Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
It's a very tough decision.

I bought a 6 last year because it was already a decent jump from the 5S, I thought it would be easier to carry, and I didn't know if I wanted to be seen with the Plus, i.e. it would just look awkward in a crowded environment. A part of me always thought though, if my mind changed for the next year, the plus would also feel fresh since I chose the regular 6 at that time.

Fast forward, and I did choose the plus this time as larger phones have become that much more common, and I wanted it to feel "new," again.

It is impressive and it works well. However, you don't gain that much from it. Most websites tend to just have slighter larger text, so you don't "see," much more, same with apps. If you do see more, it's maybe one line of text more, nothing to write home about.

Images are more immersive as a larger image rather in your library or at NY Times as images will always look better, but you have a large trade off for that, a large device to hold and carry.

Some games are better with a larger screen, and videos are always better, in my opinion.

However, for most things, it will work exactly the same on the 6 but be a bit smaller, with a lot more portability.

I honestly think you have to look into the names of these products. iPhone 6 and iPhone 6S are the iPhones, they continued the line. Many like myself, this is a comfortable one hand most of the time device. In my opinion, the iPhone 6 Plus and iPhone 6S Plus was a quick addition to the lineup to make sure Apple had an answer to the gigantic phones available elsewhere. They might not have believed in it, but if some people want it, you need to have one too. Honestly, it's just blown up without much care to it being anything extra beneficial, besides OIS, which in the grand scheme is very important to many, but more there, just because it's physically possible in that size.

I'm torn. I like the Plus, and I don't think I would mind carrying it the next year, but I worry how I would go back to a smaller size at that point? On the other hand, when I pick up my 6 now, I go "wow, this feels like an iPhone. You can take and use this anywhere!"

The plus doesn't feel like an iPhone to me, but again, I don't dislike it. Not sure what way to go. It's tough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bmwtech113
I had the iPhone 6 and swapped it for a Nexus 6 for a change, love this bigger screen so if I ever move back to iPhone I will 100% get the + model.
 
There are some people that seem to know which phone size they want and never look back and others, like me, that just can't decide.

Last year I printed out the little size guides and agonized between the 6 and 6+ for the entire time between the announcement and the time preorders started. Even hours before preorders I wasn't totally sure which phone I wanted, but I finally decided on the 6. It came and I was happy for a couple of weeks, but whenever I was in a store with phones on display I kept looking at the 6+ and wondering if I made a mistake. This was when they were still hard to find in stores, but I happened to find one one day and bought it on a whim. I used it for about a week and absolutely loved the screen size, but not the size or weight of the phone itself. After a week I decided that I made the right choice originally and I returned the 6+.

I was happy going back to my 6... For about three or four months. Then I found myself drooling over the 6+ in stores again wondering if I just hadn't given the 6+ a proper chance. This time availability was better and I ordered a refurb 6+ to save a little money. This time I kept using the. 6+ and definitely enjoying the screen. After about 2 weeks I sold my 6 and stuck with the plus. I still wish it was smaller and lighter sometimes, but this time around I ordered a 6S+ without hesitation.

So, the moral of my story is... Give the 6S+ a chance and you might just decide you like it.

My story is similar to yours, except I told myself that my hands were too small for the Plus, I'd drop it, couldn't use it one handed, etc. Over the last year I noticed something - I really NEVER used the 6 one-handed. So this time, I went with the 6s Plus and thus far am loving it. No plans to go down to the 6s at the moment. I'm loving the larger screen, landscape modes, and optically stabilized camera.
 
Been a 5 and 6 user for a while and decided to go the 6s Plus this time, but after playing around with it for a day I don' t know. It's too big for me. I miss the one-handed access but the OIS is nice. I dunno. Anyone else feeling this way?
Try a one handed keyboard that help too. There are some free ones
 
Got the iPhone 6S Plus yesterday and returning it today. I really wanted the extra battery life but imo it's just too big :oops: I realize now that I really do prefer the 6/6s form factor and I'll just walk with a battery pack and my charger
 
I had the 6 Plus for the past year after immediately dismissing the 6 for it's rather low (in comparison) screen resolution, small battery, and lack of OIS. For the better part of the year I absolutely loved the 6 Plus, but I found myself wanting something a bit more discreet that I can store away when needed and less prominent during runs/trips to the gym these past couple months.

Now I have a 128GB rose gold 6S and so far I'm loving it! The only thing I was worried about was battery life, but it's honestly been solid. Will I get a 6S+ at some point in the next year? Maybe. I'll just assess my particular wants/needs at the time.
 
Had a 6 plus and bought a 6s thinking it would suit me better. I went to apple today and bought a 6s plus. After having the 6 plus, the 6 feels like a 5.
Me exactly, tried 6s for weekend but have decided to keep the 6s+ plus battery life is much better
 
It can take a week or so to get used to the larger size, but once (or if) you do it's tough to downgrade to the smaller form factor. Every time I need to use a family member's 6 the screen feels way too small.

I'd give it at least a week. I doubt the 6's will be in short supply if you decide to downgrade.
 
I don't think I could ever go back to the 4.7" now. I had he iPhone 6 for the past year and thought I could never deal with the plus. This year after the Keynote I decided I was going with the 6s Plus because of OIS, battery and true HD screen.

On launch morning they asked me what I wanted and I told them 6s 64gb in Rose Gold and the 6s plus 64gb in Space Grey. As soon as I held the Plus I knew I'd made the right decision.
 
Thanks for all the comments, points, and insights guys! I currently have the 6s Plus at 64gb and I'm still deciding. The factors that really nag at me is the better portability, one-handed access, and if I downgrade I could go 128gb.

But with each hour, the bigger screen, and the OIS do sing to me. I guess I'm really worried about the size (bigger pixels, Live Photos, and 4K video) and one handed work flow since a pictured moment could happen any second and I had it down to a pat with the 6 in whipping it out and taking a shot but no so (hopefully yet) with the 6s Plus.

Ugh, decisions decisions
 
I was debating also. The Plus seems extravagant and unnecessary. I had a friend with an android and I commented her phone was HUGE. She said, yeah I can see it better! When I'm dragging myself on the treadmill at 6AM in the morning with my iPhone 5, I can't even focus on the text on the small screen.

What really sold me on the Plus was the better battery life & the camera stuff.

I can't wait to get my new phone! I pre-ordered through ATT. Ship date is like 10/20-30th. I'm really bumming. I didn't want to deal with the stores because every time we go there we have to wait like an hour just to talk to someone and that's not even surrounding a new phone launch. Just a regular weekend day.
 
The struggle is real indeed. Ordered a 6S preorder then swapped it the next day for a 6S+ and wondering if I made the right decision. Love the phone, screen size, camera and battery but it's just freaking large.

Last year I got the 6 Plus and hated the size so I switched for a 6 and was happy for a year but then had the itch for a new phone, the 6S didn't feel NEW to me but this 6S+ does. My worry is that next year when they redesign that it ends up being the same screen sizes as currently out but finally shrink the bezel which then would KILL resell value.

I have 13 more days to decide what I want to do. Ugh.

On top of that struggle the next struggle is color. Since the iPhone 3G I've always had white. I did buy a slate iPhone 5 but after all the scufffgate and if you sneeze you get nicks on the edge I switched to white. So that's 7 white iPhones. Got black for the 6S+ and don't know how I feel about it.
 
Did the same thing. I use my phone on the go so I need one-handed use. Ended up getting an LTE iPad mini 4 to satisfy my large device needs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: silverblack
I just hope, for the 7, they are able to shrink the physical size of the plus model (not just make it thinner). That would entice me to try the plus again. I loved everything about it except for it's size, which was a pain for me in using it one handed and carrying it around. It was a toss up for me on whether to go s or s+, but I went with the smaller choice and I am pretty happy with it. Probably be a 7s+ for me next time though!
 
I love the screen, love the battery life, but hate the wrist pain it's causing me. OIS is dope, but I'd be lying if I said I shot a lot of video that I needed it for. It sticks out of my pockets, I hate not being able to use it one handed...

I'm giving it a full week and then I'll decide. I'll really miss the battery, but not much else.
 
I went with the 6s and my wife got the 6s Plus. I find her phone just a tad too big for my hand - I have short fingers while she has longer fingers. She is happy with the size. I like the screen on hers but I am quite content with my 6s.
 
I've just swapped my 64GB 6s Plus for the equivalent 6s at Regent Street. I did the same last year, but thought I'd be able to stand the massive Plus this time round. Nope.

It's quite simply too big and heavy this year, IMO. Next year, with thinner bezels and less weight, then maybe.

I don't like returning an iPhone at a time where you know someone is desperately trying to get their hands on that same model. I wish it was easy and safe to sell to people at this time. List price, obviously.
 
I've just swapped my 64GB 6s Plus for the equivalent 6s at Regent Street. I did the same last year, but thought I'd be able to stand the massive Plus this time round. Nope.

It's quite simply too big and heavy this year, IMO. Next year, with thinner bezels and less weight, then maybe.

I don't like returning an iPhone at a time where you know someone is desperately trying to get their hands on that same model. I wish it was easy and safe to sell to people at this time. List price, obviously.

How did you originally purchase your phone? Carrier locked? Online or in store?

I'm gonna try and do an in store swap next week. Got mine on AT&T Next through an Apple preorder so just curious :)
 
I don't know. I'm so confused myself. Had the plus last year. This year I bought a 6S+ on launch day but I found myself wanting the smaller phone so I exchanged it the next day. Now I'm sad and am missing the larger one. The battery is getting to me. I didn't have to worry a whole year about battery life. That's a great feeling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eagleglen
How did you originally purchase your phone? Carrier locked? Online or in store?

I'm gonna try and do an in store swap next week. Got mine on AT&T Next through an Apple preorder so just curious :)

I'm in the UK - just bought it on launch morning at an Apple Store. Factory unlocked, £699.

By 'swap' I mean I just returned my 6s Plus (14 day buyer's remorse policy), then proceeded to buy a 6s immediately after.

There seems to be plenty of stock in London, which helped.
 
When I bought my 6+ it took me a couple weeks to adjust, but now I'm glad I went with it. The bigger screen is glorious.
 
Went from Nexus 6 to iPhone 6, didn't regret it.. Really don't get on with large phones, far to impractical for one handed use. Have tried the iPhone 6 Plus, just like the Nexus 6 it feels like such a chore to use when you're on the move. I also always pick up my iPad Mini when I'm sat at home reading or responding to emails.

Now have my iPhone 6S, didn't even consider the plus. While I'd love the extra battery life, screen resolution and video stability... Nothing trumps usability of the phone itself for me.
 
There are some people that seem to know which phone size they want and never look back and others, like me, that just can't decide.

Last year I printed out the little size guides and agonized between the 6 and 6+ for the entire time between the announcement and the time preorders started. Even hours before preorders I wasn't totally sure which phone I wanted, but I finally decided on the 6. It came and I was happy for a couple of weeks, but whenever I was in a store with phones on display I kept looking at the 6+ and wondering if I made a mistake. This was when they were still hard to find in stores, but I happened to find one one day and bought it on a whim. I used it for about a week and absolutely loved the screen size, but not the size or weight of the phone itself. After a week I decided that I made the right choice originally and I returned the 6+.

I was happy going back to my 6... For about three or four months. Then I found myself drooling over the 6+ in stores again wondering if I just hadn't given the 6+ a proper chance. This time availability was better and I ordered a refurb 6+ to save a little money. This time I kept using the. 6+ and definitely enjoying the screen. After about 2 weeks I sold my 6 and stuck with the plus. I still wish it was smaller and lighter sometimes, but this time around I ordered a 6S+ without hesitation.

So, the moral of my story is... Give the 6S+ a chance and you might just decide you like it.
Similar story here, I bought a 6, couldn't stop wandering about the 6 plus, bought one and sold the 6, and been using the 6 plus for about 8 months... Then I decided to swap for a 6 just before the 6s was announced. I am using a 6 now and loving the slimness, one handed use, lightness and the fact that I don't notice it when driving and in the gym.

I am now agonizing between 6S and 6S plus, have to make the decision at the end of this month.
 
Update: After convincing myself that the 6s Plus was fine during the weekend, after one full work day with it I discovered it was just too big for my personal flow. Of course the bigger screen, better battery life, and OIS were excellent but I lost a sense of mobility, agility, and over all sense of productivity. I know some will say I should have stuck with it longer than the weekend but already I swapped it out for the 6s on Monday.

Since then, I haven't really had much regret. I really do like the single handed aspect of it and the size, at least for me, works perfectly.

Good Luck with the decision with the rest of you all!
 
went and bought a 6S today.. have both the 6S and 6S Plus. i think the 6S will be the winner.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.