Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Lowest initial cost of investment. Use cloud and/or external if you need more storage.

Also, you never get back that initial investment % from upgraded CPU/GPU/RAM, when you go to sell on the second-hand market/trade-in after a few years.
I see where you are going, is that what you do? We keep our Macs for almost 10 years, so the overall cost is low after buying them maxed out…
 
Since they aren’t really upgradable, who would actually want a base model?
I guess the kind of people who might have bought a heavily upgraded mini since it comes into their sights?

And yes the percentage depreciation is least in the base models if you’re thinking that way. External storage can be added - for lower spec users 32gb is fine and thunderbolt or usb-c attached SSD or even a NAS might cover the difference.
 
I guess the kind of people who might have bought a heavily upgraded mini since it comes into their sights?

And yes the percentage depreciation is least in the base models if you’re thinking that way. External storage can be added - for lower spec users 32gb is fine and thunderbolt or usb-c attached SSD or even a NAS might cover the difference.
Yes, but is that what you do?
 
Since they aren’t really upgradable, who would actually want a base model?
Unlike some other Apple base models, the base Studio has quite a respectable spec. It really should have 1TB SSD as standard, but 512GB is OK if you're just going to use it as the systems/apps/current project drive and add external.

There's a lot of advantages over the M1 Mini quite apart from the extra CPU/GPU/Codecs - number of I/O ports, support for 4 external displays - and not everybody actually needs more than 32GB of RAM (c.f. 8GB on even the top-end iMacs!)
 
Yeah, I can believe that. But it is one of the loudest Macs of the last ten years during idle.
...but, so what?
I've had plenty of Macs that were silent during idle but sounded like a hoover as soon as they were under any sort of load. Having loud fans starting and stopping is way more distracting and annoying that the continuous, slight white noise that the Studio emits, even under heavy load.

Faulty units that whine are another issue entirely.
 
...but, so what?
I've had plenty of Macs that were silent during idle but sounded like a hoover as soon as they were under any sort of load. Having loud fans starting and stopping is way more distracting and annoying that the continuous, slight white noise that the Studio emits, even under heavy load.

Faulty units that whine are another issue entirely.
Coil whine is the factor that might make me reconsider a mac studio. The M2 in a mini enclosure might even be louder or hotter than an M1. I really do value a quiet working environment and so do Apple it would seem.
 
Unlike some other Apple base models, the base Studio has quite a respectable spec. It really should have 1TB SSD as standard, but 512GB is OK if you're just going to use it as the systems/apps/current project drive and add external.

There's a lot of advantages over the M1 Mini quite apart from the extra CPU/GPU/Codecs - number of I/O ports, support for 4 external displays - and not everybody actually needs more than 32GB of RAM (c.f. 8GB on even the top-end iMacs!)
A heavily BTO mini vs a stock mac studio might have different used values later too.

The upper SKU 14/16 inch MacBook Pro with 1tb would be a popular upsell in my book. Similarly for mac studio if offered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christech
I was thinking of buying a Mac Studio until I read these comments. I had no idea it had a constantly running fan. That would drive me nuts in my small, quiet space. I'll wait until that's fixed or there's a better option from Apple.
The quietest option appears to be an M1 mini. An M2 would run hotter but we don’t know if it would reuse the same case and if the fans would probably run more in any case.

For people budgeting for the mac studio there is also a 14” MacBook Pro that could be used as well, assuming m1 pro is adequate.
 
I see where you are going, is that what you do? We keep our Macs for almost 10 years, so the overall cost is low after buying them maxed out…
For my desktops/main used machines, I usually only keep them ~3 years, i.e. 2014 Mac mini->2017 iMac Pro->2020 M1 Mac mini-> 2022 Mac Studio.

For laptops or devices that I don't use daily, I typically keep those longer (usually until the OS is no longer supported), and/or I pass them along to family members if I see something "new" from Apple that is interesting i.e. M1 MacBooks.

My use case is not typical. Tech is a hobby for me, so I admit to 'upgrading' more than the average user :)
 
I was thinking of buying a Mac Studio until I read these comments. I had no idea it had a constantly running fan. That would drive me nuts in my small, quiet space. I'll wait until that's fixed or there's a better option from Apple.
I've never heard the fan on my Mac Studio M1 Max, even sticking my head close. I'd recommend listening to one at a store.
 
...but, so what?
I've had plenty of Macs that were silent during idle but sounded like a hoover as soon as they were under any sort of load. Having loud fans starting and stopping is way more distracting and annoying that the continuous, slight white noise that the Studio emits, even under heavy load.

Faulty units that whine are another issue entirely.
That seems to be a topic of personal preference. I don't render videos 80% of the time or compile some code or export huge bunchs of photos. But I do all of that and I would be perfectly fine if the Mac Studio would get to its current default 1315 rpm when it does one of those things. The Mac Studio doesn't sound "like a hoover" at 1300 rpm and this seems also to be enough for 95% of things you can throw at it. So why run it at 1300 rpm all the time and not only when it is necessary?
I've never heard the fan on my Mac Studio M1 Max, even sticking my head close. I'd recommend listening to one at a store.
Congratulations, either you'r room is louder than 25 dB or your ears are not able to hear it at the distance where you have placed your Mac Studio.
I can't recommend listening to anything at an Apple Store if you have the intention of finding out if something is loud or not. Apple Stores are busy, there are talking people, there might be music playing. Often they are in busy shopping centers. In those places it is most definitely louder than 25 dB you will find out nothing by sticking your ear anywhere in a store.
 
This is actually good for anyone looking to buy and get a Mac Studio without the long wait. The M1 Ultra models when bought new won't arrive until September, whereas you can get it refurbished for $400 off and have it by next week July.
Huh? How is something not yet available to buy available as a refurb (which would mean someone already bought it new and returned it)?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christech
Tim Cook will tell you "Don't worry we've got a solution for you, the whine issue will be no more when you buy our Airpods Max at the low price of $550. We think you're gonna love it."
That whine will be no issue at all when you buy our Apple iPlugs

09CAF30A-1C73-4944-AE65-91F91E356098.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christech
I've never heard the fan on my Mac Studio M1 Max, even sticking my head close. I'd recommend listening to one at a store.
Impossible to tell in a store tbh, far too much background noise, needs to be in an acoustically treated room. A friend of mine just bought one and says he can hear it whine, though it doesn't bother him, it would me however.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ElectricPotato
An alternative view is for 10% off you're getting a Mac (or whatever) that's been pushed though more quality checks than anything you might buy brand new. It's pretty much guaranteed to work unless it's damaged in transit.
Sad state of affairs when buying something new can no longer be considered “pretty much a guarantee to work”.
 
It is like the noise electric cars make - gives you a warm fuzzy so you know it is there - and maybe won't trip over it. Now if they can adjust the whine to sound like a TIE Fighter - and a whole group of Apple fans will be thrilled. :)
They can add it to their Benz EQS, which sounds like a pod racer.

 
I have a Studio (not the Ultra). It doesn't whine. It's silent and speedy. Love all the ports. Best Mac I've owned in ages.
How old are you (no offense)? My dad 69 (no joke) can’t hear the beep the microwave makes. He’s not bad of hearing, just certain high and pitched sounds with monotonous curves he can’t register…
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.