Not the smartest way to do a money grab, since it's relatively easy to confirm if there's lying involved or not?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Facing Lawsuit After AirPods Allegedly Ruptured Child's Eardrums With Amber Alert
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
LOL If I was doing it now maybe plugs would make a difference but this started 25ish years ago.
If you're a 14 year old with a 100watt amp you dont think, hey could this damage my ears. You think, THAT DRUMMER WILL NOT BE LOUDER THAN ME 😂
Really mature to make fun of such an incident...
Well since a Child's scream is on average 120 db, I pray they dont have a crying/screaming sibling who is also causing permanent damage to their hearing.
I rolled my eyes after reading “he will continue to live a diminished life into the future, including a diminished earning capacity.” How exactly will hearing loss in his right ear lower his earning potential when he becomes an adult?
Could actually be a benefit. Nagging wife, "sorry honey I didnt hear you" 😊
All these members quoting figures of approx 150 to 165 db required to burst ear drum are actually qutoing figures for adults. The CDC have done tests and the WHO (World Health Orginization) that say children should not be exposed to a peak sound pressure of 120db
https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/hearing_loss/toolkit/quiz-test.html scroll to the bottom of the page.
Question is, is 120db within the operating spec of air pods because if it is then an amber alert at full strength could damage a childs hearing.
https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/hearing_loss/toolkit/quiz-test.html scroll to the bottom of the page.
Question is, is 120db within the operating spec of air pods because if it is then an amber alert at full strength could damage a childs hearing.
After looking into this, the WEA alert volume is set by the government, it is not a function of the device or the headphones. Unless they can prove the AirPods effectively did not work as intended, IE the AirPods ignored the WEA volume guidelines and caused the alert to be sent at a higher volume... This one is going to be tricky for the plaintiffs. I do feel badly for the kid, this is something that shouldn't happen but whose fault it is, is open to interpretation
Valid point. Thing is though, the airpods are simply incapable of generating enough airpressure to actually rupture an eardrum.
They specifically claim that it ruptured the childs eardrum. That is a different claim from merely making a very loud noise (which, incidentally, isn’t good for anyones hearing).
I don't know if "on average" is what I would use. 120dB is more on peak levels according to anything that I could find, here is a study for a pediatric facility in which the two highest were 114dB and 116dB. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30865703/
Remember sound level changes a lot based on distance, a child may scream at a peak of say 12dB (just because that is the number you gave) but even just 5ft away will be a less amount. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/inverse-square-law-d_890.html In the example in the link above a rile was used and recorded at 134dB at 1.25ft, even just 5ft away it dropped to 122dB.
The earbud is directly in you ear so pretty much as close as sound can get along with the tip creating the seal. You can look up "amber alert airpod" and there are numerous complaints that the alerts are just too loud especially since you are already wearing earbuds why does the alert need to be so loud to begin with? I am not trying to prove that the Amber alert caused this child to have permanent issues in one ear that is the job of the lawyer and data. I imagine they would have audiology test results and whatever else. If anything comes out of this lawsuit, I hope it is the ability to turn down alerts not just "off" or "on" and no ability to adjust the volume, because sometimes the connected bluetooth device is airpods and sometimes your car
Before looking at news articles on Google, I guessed that it was going to be either Florida or Texas. Yep, it's Texas.....
yes there is a reason for them to be loud, but the alerts are so much louder and I am assuming they are peak volume which is not needed. The alert system needs to be changed to be a different volume when connected to bluetooth devices for audio. I understand the phone being really loud because it may be in your pocket or across the room and wouldn't be as loud. When you are listening to your audio through car speakers, earbuds, headphones, etc. it is a piercing sound
Yikes. I've been using my airpods a decent amount lately. Just shut off all the emergency alerts.
same here! I couldn't find anything searching the FCC rules besides frequencies that the various alerts need to be on
I don’t know, but as you know that media volume and notification volume are two independent volume settings. I believe the default for Amber alerts etc. is to play at max volume, period.
Yes. Hopefully it our lifetime. That’s be great.We need to cure tinnitus, especially the kinds that are truly intrusive (I have three sounds but out of them just one is freaking me out large parts of the day).
Like I've said before I think it would be awesome if Apple could get involved in research for solving hearing issues and tinnitus – if nothing else to get more customers to be able to enjoy Apple Music more, which likely means they'll get more subscribers.
The more I’ve opened up to others about tinnitus the more people that I find out that have it. There’s a number of people that actually have it really bad. People that I know very well. But they’re completely happy and live a good life. People like that help get me through. It’ll be ok.