

I checked the glare though, when I had them side-by-side. Both do suppress the reflection quite well, but the PS antiglare shows a bit sharper reflection than the SGP AF. SGP AF does a real good job at suppressing reflection - by sacrificing clarity.

Thanks for the info.

Greg
 

Smacky

macrumors 6502
Jul 23, 2008
455
5
Hmm, if you have to zoom in to it 100% to notice the difference, perhaps its not that significant
 

lumpen

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 1, 2010
16
0
Hmm, if you have to zoom in to it 100% to notice the difference, perhaps its not that significant

Well the difference is actually very significant. Maybe I should have taken a few more photos...
 

cheapa55

macrumors 6502a
Oct 29, 2007
903
6
Nice comparison. Just what I needed to make my mind up. Now I wonder if you have a comparison of the PS vs. naked.
 

ovrlrd

macrumors 65816
Aug 29, 2009
1,320
1
I agree, it would be awesome to see what it looks like with nothing on with the same kind of closeup comparison.
 

Dorkington

macrumors 6502a
Apr 5, 2010
685
22
I hate that I got the Griffin antiglare filter right before PS released theirs.

Oh well, maybe next month I'll buy the new one *sigh*
 

g8orballboy

macrumors regular
Mar 25, 2010
214
0
Hmmm... figures that my SGP just came in the mail yesturday. Its at home waiting my arrival. I checked every comparison thread here and couldn't decern a huge difference. Of course after i make the decision and buy it someone goes and makes an actual useful thread. Damn...
 

GoCubsGo

macrumors Nehalem
Feb 19, 2005
35,741
149
Hmmm... figures that my SGP just came in the mail yesturday. Its at home waiting my arrival. I checked every comparison thread here and couldn't decern a huge difference. Of course after i make the decision and buy it someone goes and makes an actual useful thread. Damn...

Given the reputation SGP is making for themselves around here (search the forums), I would return it and get the PS.
 

lumpen

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 1, 2010
16
0
By popular demand...

Here are few more pictures. :)
First three compare glare/reflection among SGP, PS and iPad screen itself.

1. SGP vs naked iPad screen, SGP on the left.
attachment.php


See the reflection on the right? That's myself taking this picture. It looks blurry because I focused on the screen.

2. Naked iPad screen vs PS, PS on the right.
attachment.php


3. SGP vs PS
attachment.php


Both remove glare quite well, but add some foggy effect to the screen. You should be able to see the difference in color between SGP and PS. Check the thumbnails below if you can't see any difference.


And here are more comparison - SGP vs PS.

4. SGP vs PS - Text in Zinio
attachment.php



5. SGP vs PS - Images and Text.
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • 1_SGP_AF_vs_SCREEN.JPG
    1_SGP_AF_vs_SCREEN.JPG
    264.2 KB · Views: 5,410
  • 2_SCREEN_vs_PS.JPG
    2_SCREEN_vs_PS.JPG
    279.6 KB · Views: 5,429
  • 3_SGP_AF_vs_PS.JPG
    3_SGP_AF_vs_PS.JPG
    243.7 KB · Views: 5,412
  • 4_Zinio.JPG
    4_Zinio.JPG
    345.4 KB · Views: 5,420
  • 5_Zinio.JPG
    5_Zinio.JPG
    364.5 KB · Views: 5,407

SchneiderMan

macrumors G3
May 25, 2008
8,332
200
It's no doubt that PS are the best. They put a lot of research into making their screen protectors and making sure they are super clear. It's been like this for years...
And if you want the best, you gotta pay.

OP thanks for the hard work.
 

xplocvo

macrumors member
Mar 27, 2009
30
0
Nice comparison, just wish it had been around before I had ordered mine. :) I had an SGP on mine but ended up taking it off due to the reduction in clarity. I am not sure I will order a PS, might just keep the screen naked from now on.
 

d00m42

macrumors regular
May 16, 2010
117
0
Miami, FL
I ordered a SGP skin a while ago from eBay, but it got "lost in the mail", and so they refunded me $10 of the $20 I paid, and are supposed to send me a new one. I guess if it's really horrible I'll just lose $10 on it and get a PS one. I really don't think it will be THAT bad though... We'll see
 

cheapa55

macrumors 6502a
Oct 29, 2007
903
6
Thanks OP!!! Awesome comparisons. Either you work for PS and you did some great photoshop, or this is just the best screen protector. I'll go with the PS antiglare. Thanks again!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.