My sympathy to those of you who were denied. I just got back home after going to the Apple store earlier. I had this web page/thread opened up and had also made some specific notes of buzzwords like "GSX" and Juanito23's repair label of "Problem Description: Enclosure - REP Display coating (MBPr)". I explained to the reps that my MacBook was out of warranty but that I was under the impression that this problem was being treated beyond the normal warranty period. Much of this was told to the first Apple rep who has the job of taking some preliminary notes and getting my MacBook's serial number.
I repeated some of this to the 2nd rep who came out to actually discuss/diagnose the issues, and I'm not sure if anything I said had any real impact. Regardless, he saw the issue and quickly told me that I would be covered. He added the disclaimer of the possibility of them finding signs of other damage (e.g., water damage) when they take it apart. I'm pretty confident that there isn't any damage of that sort, though I don't know why that would impact the repair of the issue at hand (the anti-reflective coating on my screen).
He told me that they're currently inundated with a ton of other repairs and the estimated turnaround time would be 5-7 days. Because of the upcoming long break I didn't want to be without my MacBook that long, so I opted to come back on Sunday to drop it off.
I'll add that there is still one issue that I'm concerned could cause me some grief...About 2 months ago I developed a horizontal line across the middle of my screen. It's very faint and I've worked around it, but to be honest, that line is a big reason why I was very interested about this screen repair getting covered. I first noticed the anti-reflective coating issues probably over 2 years ago, and was too lazy and indifferent about it to rush to the Apple store (about 30 mins away) even though I had read MacRumors earlier post about that issue being covered. Had I moved quicker to get my screen repaired I suspect that the horizontal line issue wouldn't have appeared (I'm assuming that issue is related to a defect in the display and not a defect in the main board of the MacBook), so I don't feel guilty about (hopefully) getting that out-of-warranty defect fixed. But now I do worry that when I drop it off and someone goes to do the screen replacement, if they notice it, might they note it as a non-covered defect that somehow disqualifies me. At this point, I'm fairly optimistic that because they've already "approved" me, that it won't matter.
Anyways...good luck to everyone else who has been turned down...hopefully you can fight it and get your repair approved.