It’s overpriced for what it is, $200 for a underclocked 2016 processor is absolutely laughable, it has absolutely horrendous battery life even for just listening to music, it is using an outdated design from 2012, it’s the only iOS device in the lineup without at least an A13, it’s the only iOS device still available without any form of biometrics, and it’s very, very hard to justify its existence anymore.
I’ve heard people use the excuse that “well kids love it for gaming,” but that excuse falls apart immediately the second that you bring up the budget iPad that’s only an extra $129 with a screen almost 2.5 times the size, a battery life that’s at least quadrupled, and gaming/CPU performance thats much, much further ahead.
Not to mention you can easily go on eBay and find an iPhone 7 or eight for cheaper than this with better specifications, bigger screen, better speakers, faster processors, much much better battery, Touch ID.
It literally has absolutely no reason to exist other than that Apple can say “look guys, the iPod still exists” while doing absolutely everything they can to hide the fact that it exists.
After the October Keynote, they literally made it harder to fine, completely removing the tab. You have to go into the footnotes to even find it.
So in summary, it’s horrible for kids because it has a terrible battery life and A tiny screen with horrible gaming performance so there’s not much actual gaming they can do, it’s horrible for music lovers because you have to pay $400 to actually get it with 256 GB, and even then the battery life is so terrible that you’re better off just getting a used iPhone, and it’s horrible for anyone else because if you need just an extra device that’s not your phone, the budget iPad exists with a much faster processor, much, much, much and I cannot emphasis enough, much better battery life, not to mention that the 4 inch screen in 2021 is just cramped.
Add on top of these things the fact that it has an absolutely horrendous front facing camera, a back camera from the iPhone 5, and The fact that it’s probably only gonna get another year or two of software updates, and… it just needs to go.