Did you even watch the keynote? I bet you didn't...
Lets see:
-Browsing on par with 4G speeds from a 3G phone.
HSPA+ has been available on Android phones since February (maybe earlier)
-Amazing power and great battery life.
Isn't it the same battery life as before?
-Siri is honestly cool (which is funny because I thought I'd never use it).
...Google/Android has had voice actions and voice recognition for over a year
-New and improved camera.
Its still a cell phone camera, no matter how Apple tries to spin it. Physical limits on sharpness due to sensor size.
The best thing in IOS5 are the notifications that they stole from a competing OS.
How is that not a good improvement? How did Apple blow it? I hope you realize technology doesn't evolve as fast as Macrumors readers think it does.
Hey, I am no Apple fan, but I will give the company credit where it is due.
The hardcore hipsters and trend-followers that have made up Apple's core demographic have had to endure 1+ years of their phone *not* being the most advanced phone on the market. Even when it was announced, the iPhone4 was already not the most powerful phone available.
The current incremental upgrade (after ~16 months) is a letdown for people who were hoping to buy the latest, coolest device from Tim Cook & Company.
I was saying months ago (during antennagate) that the iPhone was no longer the 'cool' device to own. I guess it has taken this long for many Apple fans to begrudgingly admit that that might be the case.
Objectively, there is nothing wrong with the iPhone 4S..... but playing 'catch up' and suing their closest competitors (Samsung) are making people take a hard look at what else is available.
Just sayin
People expect too much. If you want something amazingly better go invent it.
Lol, well.... if you do manage to invent something better, then Apple will sue you over some BS patents or "community design".... so that advice won't work.
Apple's own fault. They hype up the marketing, point fun at the competition and claim that their stuff is the best in the world. It is only just that they reap the whirlwind when they don't deliver.