Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
To

Comparing hardware specs on 2 completely different operating systems is like comparing two movies in completely different languages.

I don’t hate windows, but comparing hardware specs and pricing is moot if the OS experience is so different.
See that's where you still sit and don't realize time has passed by. MacOS is nowhere near superior or diffrent to Windows. When it was OS X, yes I would agree with you. Apple has not really done anything to MacOS to make it seem a better choice in a long time and Windows has come a long ways where they use to be. The only thing really differentiating Apple from Windows Ecosystem is, 1.(not saying it is worse, but pretty much everyone has caught up with them.) the hardware, which I think it's obvious, Apple is no longer the top spot and 2. you got so sucked into the Apple ecosystem with services etc etc that it would be really hard to ever get away from.(This i am saying is actually a bad idea.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mendota
I've had two Apple laptops (a Pismo and a 12" PowerBook) from the early 2000s fail, and two grater MacPros fail (one a G5 and one Intel) from the mid 2000s fail.

Since Tim Cook became CEO every piece of Apple gear my family owns (laptops, iMacs, Watches, HomePods, iPhones, iPads) has been working perfectly. From my anecdotal experience there's been an increase in quality control.
Sure perhaps in your case, but overall the quality control has gone down in particular the past few years. I'm not even referring to Tim Cooks leadership.
 
Apple runs a trillionaire class business. I run a thousandaire class business. I think they are doing well without me.

I have no idea what it is that could be wrong with this model since we have only seen about three of them. It is too new. The fact that the programs are now coming out before the machines have been out for a year is frightening.
What’s frightening is your lack of logic (and btw since there’s only a small number of affected machines, you may _never_ see one).

It may be as simple as this: Apple has identified a marginally under-spec part (or one that’s less reliable than it should be) based on failure tracking. Could be 500, 5,000 or 50,000 affected, Apple knows based on manufacturing records. If a part that shouldn’t fail in 20 years is failing in a month or two, that’s a problem. A repair program instituted as soon as the issue is identified is the exact _opposite_ of frightening, whether at six days, six weeks or six months.
 
Last edited:
What’s frightening is your lack of logic (and btw since there’s only a small number of affected machines, you may _never_ see one).

It may be as simple as this: Apple has identified a marginally under-spec part (or one that’s less reliable than it should be) based on failure tracking. Could be 500, 5,000 or 50,000 affected, Apple knows based on manufacturing records. If a part that shouldn’t fail in 20 years is failing in a month or two, that’s a problem. A repair program instituted as soon as the issue is identified is the exact _opposite_ of frightening, whether at six days, six weeks or six months.
What’s frightening is your lack of logic (and btw since there’s only a small number of affected machines, you may _never_ see one).

It may be as simple as this: Apple has identified a marginally under-spec part (or one that’s less reliable than it should be) based on failure tracking. Could be 500, 5,000 or 50,000 affected, Apple knows based on manufacturing records. If a part that shouldn’t fail in 20 years is failing in a month or two, that’s a problem. A repair program instituted as soon as the issue is identified is the exact _opposite_ of frightening, whether at six days, six weeks or six months.
In that case Apple should have simply stated what you just did and no one would be worrying about a keyboard-like fiasco.
 
I'm not going to carry a dongle around for every missing port in anticipation that I might need one. Nobody does that. I don't even care about the cost.
What's so good about having ports you need an adaptor to use in nearly every situation? The only useful thing about USB-C so far is charging.

I don't care about nostalgia. The new ones look like Dell Latitudes. They're not ugly, but they're not an improvement. Just cause it's new doesn't mean it looks better. Lit up logo was way cooler than the awkward metal thing they have now.
This is all your opinion. A lit up plastic logo is classier than a polished aluminum logo? Common now. It’s nostalgia to some people and you’re one.
No idea why anyone would think the 2016 design looks bad. The 2015’s look dated but hey it’s all your opinion.
Don’t like it don’t buy it. Buy old technology for the next 10 years cause you hate buying a few new cables.
 
It's really weird that they don't say what the issue is. Seems like they'd have *something* in their system...like a failed diagnostic code or common symptom of the failure. Or do they feel like replacing any logic board for free?? Consumers certainly won't mind but I think the shareholders would lol...
 
My wife’s computer had this exact issue just recently. In fact, Apple already has it to fix. They told her she was crazy and there was nothing wrong with it. It kept randomly shutting off, plugged in or on full battery. Then it was really hard to turn on again. They said it passed all their scans and was fine. She insisted on leaving it with them overnight, and it finally happened again when she went to pick up “because there was nothing wrong with it.” Then they admitted an issue and sent it for repair. Was very frustrating and unusable. Glad to see some info on this come out.
 
It's really weird that they don't say what the issue is. Seems like they'd have *something* in their system...like a failed diagnostic code or common symptom of the failure. Or do they feel like replacing any logic board for free?? Consumers certainly won't mind but I think the shareholders would lol...

Per the article, there’s a serial number range of the affected machines:
When the serial number of an affected MacBook Air is entered into Apple's internal repair system, a message will direct technicians to replace the logic board.
[doublepost=1561949855][/doublepost]
In that case Apple should have simply stated what you just did and no one would be worrying about a keyboard-like fiasco.
The fears of the Apple-hate crowd at MR forums are not nearly so easily allayed. Of the dozens and dozens of complaints, “concern” and negative posts, there have been what, two or three actual 2018 MacBook Air owners?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zdigital2015
I have used several MacBooks since 2008 and the only model I have ha problems with was the 2016 MacBook Pro. On the second visit to the local genius bar here in Australia they swapped it with a new 2017 model. I have yet to have a bad experience with Apple service.
 
Yep, others just have the problems and let people get screwed if out of warranty. From what I've seen, Mac hardware is about as reliable as others, not better or worse.

no better or worse is not good enough, given the price quality should be superior. It used to be. Mac prices held so much longer than PCs and lived longer too AFAIK. new MBs are on repair programs day 1.

I am losing a lot of confidence in Apple. My 2016 MacBook has had constant problems - randomly restarting, disk with question mark, etc.. and I have taken it in to Apple care several times and they never find any issue.

I think this is my last Apple laptop until they fire Cook or they make a new reliable design. I use Apple for reliability not headaches. Otherwise I will go back to Windows. I have no intentions to pay $1.5K-2K machines to deal with failures.
 
And Apple has an SVP of hardware engineering for what then? Is he just a seat warmer in the board room?

j8pjit.jpg
Pretty much....or we wouldn’t have so many iterations of the crappy butterfly keyboard.
 
Yeah, it's always a "smaller number."
[doublepost=1561966929][/doublepost]
It’s not just MacBooks... even the iPads are developing white spots all over the 10.5 screen.. Chinese junk. Apple refuses to acknowledge it too. Unreal.


Interesting. I haven’t heard of that until now. I returned my iPad mini 5 because of a number of display issues. In a nutshell, my iPad mini 4 had a much better display. I sampled quite a few other iPad mini 5s in the local stores and they were all the same. Quality shouldn't go down with new products.

So I put a new battery in my iPad mini 4 myself, which restored full performance and battery life. Since iOS 13 is likely the last iOS version that will support my iPad mini 4, I’m good for at least a little over a year. Will see what Apple does then. Hopefully the mini will be updated again by then with a better display.
 
Last edited:
Pretty much....or we wouldn’t have so many iterations of the crappy butterfly keyboard.

Mistakes happened under Steve Jobs but never over and over again for the same thing. Apple has really gone downhill. The extremely overrated designer is now gone, thank God, now Tim Crook needs to go.
[doublepost=1561967367][/doublepost]
What’s frightening is your lack of logic (and btw since there’s only a small number of affected machines, you may _never_ see one).

It may be as simple as this: Apple has identified a marginally under-spec part (or one that’s less reliable than it should be) based on failure tracking. Could be 500, 5,000 or 50,000 affected, Apple knows based on manufacturing records. If a part that shouldn’t fail in 20 years is failing in a month or two, that’s a problem. A repair program instituted as soon as the issue is identified is the exact _opposite_ of frightening, whether at six days, six weeks or six months.

It's always a small number of affected users with Apple. What that really means are only the customers that will notice, care, or bring it in on time to repair.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mendota
Does not surprise me, these days Apple has become pretty lame with their desire to hide everything that even smacks of a problem.
You wanted privacy, now you have it.
Seriously though, I agree. All companies cover things to a degree as do individuals but some of their 'covering' is tantamount to lies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PC_tech
y
The logic board has failed two times on my MacBook (2015). Apple won’t replace it without charging me $400+. I have a brick now because I won’t pay that price. I’m so disappointed in Apple. I’ve never had so many issues with a MacBook before. And this isn’t counting the audio and keyboard issues as well.

you might want to give Louis Rossmann's NY repair shop a try, he has a huge YT channel, and if he can fix it, the fix might even be more permanent, e.g. larger capacitor, re-soldering instead of pressing rubber pad, and details like that
 
Rossmann is almost as annoying as people calling other people “sheep”.

Comments on Rossman's YouTube videos are just the worst kind of echo chamber I've ever seen. People incapable of making their own educated opinions.. they've just seen a YouTuber critique Apple products and just regurgitate the same crap. It's a total dumpster fire.
 
Comments on Rossman's YouTube videos are just the worst kind of echo chamber I've ever seen.

Rossman's profession means he gets a very skewed picture of the quality of the products he repairs. By definition all of the products he is working on have problems. I work in tech support and have done so since the beginning of the '90s and my impressions of my company's products are that they are a pile of crap. This being caused that very few customers tend to call in to say that product XXX has been very stable. You only come in touch with problems and that tends to colour your view of them.

I am not sure a lot of Rossman's viewers realize this.
 
See that's where you still sit and don't realize time has passed by. MacOS is nowhere near superior or diffrent to Windows. When it was OS X, yes I would agree with you. Apple has not really done anything to MacOS to make it seem a better choice in a long time and Windows has come a long ways where they use to be. The only thing really differentiating Apple from Windows Ecosystem is, 1.(not saying it is worse, but pretty much everyone has caught up with them.) the hardware, which I think it's obvious, Apple is no longer the top spot and 2. you got so sucked into the Apple ecosystem with services etc etc that it would be really hard to ever get away from.(This i am saying is actually a bad idea.)
If you say so ‍♂️
 
You wanted privacy, now you have it.
Seriously though, I agree. All companies cover things to a degree as do individuals but some of their 'covering' is tantamount to lies.

This is completely different than privacy. Privacy is about customer's information, this is lies about Apple's devices owned by customers, which because they own the device now have a right to know about design and manufacturing flaws that prevent the device from delivering what the purchaser purchased.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.