Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
69,017
40,052


Apple and Samsung have reportedly issued cease-and-desist notices to Xiaomi in India for an ad campaign that directly compares the rivals' devices to Xiaomi's products. The two companies have threatened the Chinese vendor with legal action, calling the ads "disparaging."

xiaomi-apple-ad-india.jpg

Ads have appeared in local print media and on social media that take pot shots at the competitors' premium offerings. One full-page print ad published in April wished readers a "Happy April Fools' Day" if they believed the iPhone 16 Pro Max's cameras could match those on Xiaomi's recently launched 15 Ultra.

In March, another print ad described the triple lens array on the iPhone 16 Pro Max as "cute" and questioned whether it was "really the best," while touting the Ultra's higher camera specifications and more affordable price. Xiaomi has launched similar ad campaigns against Samsung.

Apple and Samsung contend that the tone of Xiaomi's promotions went beyond fair competition, and portrayed the global market leaders in a negative light. Comparative advertising in India is not prohibited provided they are fact-based and fair, but lawyers can legitimately get involved if the tone and language is perceived as mocking.

xiaomi-ipad-pro-ad-india.jpg

Samsung's promotional jabs at Apple have recently taken a more understated approach. Its ads typically don't call out iPhones outright, and instead spotlight features where Samsung believes it has the edge.

The tech giants' responses to this particular ad campaign indicate just how fiercely contested India's smartphone sector has become. As the country's two leading high-end vendors, both brands obviously see their reputation and market share as vital in one of the world's fastest-growing and most lucrative markets, and intend to defend them using all the legal tools at their disposal.

Article Link: Apple and Samsung Push Back Against Xiaomi's Bold India Ads
 
Last edited:
Apparently not.... Need to step up your game here guys..
This. Sans software support, I understand Apple does extensive testing and certification with it's hardware. However, with this kind of competition coming in fast, Apple needs to start speeding up this process or people in my generation that can actually make confident decisions about investing heavily in high priced hardware will go elsewhere to commit.
 
I see nothing wrong with the Ads. They are not lying, they are just stating specs. The two things that stand out here are:

A) They are doing a direct comparison to a competitor, that typically doesnt work out well for the company. Think McDonalds saying they have better Burger than Burger King.

B) Apple / Samsung are either so bother or it is actually impacting sales in this market for them to take action. The fact that they had to take legal action makes this a win for Xiaomi because we are talking about them so they are get more than their moneys worth for the ad via exposure. Will it be effective in the long run is another issue them.
 
I always think disparaging ads feel like desperation and make me actively dislike that company more. Xiaomi wouldn't even be a company if it wasn't for Apple: where else would they get all their ideas to copy?

This. Being "the least worst" is not a great selling point. If you can't market a consumer product as being good in and of itself, and you have to lean on your product being "comparatively good", you need a new marketing department.

Using the example above, If McDonalds say that they have better burgers than Burger King, they are not actually saying their own burgers are good. And McDonalds then have also made their potential customers think about Whoppers.

"Don't think of a pink elephant"
 
I always think disparaging ads feel like desperation and make me actively dislike that company more. Xiaomi wouldn't even be a company if it wasn't for Apple: where else would they get all their ideas to copy?
They are doing better stuff actually... That we don't care to try it doesn't mean their tech is not better.
Apple hasn't been innovative since Steve died...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.