Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Did you switch to a non-iPhone? Are you happy about that?

  • I switched and I can't imagine going back to the iPhone.

    Votes: 6 14.6%
  • I switched but I miss the iPhone.

    Votes: 4 9.8%
  • I switched, but I've switched back to the iPhone since.

    Votes: 14 34.1%
  • I haven't switched, but I am thinking about it.

    Votes: 6 14.6%
  • I've given up all phones completely.

    Votes: 11 26.8%

  • Total voters
    41

TheSpaz

macrumors 604
Original poster
Jun 20, 2005
7,032
1
What are your thoughts. Have you regretted it? Did you return to the iPhone after a while?

Has anyone been happy since getting rid of their iPhone?
 
I honestly think someone would have to blow me away with another phone to get rid of my iPhone. Like that thing better get me better MPGs in the city or something.

Hate blackberrys, too old for a sidekick, not a fan of how bulky the latest htc phones have been.
 
What are your thoughts. Have you regretted it? Did you return to the iPhone after a while?

Has anyone been happy since getting rid of their iPhone?

I can't see me leaving the iphone camp for a while yet, I came from Nokia and still own a N95, N95-8gb and a N96, all are ok but the Iphone is in a different league, It's the smoothness I love and I use my phone a hell of a lot, to give you an example I have to charge my phone from empty 2-3 times a day.

On a recent trip to Amsterdam I did use my N96 because the camera and video are amazing, but day to day in the UK my iphone is the weapon of choice :)
 
.... Why would I want a phone made out of gold....

In the Spaz's case, the pixels would be aligned correctly, there would be no creaks, no light leaks, it can send MMS, the case wouldn't crack.

My post was mostly a joke. I was essentially saying there isn't many phones can can match the build quality, function and scratch resistance (screen) of the iPhone.
 
I switched from a brand new iPhone 3GS (32GB) to a used, cracked, and scratched up iPhone 3G (16GB) running 2.2.1 because I didn't like the iPhone 3GS build quality and screen. I love my iPhone 3G screen and other than the cracks that I put there, I can't complain about the build. It's a great phone and 2.2.1 makes it almost as fast as the iPhone 3GS.
 
I went from the iPhone 2G to the 3G, then to the 3GS and now I switched to a G1 (Android Dev Phone 1). I love the G1 to be honest. Android is a nice looking, refreshing OS with openness that really allows app developers to code anything, from replacement mail apps to replacement SMS apps, etc. Also, I do enjoy having the physical keyboard on the G1. All in all, it a solid device. But will I switch back to my 3GS? Hard to say.
 
My brother went from iPhone (First gen) to HTC Tilt. Then he didn't like that so he went to a Moto Q, then to a iPhone 3G. Then he wanted the Blackberry email thing so he went to a HTC Fuze (Touch Pro). Then he didn't like that, so back to iPhone 3G. Then to a Nokia N97. Now he's selling his Fuze and N97 to buy a BB Curve.
 
"It's a great phone and 2.2.1 makes it almost as fast as the iPhone 3GS. "

In your mind only. Scientific tests and data prove otherwise
 
"It's a great phone and 2.2.1 makes it almost as fast as the iPhone 3GS. "

In your mind only. Scientific tests and data prove otherwise

2.2.1 is pretty fast for me. 3.0 was so sluggish on my iPhone 3G that it made the 3GS look like a rocket. 2.2.1 is better, but still not as fast as the 3GS but, it's faster than 3.0 on an iPhone 3G, so I say 2.2.1 is almost as fast as the 3GS.
 
And again I say that it's been proven otherwise. It might be faster than 3.0 on the 3g you had. But the 3gs is exponentially faster - not "almost" as fast
 
2.2.1 is pretty fast for me. 3.0 was so sluggish on my iPhone 3G that it made the 3GS look like a rocket. 2.2.1 is better, but still not as fast as the 3GS but, it's faster than 3.0 on an iPhone 3G, so I say 2.2.1 is almost as fast as the 3GS.

I have 3.0 running on my 2G iPhone and in speed terms its barely any different than 2.whateveritwas. A tiny bit of extra lag opening apps or closing them, but I'm rarely in so much of a hurry than a handful of milliseconds aggregated over a few hours during the day makes much difference.
 
And again I say that it's been proven otherwise. It might be faster than 3.0 on the 3g you had. But the 3gs is exponentially faster - not "almost" as fast

"Almost" isn't an exact measurement. Launching apps on 2.2.1 next to an iPhone 3GS is only slightly behind. I'm being serious. It's about a half-second difference.

What is your problem?

Also, I forgot to mention. I'm not just talking about launching apps, but animations are smoother and the graphics are better looking (in my opinion). 3.0 is pretty ugly as far as design goes.
 
I miss the iPhone.

Someone I work with has just got an iPhone 3G and it made me realise how stupid it was to sell my old iPhone 2G. I'm saving up for either a 3G or 16GB 3GS.. not decided yet.
 
"Almost" isn't an exact measurement. Launching apps on 2.2.1 next to an iPhone 3GS is only slightly behind. I'm being serious. It's about a half-second difference.

What is your problem?

Also, I forgot to mention. I'm not just talking about launching apps, but animations are smoother and the graphics are better looking (in my opinion). 3.0 is pretty ugly as far as design goes.

al·most (ôlmst, ôl-mst)
adv.
Slightly short of; not quite; nearly

Again - benchmark tests have shown the 3gs to be MUCH (not almost) faster.

I don't have a problem other than you misrepresenting facts. That's all :)
 
I switched from a brand new iPhone 3GS (32GB) to a used, cracked, and scratched up iPhone 3G (16GB) running 2.2.1 because I didn't like the iPhone 3GS build quality and screen. I love my iPhone 3G screen and other than the cracks that I put there, I can't complain about the build. It's a great phone and 2.2.1 makes it almost as fast as the iPhone 3GS.

3.0 on the 3G sucks, 3.1beta on the 3G is awesome... it doesn't lag like 3.0.
 
al·most (ôlmst, ôl-mst)
adv.
Slightly short of; not quite; nearly

Again - benchmark tests have shown the 3gs to be MUCH (not almost) faster.

I don't have a problem other than you misrepresenting facts. That's all :)

Give me links to these tests. Because honestly I had 2.2.1 on my 3G and went to AT&T and did side by side with the 3GS and there was maybe 1/2 second difference.

Now that I have 3.0b1, next to the 3GS at the same store there is no difference.

Yeah I know that Apple says it is 2X faster on their website. If that's all you're going on then...
 
My brother went from iPhone (First gen) to HTC Tilt. Then he didn't like that so he went to a Moto Q, then to a iPhone 3G. Then he wanted the Blackberry email thing so he went to a HTC Fuze (Touch Pro). Then he didn't like that, so back to iPhone 3G. Then to a Nokia N97. Now he's selling his Fuze and N97 to buy a BB Curve.

After all that and he STILL isn't happy? I'm thinking he is expecting too much from his phones and/or is only excited by the "newness" of a product and quickly becomes bored.

I shudder at all the money he has thrown away with his ADD. :(
 
Switched from a 3G to a BlackBerry Javelin. I miss some aspects of the iPhone, but overall I am very happy with the switch, and won't be switching back.
 
Give me links to these tests. Because honestly I had 2.2.1 on my 3G and went to AT&T and did side by side with the 3GS and there was maybe 1/2 second difference.

Now that I have 3.0b1, next to the 3GS at the same store there is no difference.

Yeah I know that Apple says it is 2X faster on their website. If that's all you're going on then...

I own both the 3G and the 3GS, there is no comparison, the 3GS is MUCH faster.
 
After all that and he STILL isn't happy? I'm thinking he is expecting too much from his phones and/or is only excited by the "newness" of a product and quickly becomes bored.

I shudder at all the money he has thrown away with his ADD. :(

He doesn't have ADD.

He just likes gadgets.

And if he gets a new phone, he's usually pretty good about throwing the old one on eBay, so he makes up the cost (We have 4 lines, he can use an upgrade on any line pretty much, and since we have a FAN discount, and we pay over $150 a month, we get upgrades every year).
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.