Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
With great marketing, you can sell anything. And Apple has great marketing. I have seen so many free advertisement for Apple its ridiculous. News program advertising for Apple pretending that its news. Lots of popular shows doing product placements. And don't forget all the A list celebrity endorsements. Its going to be a record number of sales, and for a phone that's anything but magical.
 
The only issue here is whether or not they intentionally held back product that was ready to sell just to make a "hot spot" on the nightly news. I guess we should all believe that Apple had an infinite supply of iPhone 5's available and no matter what, they should have been able to accurately gauge their sales and produce enough in advance to meet demand. But instead, they turned away millions in possible profit to make a point.. do you seriously believe what you are saying? I'm not saying such a practice is never done, of course it is. But there is a MAJOR difference between holding back some stock vs turning away millions of dollars in potential sales while the product is still very much on everyone's lips.

Take note: According to TechCrunch, the iPhone 5 sold out TWENTY times faster than the iPhone 4 or 4S. Did you also predict that would happen and Apple was faulty in not predicting this?

People don't seem to understand that manufacturing a product in volume like this takes a lot of time, and there's not that much time before launch to actually manufacture all that many. Apple's rollouts are some of the largest and fastest of any product, but they are restricted to the same laws of physics and economic realities as everyone else.

A product needs to be designed, prototyped, tested, and then manufactured in bulk. You can spend a lot of money on designing and prototyping, since those are costs you only have to pay once, but a production model has to be made sufficiently cheap, and that means economies of scale have to catch up with what you want to do, on every component of the product. If you only get one usable chip on a wafer for a new process, you can't make millions of iPhones with that chip. You have to keep working at it, until the chip yields are acceptable. This takes a lot of time, so production model products can't be made in bulk and at the right price point until close to when you actually want to start selling the thing. If you wait too long, somebody will make a similar product for much cheaper, or a better product at the same cost.

It's just not realistic for Apple or any company to ramp up production on a new product for a long period of time before they start selling it. There's no reason to keep them in warehouses, no reason at all. You have to pay for the warehouses, and you lose demand by selling an obsolete product when you finally go to sell. You try to build up just enough supply to meet initial demand, then as it becomes cheaper and cheaper to make and demand drops off, you can safely reduce the scale of your manufacturing.

These things have a definite window. If Apple were to spend more time manufacturing ahead of release, people would complain about obsolete technology and not buy it. If Apple manufactures in lower amounts, nobody can buy the product and they spend their money elsewhere, plus Apple can't take advantage of the economies of scale. Apple has to figure out where the window is, predicting variables that are far from being easy to predict. Apple gets it mostly right because clearly Apple is very profitable, but they're not perfect. Perhaps they could have made more iPhones available in this release cycle than they have, and they would have all sold. But Apple would have to spend more money to do so. This is one of those areas where it's not such a bad idea to be a little bit conservative in your sales estimates. This time, I would argue Apple was too conservative since they sold out so quickly, but it's difficult to say since we don't know how insanely high the demand has really been. What might have seemed perfectly reasonable at the time was clearly not enough. For all we know a hundred million people want to buy the iPhone in the first week. I doubt that, but we just don't know yet. All this is pointless speculation until we get hard figures maybe on Monday.

I don't blame Apple for not being able to accurately predict how successful they've become. Their rise since the 90s has been nothing short of astounding. Could anyone have really expected Apple would be doing as well as they're doing?
 
With great marketing, you can sell anything. And Apple has great marketing. I have seen so many free advertisement for Apple its ridiculous. News program advertising for Apple pretending that its news. Lots of popular shows doing product placements. And don't forget all the A list celebrity endorsements. Its going to be a record number of sales, and for a phone that's anything but magical.

You don't need marketing when you establish yourself and make great products. It's just an excuse the haters like yourself make to explain why Apple is so successful.
 
F it. I just sold my 4S and bought a Samsung S3. So far I'm impressed and content its going to be better than the 5.

I've bought Apple since I was 20 (i'm 39 now) and bought the first iPhone the day it came out but I think they've dropped the ball with this one.

If you really feel that way, why didn't you look into the windows phone? They are far better than any android IMHO
 
Last edited by a moderator:
lol, we all knew of the manufacturing issues they've had, and as I called a few days ago, they would use that to spin their sales...

I don't doubt the 5 is selling VERY well, better than the 4s however?

Not a chance, not a chance in the world.

Are you for real buddy?
Anyone who has been following Apple knows exactly what to expect, & year after year they have been bettering their sales from the iPhone.
saying that the 5 is not surpassing the 4s is plain stupid. Wait until Monday when they announce the over the weekend sales.
 
Apple loves it when people blow them...away. I'm sure someone is swimming in a big pool of money like Scrooge mcduck right now.

- sent from my iPad 3/ iPhone 5 / iMac / MacBook pro / MacBook air

Tell them I said they're welcome lol c:apple:
 
All the posts I saw about how people hated the iPhone 5. And if all the leaks were true then nobody would buy this phone. This article proves otherwise, and all those people are truly Apple fan boys/girls no matter what product Apple releases. Slaves I tell you....Slaves! This also goes along with all the people who threatened to leave AT&T when the phone was released. Again...people are so fake sometimes.

Don't take this as me trolling. I would buy the phone too if I could afford the $450 early upgrade fee. However I never claimed to hate the leaked iPhone 5, or to leave AT&T because they are evil bastards.

:apple:
 
Are you for real buddy?
Anyone who has been following Apple knows exactly what to expect, & year after year they have been bettering their sales from the iPhone.
saying that the 5 is not surpassing the 4s is plain stupid. Wait until Monday when they announce the over the weekend sales.

Exactly. Yeah, because apple is going to lie about it now when they're going to release sales figures later. They're a publically traded company!

----------

I'm blown away by how much people obsess over a freakin phone.

Said the person who spends his Friday nights on a Mac forum. People obsess over guns, too. A gun forum would solve your problem.
 
Possible, but I doubt it

The fact that it was sold out in an hour just means supply was less than demand. If they had 2 and got orders for 3, it would be sold out. It has nothing to do with record-breaking sales figures, yet at least. The initial supply just might have mean a lot less this year. This is no information until they quote actual pre-order unit sales. :rolleyes:

For all we know, Apple might have just held back supply to purposely say they were sold out in hour for publicity. I'm not saying that's the case, but it's possible. :)


Considering they will likely report #s at the rumored iPad mini Launch next month. They will want to report big #s and that wouldn't be possible if they lowballed the stockpile at launch.
 
The iPhone 4S had sales of 4 million over its first weekend[sup]1[/sup], and 1,00,000 pre-orders[sup]2.

The iPhone 4 had sales of 1.7 million over its first weekend[sup]3[/sup], and 600,000 preorders[sup]4[/sup]

Foxconn apparently makes ~140,000 iPhones per day[sup]5[/sup]

Pre-orders appear to be limited to the 25-30% range. If you were to accept Apple will approximately twice as many iPhone 5s as iPhone 4S’ then you’re talking 8 million units. At 140,000 units per day (that’s 1.5 phones every second) Apple would need 57 days of manufacturing to meet first weekend demand. The rumors the iPhone 5 went in to production started in mid-to-late July giving them almost exactly 60 days.

Of course Foxconn could have increased the rate at which iPhones are produced since 2010, and the iPhone 5 could have gone in to production earlier than mid-July. It’s also possible the iPhone 5 production rate is slower because it’s so new, and the mid-July date was wrong, and it was August. It’s also possible the first weekend sales won’t double those of the iPhone 4S.

Having an Industrial Engineer for a father though, I have a decent understanding of how they think. I suspect those numbers aren’t far from the truth. The iPhone 5 started production in mid-July. Apple will have 8 million of them available for sale next week. One-quarter to one-third of those were reserved for pre-orders.

If you think the overall production for the first weekend, or the limit to pre-orders is in anyway driven by marketing you simply have no idea how a factory is run. Does marketing take advantage? Sure, but the number of devices and the pre-order limits are set by capacity, simple as that.




1. http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2011/10/17iPhone-4S-First-Weekend-Sales-Top-Four-Million.html

2. http://www.apple.com/pr/library/201...Orders-Top-One-Million-in-First-24-Hours.html

3. http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2010/06/28iPhone-4-Sales-Top-1-7-Million.html

4. http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2010/06/16Statement-by-Apple-on-iPhone-4-Pre-Orders.html

5. http://www.tuaw.com/2010/09/15/report-foxconn-making-1-5-iphones-per-second/

Most informative post of this whole thread, thank you.
 
Exactly. Yeah, because apple is going to lie about it now when they're going to release sales figures later. They're a publically traded company!

----------



Said the person who spends his Friday nights on a Mac forum. People obsess over guns, too. A gun forum would solve your problem.

Haha good one!!! But I'm sick at home and looking up information on the iMac cuz I NEEED to have one for my job. So it's not quite like that sorry...
 
The word "innovative" has lost all its power over me. I mentally delete it from all hype. Using your post as an example, what I read is:

"Lumia 920 is more <marketing term> smartphone. iPhone 5 is disappointment in terms of <marketing term>."

It's such a vague word, and I don't know what most people mean when they use it.

That's OK, most people who use it don't know what they mean.
 
I have heard a few people who had ordered through the apple store already seeing a transaction on their credit card, for those of you who ordered through verizon's website, have you seen any transaction yet on your credit card or have a tracking number?

I ordered from apple.com and my card has been charged, and my order is preparing for shipment :cool::D

----------

I ordered the iphone through Apple's website at 12:04 am, and it is processing my order. The phone has been charged to my visa account which means the order went through and hopefully will be shipped in time to arrive on September 21. :D

I ordered at 12:02 AM and my order changed to preparing for shipment :p:cool:
 
You can make the same statements about the Galaxy S3 vs. the S2. What really changed? The screen went from big to huge, the CPU evolved, and they added some eye candy.

Let's face it. Big changes even in technology are relatively rare. Evolution is the norm. Mobile phones in the 1980s were bricks that made calls. In the early 1990s they shrank down and became affordable. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, they settled on the candy bar design. Then RIM came along and added enterprise e-mail. Other "smartphones" followed but it took Apple to make it mainstream. I think we've reached the point where the smartphone will just evolve until someone, be it Apple or someone else, takes advantage of some up and coming technology. But at some point, the next big thing requires a new category. PCs changed significantly between 1980 and 2000. However, in the last 12 years it's been mostly evolution. They are smaller, cheaper, and faster, but the basic design of our desktops and notebooks has been pretty much the same. It took a new tablet category altogether (epitomized by the iPad) to shake things up. Microsoft is trying to push the category along further, but again it is more an evolution of the tablet.

I don't know what comes after smartphones. Maybe it's Google with their funky new glasses. Maybe it's a company we haven't heard of yet.

In the meantime, expect refinement from Apple and Samsung, and whoever else remains in the industry. iPhone 5 is a good refinement. They are late to the LTE party, but they were also late to the 3G party back in 2008, and for good reason. LTE chipsets are a lot more refined than they were 12 months ago and suck up a lot less battery. Plus we have significantly better coverage of LTE than 12 months ago. For as much as Samsung is mocking Apple in advertising right now, you can bet you'll see many of the same refinements in the SIV (Cortex A15 chip, newer chipsets, better battery life, perhaps a thinner design).


Well stated. At the rate in which technology is moving forward at this pace, most of the phone improvements will be evolutionary rather than revolutionary. There is so much you could improve upon the existing technology. Larger screen? Well, too larger and it turns into an ipad. Thinner Phone? Well, there is a limit to that as well unless you want to wear your phone on your wrist or around your neck, which may not be a far-fetched idea in the future. Faster microprocessors and higher resolution screens? Yes, for now, that will be the trend. One thing many seem to miss is that as long as there is profits to be made with the existing technology, Apple or any other company for that matter, will not introduce new technologies even though they may already exist. This explains why Apple's approach to innovative technology is incremental.
 
Not hard to be blown away there at apple, seems they're really over thrilled with themselves as of late. Believe me love the products, ordered the 5 last night blah blah but man that keynote. Lets say Steve is very missed. Cook seems like a good guy but oh boy all the overemphasis on the talk pattern and the rest just acting like every little thing was like introducing the second coming is over the ****ing top now. I can see how android fanboys think we are douchy at times however IMO they do make the best products in the world still
 
This is true. Every year it's going to be harder and harder to top the numbers and when they don't everyone will be screaming that it's the end of Apple.

I think having 2 earnings "misses" is actually helping the process. If you had bought after July's earnings release, you'd be sitting on a 20% return in 2 months. Some more "misses" like that and maybe Tim Cook and Peter Oppenheimer will convince analysts that their estimates are realistic now.
 
All the posts I saw about how people hated the iPhone 5. And if all the leaks were true then nobody would buy this phone. This article proves otherwise, and all those people are truly Apple fan boys/girls no matter what product Apple releases. Slaves I tell you....Slaves! This also goes along with all the people who threatened to leave AT&T when the phone was released. Again...people are so fake sometimes.

Don't take this as me trolling. I would buy the phone too if I could afford the $450 early upgrade fee. However I never claimed to hate the leaked iPhone 5, or to leave AT&T because they are evil bastards.

:apple:

FYI nobody cares
 
And I'm literally amazed (whatever that means, "literally" is not really appropriate to use in that context) that some people simply don't understand that it can be tough to predict the popularity of products that dwarf EVERY OTHER PRODUCT IN THE HISTORY OF THE PLANET EARTH.

Ten years ago, Apple was practically dead.

Today, they are THE MOST VALUABLE CORPORATION ON THE PLANET.

THEY ARE WORTH MORE MONEY THAN THE OIL COMPANIES.

THE IPHONE IS BY FAR AND AWAY THE BEST-SELLING CONSUMER ELECTRONICS DEVICE IN HISTORY.

APPLE MAKES MORE PROFIT THAN ALMOST ANY OTHER COMPANY ON THE PLANET.

APPLE MAKES MORE PROFIT OFF OF THE IPHONE THAN EVERY SINGLE OTHER CELLPHONE MANUFACTURER COMBINED.

This is all coming from a company that was nearly out of business a hair over a decade ago, and wasn't even in the cell phone game until 5 years ago.

Most of their executive management has been at Apple THAT ENTIRE TIME.

Yes, I do believe they can be genuinely "blown away" by their repeated, and GROWING, level of success.

I guess we'll have to disagree.

I know I'm blown away. It remains to be seen if I'm blown away by the iPhone 6th gen's sales numbers, but I'm certainly blown away by the speed they sold out the first batch.
 
Are you for real buddy?
Anyone who has been following Apple knows exactly what to expect, & year after year they have been bettering their sales from the iPhone.
saying that the 5 is not surpassing the 4s is plain stupid. Wait until Monday when they announce the over the weekend sales.

It likely won't be this weekend since they can't technically count them as "sales" until they deliver the product, but it's almost certain they will have a press release a week from Monday.
 
? Who cares. The number sold means that people for whatever reason stayed up that night or got up this morning and placed their order. It doesn't matter if they already had an iPhone, had an android, are white, black, asian, male , female, christian, tall short etc.

That's like saying if your platform already has 80% of the market, and 100% of those folks upgrade to the latest model, but it fails to capture 2% of the uncaptured market, then it's a failure. It would be a failure if NO ONE bought it.

Well it matters quite a bit when you want to consider growth. Without growth a company becomes stagnant and that leads to failure. Isn't the whole point to capture more of the market??? Try to look at the larger picture here instead of the hyped up immediate numbers (which can easily be skewed with little effort) that simply do not mean anything by themselves. I never even said it was a failure to begin with.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.