Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Agree.... More bad money invested after bad. Let's be honest here. Even respected artists like Madonna are far past their prime. It's not really a "big deal" that she's signed on with Tidal. How many more hugely successful albums do you really expect her to put out?

And in the bigger picture? Why such an African-American hip-hop/rap heavy slant to Apple Music? Is nobody out there except rappers or former rappers who run today's music industry?

Maybe it's not the "politically correct" thing to say it ... but even the "Beats 1" streaming radio station Apple does has the overall feel that it's catering more to a young, urban audience who favors rap/hip-hop than anything else.

As someone who grew up listening to classic rock and continued liking the album-oriented rock, "progressive rock" and even "glam metal" along with heavy metal and much of the grunge scene, plus a lot of "alternative rock" and some punk -- I feel like my interests are better represented on many of the SiriusXM satellite stations than on Apple's music service.

Obviously, I'm not implying you can't find these types of music to download or stream on Apple Music. They have lots of variety. There's just this feeling that the people in CHARGE of the whole ball of wax don't care much about any of that, except for the fact it still makes money.


Another bad purchase....Tidal is barely a blip in the streaming world.
 
Never heard of Tidal. But wow ok, it's a good move for Apple. Luckily for me, I don't care about any of those artists to care whether the deal goes through or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tonyr6
All I can think: "White men can't jump"


Way to make it racial, not to mention that doesnt make sense. I mean who failed to win and is about to sell out here here?
[doublepost=1467399594][/doublepost]By the way I think this is a bad business move. Tim. Cooks. Apple.
 
So this is how it goes now Apple? Instead of using bank to innovate be a fat lazy cat, buy up the competition, bite off more than you can chew and make up the expense with lazy, half-conceived products that infuriate us? Beats headphones acquisition lead to phasing out the headphone jack, a streaming service that feels like its still in beta phase and a very rocky iTunes. Try improving your core products and services before pretending like you can handle more.
 
Last edited:
Wow! Apple executives must really love RAP music! They are investing massive amount of money in anything related to this music style.

It's kind of interesting to think that many of these artists have written so much homophobic or sexist stuff.

Before you comment on my post, let me say I don't dislike RAP music or the RAP culture. It's just not favorite.

Hey buddy. People don't have to like the same thing that you like. Based on your language you must be a RAPPER too! Cause that's what they do. They are motivated by hate. They hate da police, they hate women, they hate LGBT, and they also hate each other. Calm down my friend. One day you will also become a mature person (or old as you said) and you will realize that hate is not a good thing.
[doublepost=1467333840][/doublepost]
You don't understand sarcasm...

Based on your posts, it's obvious that dogwhistle racism is your preferred language.

I keep forgetting that the average age of iPhone owners and the MR forum is like 16.

Yes, only 16 year olds like a three decade old genre. These young whippersnappers, I tells ya. Next, you'll be telling me some nonsense about this newfangled "punk rock" the kids are listening to.
___________________________________________________________________________
Anyway, this would be a good thing if only for fact that the amount of streaming services with exclusive access to content would be culled down to just one, making things less confusing for consumers.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: thefourthpope
This has nothing to do about being a good purchase or bad purchase, it's all about acquiring competition and growing user base. Essentially this is a horizontal acquisition.
 
sure, I am the only person on this planet who complained that's why they redesigned it after one year



Russian, really? of all languages? I can't even stand the sound of it when they talk. can't imagine listening to them sing :p
It helps being Russian :p
 
I don't see how this can make money for Apple. Almost all of the Tidal performers are past their prime. I don't think the Tidal catalog can be worth enough for the purchase.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
There are so many FREE options to listen to music and a few pay options, that it's probably correct to say music growth has flattened.

If that is the case then Apple was truly negligent buying Beats Music just two years ago when the downward growth trend would have been apparent then. But, in fact, Spotify has been acquiring more and more paid subscribers every month this year so far as CD sales dwindle. That doesn't suggest slowing growth for the industry. Apple Music has had a bumpy start. Pandora's catalog is thin as is Amazon's. But those are company specific problems, not industry-wide warning signals.
 
Spotify will eventually burn itself out anyway if they can't figure out a way to actually make money. Not sure why everyone gives them so much credit. Apple Music would eventually beat them out through attrition regardless.

I think this is more of a move to acquire exclusives and possibly Jay-Z himself for Apple Music.
 
They did commercially in the 2000's but hip hop and rap are all but dead now and what's left has transitioned into dance incarnations. The kids listen to EDM these days. Rock will resurge before rap does.
Quite frankly I used the term RAP generically, because sometimes it's hard to tell what kind of music they are playing. Is it hip hop? Is it Dance? Nevertheless a lot these guys claim that they are RAPPERS. Two examples
Based on your posts, it's obvious that dogwhistle racism is your preferred language.



Yes, only 16 year olds like a three decade old genre. These young whippersnappers, I tells ya. Next, you'll be telling me some nonsense about this newfangled "punk rock" the kids are listening to.
___________________________________________________________________________
Anyway, this would be a good thing if only for fact that the amount of streaming services with exclusive access to content would be culled down to just one, making things less confusing for consumers.

Not really. You are reading too much into my post. Were you personally offended by it or do you just disagree with it and felt the urge to attack?
 
Tidal has a web player like every other service. Apple buys them then you are forced to use that POS iTunes. No thanks.

what if part of the redesigned apple music includes a web interface? for me, that plus tidal exclusives like prince would be amazing.
 
There is a school of thought that says Apple should buy Tidal, not because they need them. But they should so no one else would. Right now Tidal is a pain in Apple's arse because artist sign exclusives that they believe should have went to Apple Music.

Your thoughts?
 
You would be gobsmacked to know just how few people care about "quality sound."
While I agree with you that people do not care about quality sound I wonder if Apple will push lossless to justify the move to lightning headphones with built in DACs. It's a bag of crazy but how else will Apple justify a move like that with zero benefit to the consumer?
[doublepost=1467442033][/doublepost]
Whatever happened to "Think Different"? This is a serious question, not just a dig at Apple. As a 25 year Apple user and a lover of the 1984 commercial concept, how did the company move from "Don't just be like everyone else" to "Acquire all the brands that we think are cool!"???

I really think there has been a monumental change in fundamental DNA of the company that is Apple under Cook. They're getting embroiled in political issues, slobbering over celebrities & allowing others to do the innovation for them.

IMO, they are still riding the wave that was put into motion by all the years of actual revolutionary technological dreaming, but it seems the vision has been replaced by someone who's pushing their own affection for Hollywood.

It's like when Looney Tunes transitioned from hand-drawn animation to digital creation. It still claimed to be Bugs Bunny, but it was just never the same creativity.
I think Apple is doing a tremendous job of appealing to a very young audience while simultaneously stripping itself of the older loyal base of users as well as any professional users. They can make more money this way.
 
MQA could be a key factor here. I have a Meridian DAC and the sound quality of the limited number of MQA tracks I have is VERY good. Tidal is reportedly converting their catalog to the MQA format and is expected to offer MQA streaming in the near future. If they're acquired by Apple I would hope that Apple would continue with this plan as well as offer the iTunes catalog in MQA as well. It would probably not be hard to put a MQA DAC into a lighting adapter and/or lighting headphones. Audiophile sound from Apple - I think Steve would approve...

I agree. MQA is a cool idea, too bad many people (at forums/discussions) still don't get it and many companies (for their own reasons) still don't endorse it. This could change if Apple decides lossless is the way to go. I really hope Apple gets in the game and doesn't just use Tidal for getting exclusive artists I don't really care about. While Beats acquisition made no sense at all, Tidal could benefit both Apple and customers.

On the other hand, Apple being Apple, they might do it to just to catch Spotify and lock the API to Apple products or commercial solutions (i.e. the usual lame Windows port or the boring Android player).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jhwalker
I hope they do not plan to make Apple Music "HD". It should be common sense that it's useless. 16-bit 44.1 KHz is enough forever. Lossless maybe, but it should have much greater compression ratio. Do they just want me to waste my data faster?
 
I think Apple is doing a tremendous job of appealing to a very young audience while simultaneously stripping itself of the older loyal base of users as well as any professional users. They can make more money this way.

Yup! That is exactly it. Once the young audience moves to the next thing Apple will be out of tricks and out of money. Maybe Jay-Z will be CEO for a while...long enough to get the company delisted from the market. Dre will be CFO (he'll spend all the money thats left) and they'll get Eminem to replace Eddy Cue. WWDC 2020 will be off the hook! Lil Wayne could be the director of marketing!
 
I don't see how this can make money for Apple. Almost all of the Tidal performers are past their prime. I don't think the Tidal catalog can be worth enough for the purchase.

Tidal has the same catalog as everyone else. The clear value would be the lossless streaming infrastructure and possibly their announced move to MQA encoding.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.