Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This whole LG farce is why Steve never put the wellbeing of his company in the hands of a third party.

Hardware before any smart hole mentions apps.

Good point, but I think Apple has such dislike toward anything without a planned obsolescence that they just don't want to touch displays. If they did, then people would start asking for other things, like new computers to go along with them. Nobody needs that headache. :D
 
Ugh. Wish they'd just make a killer 5k standalone Apple display. Seriously. This has been ridiculous.

I really believe that getting out of the display businesss was probably for the worse. I know it's a very low-volume business for them but at the same time, they were selling a 1080p monitor for $1000 when you could buy a 1440p or even a 4K of good quality for considerably less. No wonder the sat and collected dust at that point.

Apple isn't perfect, they've had their fair share of "oops" moments, but I don't think anyone of them even approach the ridiculousness of the LG display fiasco. And if one was, they certainly were quicker with rectifying the issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck and iMi
I really believe that getting out of the display businesss was probably for the worse. I know it's a very low-volume business for them but at the same time, they were selling a 1080p monitor for $1000 when you could buy a 1440p or even a 4K of good quality for considerably less. No wonder the sat and collected dust at that point.

Apple isn't perfect, they've had their fair share of "oops" moments, but I don't think anyone of them even approach the ridiculousness of the LG display fiasco. And if one was, they certainly were quicker with rectifying the issue.

The monitor for 1000$ was 1440p.
 
  • Like
Reactions: svendobbelaere
Apple should have never stopped making the Cinema Display. Quality control goes right out the window. How hard can it be? Just release a 5k IMac without the computer. They are halfway there. I really don't understand why Apple handed over such a huge component to home computing to an outside company. The LG display doesn't even look like an Apple product. I don't know about y'all, but I want my Apple MacBook Pro to aesthetically match my external display. It's just so un-Apple like to mix & match like this. Boo!
 
Don't devices like this have to pass some sort of FCC tests for radio interference before they can be sold in the US?

If so, how did this get past testing and certification?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck and marty11
I really believe that getting out of the display businesss was probably for the worse. I know it's a very low-volume business for them but at the same time, they were selling a 1080p monitor for $1000 when you could buy a 1440p or even a 4K of good quality for considerably less. No wonder the sat and collected dust at that point.

Apple isn't perfect, they've had their fair share of "oops" moments, but I don't think anyone of them even approach the ridiculousness of the LG display fiasco. And if one was, they certainly were quicker with rectifying the issue.

You make an interesting point. But the reality is that low-volume business for Apple still means 100's of millions or more in business. It would certainly generated sufficient revenue to justify having the staff dedicated to it.

Plus, if Apple was still Apple they would care more about the user experience. The Apple of yesterday would say "we have engineered this new display to give users the ability to experience the new Mac Pro the way it was intended." Today it seems like they are more interested in selling us watch bands and dongles. Lots of dongles.
[doublepost=1486686292][/doublepost]
Don't devices like this have to pass some sort of FCC tests for radio interference before they can be sold in the US?

If so, how did this get past testing and certification?

Excellent question!
 
Why echo the same things over and over? Complaining about the bezels does nothing productive and that's all anyone ever says.

It's easy to hate on products you have no intention of buying. I've never used this display but from what I hear it's pretty darn good.

Whoa there trigger - first time I've ever mentioned that!... and I am exactly the market for this sort of thing as a VFX / animator. In fact I recently bought 2 of these...
http://www.philips.co.uk/c-p/BDM3275UP_00/brilliance-4k-ultra-hd-lcd-display-with-multiview
for less that the price of one of the LGs... yeah I know that has 1 whole K more but cost / use * need and all that..

Point is with the LGs they are incredibly chunky and when you can 2 together the middle is basically a 5cm black line and do they really need to be? My 4K LG OLED TV has 5mm bezels.
[doublepost=1486686647][/doublepost]
This whole LG farce is why Steve never put the wellbeing of his company in the hands of a third party.

Hardware before any smart hole mentions apps.

Well in all fairness they only promoted this as a 5K monitor you COULD buy as it has the right connectors... it's not like they "put the wellbeing of his company in the hands of a third party."
[doublepost=1486686837][/doublepost]
The Apple Cinema display bezels were much larger... like the top bezel all the way round.

They were... 10 years ago when they were released...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck and robeddie
Why did Apple get out of the display business anyway? Even if it wasn't as profitable as other parts of the business they are involved in the display game with their laptops and iMac's so why not continue to make stand alone models? They could have avoided the embarrassment of all of this. I didn't get the decision to end the airport line either. If people want to pay the Mac tax on displays and wireless routers then let them.
 
Gonna keep my display for another week till the end of it's return window then request a replacement I guess. Apple should've never gotten out of the display game. What a debacle.

Or the prince game for that matter.
 
If that's not a reminder of the potential health hazards of the radiation eminating out of a router sitting on your desk one foot away from you, I don't know what is.
As a household of multiple computers/devices it would never occur to me to put my router next to a user instead of the optimal coverage location. I guess lonely guys have more to worry about than I realized.
 
Why echo the same things over and over? Complaining about the bezels does nothing productive and that's all anyone ever says.

It's easy to hate on products you have no intention of buying. I've never used this display but from what I hear it's pretty darn good.
From someone who has used the display, it sucks if you can't use it within six feet of a router.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mkeeley and Huck
Why echo the same things over and over? Complaining about the bezels does nothing productive and that's all anyone ever says.

It's easy to hate on products you have no intention of buying. I've never used this display but from what I hear it's pretty darn good.
Do you like the bezels?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck
How close is "too close" to the router? Is the interference gradual with distance, or is it an all-or-nothing?

Someone should run experiments!
 
This is Tim Cook's Apple people!

Yep, marketing said "do it!" and the employees did it, for better or worse. It seems to me that Cook loves the thought of Apple making excellent products, but doesn't know enough about high-tech products to lead the team to actually achieve excellent products. Thats why he was a great supply chain guy. Now even that is failing Apple.
 
Do you like the bezels?
Nobody really does, but some of us understand the need - many who whine about bezels would also whine when something hits the edge of their display/phone/ipad and the entire display shatters.
[doublepost=1486692487][/doublepost]
Yep, marketing said "do it!" and the employees did it, for better or worse. It seems to me that Cook loves the thought of Apple making excellent products, but doesn't know enough about high-tech products to lead the team to actually achieve excellent products. Thats why he was a great supply chain guy. Now even that is failing Apple.
Yes, because the CEO is the guy soldering motherboards and designing the dimensions and components of every product....

smh some people don't understand business or technology.
 
Come on Apple, get to your senses and make your own displays again. It will sell well. Don't stop focusing on the Mac and peripherals. Airport back will be welcome too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CE3 and Huck
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.