Doctor Q said:
That's why Apple should sell products that work with Macintosh computers. Simply selling mousetraps would take them away from their raison d'etre, but selling Mac-controlled mousetraps would add to their presence in both markets.
It's a shaky thing - you have to be careful. I think they did an excellent job with the iPod/iTunes in this regard. PC owners running Windows could buy an iPod and have a great product and a good full-range system for your digital music habits. However, you could get a little more functionality by using your iPod with a Mac - you can sync with iCal and AddressBook too. Now, I know there are several Windows apps that let you do this with Outlook as well but it's not as streamlined as on Apple. I had already wanted to get a Mac and take OS X for a spin, but having my iPod and knowing I could more easily get more use out of it with my Mac was yet another reason that influenced me to buy a Mac.
I think the same approach in the living room could help them. Think about it - what are Apple's biggest products? I really only see two large "concepts" within Apple: 1. Macs and OS X - the ideal, user-friendly, intuitive computing experience. 2. Your digital life - iLife, obviously iPod/iTunes is the largest part of this right now. The Pro apps also ties into this concept on the content creation side. While the digital lifestyle concept has a huge stake in computing it also extends out to the rest of our lives, Apple capitalized on this with the iPod and going into the living room to spread the "iLife" concept further is a good idea.
I think a home setup box is a logical next step for Apple. It could allow you to view your photos and movies, play music, a built-in PVR would be nice as well. Music is always going to be the bread and butter of the iPod. I can't see movie viewing ever becoming mainstream on such a small device - I wouldn't want to do it and from many people I've talked to there just doesn't seem to be much interest. However, as a set-top box in the living room I think it would be marketable and Apple based on their focus and past endeavors seems to be prime for this task.
The key factor to success will be implementation. It will need to be easily usable without a Mac in order for it to be a big success. I agree there should be additional functionality allowed when using it with a Mac to offer incentives for people to switch, but it cannot be critical functionality that will turn people off to the product. Again, if they can do it as well as they did with the iPod I think it would be great.
I think they could release such a device and still stay focused on their core "Apple" concepts. I hope they give it a shot - they are poised well to take this opportunity at the moment, not sure how long it will last. It might fail but if they execute it well the pay off could be huge. Besides, I'd love to see Microsoft get killed in the living room. I think the XBox is a great gaming system and I don't hate MS they have some great technologies for enterprises, but Apple has just owned the "digital lifestyle" market and I want to see what they can do in my living room.