Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Everyone is evil! I'm gonna throw away all my computers, and go live out in the woods!

I think this whole "x is evil" thing is getting way out of hands. Unless Apple, Google, or MS are actively killing orphans, and grinding up their souls to power their cloud platforms, I wouldn't call any of them evil. Cheesy? Sure. Occasionally creepy. Why not? But evil? Nah.

Nice imagery.
 
I couldn't help noticing how little you just said.

And who is not evil according to you, oh one of great wisdom.

I am not evil. Does that answer your question. In fact, I am magnificent. I am pure as the driven snow, an angel. A snow angel. ❄ #
 
Everyone is evil! I'm gonna throw away all my computers, and go live out in the woods!

I think this whole "x is evil" thing is getting way out of hands. Unless Apple, Google, or MS are actively killing orphans, and grinding up their souls to power their cloud platforms, I wouldn't call any of them evil. Cheesy? Sure. Occasionally creepy. Why not? But evil? Nah.

How about "morally deplorable"? At least with Apple if you're happy to play nice in their walled garden, they treat you as a customer not a product.
 
How about "morally deplorable"? At least with Apple if you're happy to play nice in their walled garden, they treat you as a customer not a product.

Google leans a little more towards the creepy end of things, but I wouldn't go so far as to call them morally deplorable.

It's like I've always said around here, Google is more a hopped up Nielsen demographic generator on steroids than they are a Big Brother wannabe.
 
According to plaintiff attorney Patrick Coughlin, a user who downloaded music from a competing music service to iTunes and then tried to sync the content to an iPod would receive a nondescript error message. The vague message would advise the iPod owner to restore the device to its factory settings, deleting the music that had been downloaded from a rival service and preventing it from being played.[/url]

Title: Apple Deleted iPod Owners' Songs Downloaded From Competing Music Services Between 2007 and 2009

Corrected Title: iPod Owners' Songs Downloaded From Competing Music Services Between 2007 and 2009 Didn't Sync to Their iPods
 
Only Apple apologists would let Apple off the hook for this. Next, you'll be saying the owners of these iPods should apologize to Apple for buying music from places other than iTunes. :rolleyes:
 
So, why would it sync something to the Ipod that's not even in the Itune library on the computer? I am missing something? Does this crap even make sense?

Everything worked EXACTLY as it should. Maybe the user being dumb as a brick should be noted in the court proceedings.

BTW, If I put songs on my Iphone outside Itunes (yes, there are ways...), I don't expect Itunes to put them back on if I sync devices!!! It doesn't even know these songs exists!!!
 
What?? My dad had an iPod. Almost none of the music on it was from the iTunes Store, of course. This problem never occurred.
 
Only Apple apologists would let Apple off the hook for this. Next, you'll be saying the owners of these iPods should apologize to Apple for buying music from places other than iTunes. :rolleyes:

Did you even read what's purported? Are you an apologist for commenting after only reading headlines of articles?

----------

What?? My dad had an iPod. Only about .01% of the music on it was from the iTunes Store. This problem never occurred.

Even if its not from the Itune store, you usually still use Itunes to sync it. In this case, who knows how those songs got on the phone; seemingly didn't use Itunes...

My songs all came from ripped CDs and no issue at all.
 
These comments are wimpy at best.

People don't seem to get it. Why should Apple have let another company into its ecosystem.
If I own a grocery store, you can't come in and tell me you are going to put your stuff on my shelves! And if you do, I would most certainly throw you and your stuff out on the curb.
After Apple wins this, and they will, I hope they take each an every individual in this sham of a class action to court and sues them into abject poverty.

haha....the true American way. :)

Actually it's more like me purchasing a bag from your store, going home and filling it with items I bought from your competitor's store and then you taking those items out and trashing them.
 
Did you even read what's purported? Are you an apologist for commenting after only reading headlines of articles?

----------



Even if its not from the Itune store, you usually still use Itunes to sync it. In this case, who knows how those songs got on the phone; seemingly didn't use Itunes...

My songs all came from ripped CDs and no issue at all.

I read the article. It's Apple doing what it's always done: locking you in to its services.
 
Actually it's more like me purchasing a bag from your store, going home and filling it with items I bought from your competitor's store and then you taking those items out and trashing them.

Except that if you actually read what happens. That's not what happens. The anology doesn't fit at all BTW.

- It is more like selling a special key-chain on which all the keys are exact copies of master keys kept in a special file. Then, someone adds keys on that key-chain without putting into the file and loses that key-chain and expects the key replicator to replicate keys it doesn't have.
 
Kind of a misleading title... its not like Apple went in and deleted those specific songs without the owner knowing (essentially like hacking). The iPod was restored, which coincidentally erases the entire contents of the iPod.

A distinction without a difference, I'd say.
 
What am I missing? Didn't the record companies express concern over iTunes/ipod etc making it too easy to pirate music? so apple tightened up the itunes "ecosystem" to control and contain music in general. Not to block competition but to protect copywriter of the music companies?

AND I agree title is very misleading, i like when macrumors reports on facts AND rumors mentioned by others but don't start your own rumors or ill set up a site called "MacRumors, Rumors" :)
 
There are audiobooks and music that I can not play from the cloud or store. The only place I have the files is on my computer now in drm format.
 
These comments are wimpy at best.

People don't seem to get it. Why should Apple have let another company into its ecosystem.

Ummm... if you bought an iPod, it belongs to you to do whatever you want with. It's not licensed software, and it's not a service. You own it, legally. It's not part of Apple's ecosystem, except in the sense that it is compatible with some other offerings of Apple. It's 100% your personal property, and if you want to run other software on it's your business. Apple can void your warranty, but that's it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.