Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Seems like he must have given them his phone to get this data. Anything else is very strange as Apple made it clear with the San Bernadino shooter they wouldn't give user data away anymore.
Yes, if you click through to the article, toward the bottom it says he gave the police permission to access the phone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Captain Trips
There is no mention anywhere that he had an Apple Watch, just the iPhone. Why are so many commenters talking about what the watch would record? The phone doesn’t record steps as accurately as the watch does so that could explain why so few steps.
 
18 steps is impressive, I know my Apple Watch has recorded more than 50 steps while I have been sleeping, it is called tossing and turning, it has even recorded it as standing a few times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: motulist
I know. This story just makes me very uneasy. What if someone in my house is murdered at 11pm, and I happen to be using the bathroom at the same time as the murder? Then police can say “you took 16 steps at 11pm” or whatever. With all this data, I feel like more mistakes could be made.
Yeah you could be hit by lightning twice also, find something else to be uneasy about. Or not
 
Lol just as I thought we have a thread full of armchair lawyers second-guessing a 3-year trial based on a 20 second article. Adorable as always
 
Incorrect conclusions have been happening from day one and it will keep happening, unfortunately.
Yea it’s not like this was the smoking gun. It simply re-enforced other evidence found at the crime, like the fingerprints. Regardless of steps, it shows that he lied.
 
I know my watch isn't 100% accurate. I get steps when I am not walking and do not get steps when I am. I've gotten standing congratulations without leaving my chair.

Also, there are a lot of bottles in my house with my fingerprints on them - not just the Rum - the other stuff too.

I really hope there was more to this case than that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: motulist
There was a case here of a woman accused of killing her mother in law that went to trial last year and data from an apple watch was used as part of the prosecution evidence. The accused alleged her MIL was followed home by three people, they stood outside arguing for 20 minutes and they then killed her and tied up the accused. The apple watch data contradicted that version of events as it showed when she died which was soon after arriving home, not later as the accused said.
Ultimately the jury was hung and it will go to retrial later this year so it clearly didn't sway them one way or the other, but with more smart devices capable of biometric data collection being used perhaps it will play a big part in future court cases.
 
I've woken up with hundreds of steps before. Either I toss & turn a lot, or maybe it's not quite as accurate as we might like to believe...
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaRev
Where is End to End encryption promised for health data?
PS no wonder. no encryption - only marketing.
You're kidding, right? All the encryption in the world can't save you entirely from physical access. If someone wants into something, they'll get into it.
 
All the encryption in the world can't save you entirely from physical access. If someone wants into something, they'll get into it.
Well, no, that’s sort of the whole point of encryption.

if you’ve learned otherwise, this guy will probably be happy to provide physical access:

 
I was suspicious of the 18 steps. I figured that could be explained by moving in your sleep, rolling over, etc. I just checked in the Health app and my watch recorded steps on my watch 5 times while I was asleep last night: 49, 8, 16, 6, and 9 steps. I looked back a few days and every night it records a few steps. I'm guessing this is very common and certainly doesn't prove someone was awake.
I think you just admitted to committing 5 murders last night.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rjp1
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.