Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
That is incorrect. The MB and low-end 15" MBP share the same CPU (2.40 GHz, 3MB cache) but the high-end 15" MBP has a 2.53 GHz, 6MB cache CPU.

That is also incorrect. The only the high-end MB shares the same CPU as the low-end MBP (2.40 GHz). The low-end MB has a CPU of 2.0 GHz.
 
When they do eventually bring the 17inch Macbook Pro in line look wise what do you think the chances are of them having a matte display option for it? Also do you think they may keep a firewire 400 on the 17 inch MacbookPro when it's looks are updated?

I doubt it.

I think the primary reason for eliminating the matte display is because there is one piece of glass across the entire front of the display. Matte finish would look weird over the black bezel. Besides the glossy displays are brighter, have more contrast, and really are more accurate because they don't smear the light emitted from the LED backlight.

Firewire 800 is backward compatible with FW 400, so I don't think Apple will add a FW 400 port. If anything they might have two FW 800 ports.
 
I just think they have been concentrating their efforts on the far more popular 15" model, in order to get this out fast. Nothing new there... it's the same as when they switched to Intel chips, right?
True, but the same cannot be said for the PowerBooks back in the day. When the 12" and 17" were introduced, the 15" remained Titanium for eight months.
 
yeah, just don't get one in photography or graphics design unless you're willing to work on Windows from now on.

haha.. aw, that makes me kinda sad. I'm a graphic designer and I've been anticipating this upgrade because I need to get one. I feel like I have little choice but to shell out the money cuz I'm so used to designing on a Mac. And as much as professionals are pissed, it still is the industry standard.

I'm going to have to test the screen out in person to see if it’s tolerable. If not, I might have to work in bright locations less... The color’s not a big deal for me because web stuff is going to be displayed (and thus tested) on different monitors anyway, and for print, we should be sticking to proofs and Pantone for color matching. Can color calibration and perhaps a matte screen protector (weary) be enough for this thing to be usable without a monitor?

I can just see Steve Jobs saying at his next notebook keynote, “We talked to users of the MacBook Pro, and something that people overwhelmingly wanted was a matte display. And now we're giving them that option.” :(
 
I cant stand the people who say "you gripe too much; stop complaining!"

Is it too much to ask for perfection? Apple's always proclaimed they're "different," yet they've proved they now conform to the industry standards. Yes I have a problem with the black screen, the black bezel, the black keyboard. Terrible updates and a step backwards. I've used the anodized aluminum iMac at a school lab and it actually hurt my eyes - didn't think it'd happen to ME.

Also, does Apple not realize that nobody cares if their computer is "green?" They don't care how the computer was manufactured, whether its 1 piece or 1000 pieces. And what a waste of an aluminum block. I wonder how much energy it takes to run their factory? I bet neither are environmental friendly.

I hope Jobs leaves soon because if this is the direction Apple is heading, I'm going to use my same old Macbook Pro for years to come.


i own a alumamac and i think you are overreacting a little here. Sure the glare is a huge and understandable issue for professionals, but i think the case that the black is hard on your eyes is a weak argument. The black keyboard is just a design disagreement, personally i like the black keyboard but hey whatever, no one is gonna say you're wrong about preference.
 
haha.. aw, that makes me kinda sad. I'm a graphic designer and I've been anticipating this upgrade because I need to get one. I feel like I have little choice but to shell out the money cuz I'm so used to designing on a Mac. And as much as professionals are pissed, it still is the industry standard.

I'm going to have to test the screen out in person to see if it’s tolerable. If not, I might have to work in bright locations less... The color’s not a big deal for me because web stuff is going to be displayed (and thus tested) on different monitors anyway, and for print, we should be sticking to proofs and Pantone for color matching. Can color calibration and perhaps a matte screen protector (weary) be enough for this thing to be usable without a monitor?

I can just see Steve Jobs saying at his next notebook keynote, “We talked to users of the MacBook Pro, and something that people overwhelmingly wanted was a matte display. And now we're giving them that option.” :(
judging by the fanatical reaction by these forums i would venture to guess that there will be a revision within months with either antiglare glass/film or a no glass option.
 
i own a alumamac and i think you are overreacting a little here. Sure the glare is a huge and understandable issue for professionals, but i think the case that the black is hard on your eyes is a weak argument. The black keyboard is just a design disagreement, personally i like the black keyboard but hey whatever, no one is gonna say you're wrong about preference.

But in terms of the evolution of Apple portables, the black IS a step back. Does this look familiar?
15-inch-titanium-powerbook.jpg


Apple couldve easily kept aluminum keys, and reduced the bezel. Better yet, make the screen enclosure one piece too, if the "one piece" design is what they are going for.
 
But in terms of the evolution of Apple portables, the black IS a step back. Does this look familiar?
15-inch-titanium-powerbook.jpg


Apple couldve easily kept aluminum keys, and reduced the bezel. Better yet, make the screen enclosure one piece too, if the "one piece" design is what they are going for.

im not saying you're wrong, but personally i like the contrast of the black on aluminum. I think if they had made the keys white it could have been interesting but i certainly wouldn't call the black keys a deal breaker or an issue for that matter.
 
It can. It is not a big deal. For some reason, people are choosing to use this as a scapegoat issue to justify their wait for the next revision, only to find something else to nitpick about.

Sorry, but I've been reading a few of your comments, and I have to say that your opinion here is way off the mark.

I'm going to buy one of these new machines, because I need one. So will most of the other people who think that the stuff we lost from the MBP line is inexcusable.

All of you out there who scoff at anyone who dares to question the wisdom of the almighty Steve need a wakeup call - for a lot of us, these bloody things aren't objects of desire, or commodities, or some fancy way to keep ourselves distracted, or status symbols - THEY'RE F'N TOOLS that let us MAKE A LIVING.

Would you fault a carpenter who was pissed that he couldn't hold onto his hammer anymore because the manufacturer made the handle too slippery? Imagine that the carpenter couldn't work as easily anymore because his fantastically special nails that he relied upon only worked with that hammer, and he found himself at the mercy of the hammer maker's increasingly bad design decisions.

Would you laugh at a bus driver who was infuriated by the omission of a rearview mirror on his vehicles? Imagine that he was stuck driving the diminished bus because that bus's maker also made the superior roads he relied upon to move around. Would he have a right to be upset?

No. Clearly, in your eyes, we should all be happy with the same pretty shiny objects, and stop daring to ask for tools appropriate to our professions from the company that has supplied them to us for so long, and to whom we have invested time, money, energy, loyalty, and evangelism in the past.

I so desperately want to like the machine that I'm about to put myself into debt for, but christ on a pogo stick, I don't, because the very small thing that would be so easy to get right is a very big deal to me when it's wrong, and messes with my professional life for 45 hours a week for the next few years.

Scapegoat my hairy arse.
 
haha.. aw, that makes me kinda sad. I'm a graphic designer and I've been anticipating this upgrade because I need to get one. I feel like I have little choice but to shell out the money cuz I'm so used to designing on a Mac. And as much as professionals are pissed, it still is the industry standard.

I'm going to have to test the screen out in person to see if it’s tolerable. If not, I might have to work in bright locations less... The color’s not a big deal for me because web stuff is going to be displayed (and thus tested) on different monitors anyway, and for print, we should be sticking to proofs and Pantone for color matching. Can color calibration and perhaps a matte screen protector (weary) be enough for this thing to be usable without a monitor?

I can just see Steve Jobs saying at his next notebook keynote, “We talked to users of the MacBook Pro, and something that people overwhelmingly wanted was a matte display. And now we're giving them that option.” :(

I see that happening at MacWorld with the release of the 17 inch, the dropping of the white MB and price drops all around. I also hope that they rethink this education discount, which only gets me 50 dollars off the price of the new MBP (here in Canada, 50 dollar price increase and only 100 dollars off instead of 200)
 
Fair enough.

Everyone has an opinion and where would we be today without whiners. If everyone was 100% satisfied with what lays before us we would still be living in caves and chasing antelope for supper.

That's a mockery of those who still live indigenously, usually with more humility and fulfillment than the common civilized human.
 
Ruined

The colour on the key pad doesn't work, you know mac, leave the key pad the same colour of the base of the mac!, in my opinion they completely destroyed it, like what were they thinking!, i agree glossy pad, come on, they HAVENT used a computer with the windows open and when the sun shines in Hmmph :confused:

Quick thing if you're on a mac and need that :apple:, for a mac book its alt+shift+k  =]] :p
 
All of you out there who scoff at anyone who dares to question the wisdom of the almighty Steve need a wakeup call - for a lot of us, these bloody things aren't objects of desire, or commodities, or some fancy way to keep ourselves distracted, or status symbols - THEY'RE F'N TOOLS that let us MAKE A LIVING.

That post rang true with me! I always thought Mac fans were cultishly obsessive, but when my Powerbook was stolen, I was forced to get a new one and have since been following the rumors closely (dare I say obsessively).

messes with my professional life for 45 hours a week for the next few years.

I realized this is why I'm up at 3 in the morning posting on a mac forum. I literally live on my laptop, whether I like it or not.
 
Didn't think I'd end up with the complainers, but after waiting 6 months for this update (to replace my 1st gen Macbook Pro) I'm not going to bother - I'm going to buy a iMac instead.

2 Reasons:

1. Increased UK price.
2. After all this time, still no hi-res option on the 15. 1600x1080 would have been ideal.
 
judging by the fanatical reaction by these forums i would venture to guess that there will be a revision within months with either antiglare glass/film or a no glass option.

I keep my fingers crossed for a MBPP! ;)
The option for no glass at all would be best. In short, like it was before and with anti-glare coating on the LCD. The black border doesnt bother me.

Glass on top of a screen feels cheap PC and low quality LCD to me.
 
Variety

One thing is for sure mac users cover a wide spectrum. In the past they produced machines which covered all the bases and gave you choice. Forget slim and light it's raw power and flexibility that's needed imho. One of the great bonuses of a mbp was you could do anything with it in the future this justified it's price tag. There is a glimmer of hope for the 17" as it surely has more space. It remains to be seen whether Mr Jobs has the decency and flexibility to offer a matt option. After all he said he had spoken to consumers, what if the consumers spoke to him ? Choice is good it's only a piece of glass for the sake of a little sand blasting or whatever everyone could be happy. The other concern is the growing consumerism in the range. The Mac Pro is the last bastion of the old pro apple ethos.

On a side note why does the mini display port to dual link dvi adapter have 3 tails (ends) one is dvi ,one mini display port and the third ? EDIT apparently it uses USB power as well hmm flexibility compromised again.
 
But in terms of the evolution of Apple portables, the black IS a step back. Does this look familiar?
15-inch-titanium-powerbook.jpg


Apple couldve easily kept aluminum keys, and reduced the bezel. Better yet, make the screen enclosure one piece too, if the "one piece" design is what they are going for.
No Apple notebook that I know of has aluminum keys. As for the bezel, I really don't think they could have literally made the entire upper chassis the display.
 
Well damn...

I was really hoping everything would shift down a price point. I guess "aggressive price points" actually means just the white macbook. Guess I'm saving up for a Pro...
 
What happened to Apple pushing the bar? These are just small tweaks (and several of which make them less desireable to many - glossy screen one of them).

These are essentially the same - same res screen, slightly faster, slightly larger HDD etc.

And who is going to pay an extra $1000 for a Pro to get a backlit keayboard, FW800 and bigger HDD?
 
Wow. I still think some of the complaining is out of hand. I happen to be very happy with the glossy MBP that I have, and it's my first time using a glossy screen. Granted, I don't do photography, so I don't know how true the statements are about inaccurate colors (but it doesn't make sense to me).

I DO agree about the FW port, however (on the MB, not the MBP). I don't udnerstand the decision to remove FW altogether. I'd be ok with all MB(P)s having FW800 only, since a converter is not a big deal.

The black keys - When I first got my PB 12" (1GHz), I was slightly disappointed that the keyboard had no contrast to the machine itself. So, I'd be happy with a black keyboad.

Regardless............ I won't be buying until at least 2009 or 2010, since I cannot justify another computer purchase right now (and I want some next-gen tech, such as Snow Leopard and Core i7).
 
On a side note why does the mini display port to dual link dvi adapter have 3 tails (ends) one is dvi ,one mini display port and the third ? EDIT apparently it uses USB power as well hmm flexibility compromised again.

Yikes. Another way Apple’s pushing you to buy a Cinema Display?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.