Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Because Apple needs to expedite their "record breaking" iOS 7 adaption headlines. So they've lowered themselves to using extortion tactics.

Not that most people aren't already on iOS 7, but it seems rather sleazy to force it on people (who don't want it) when it certainly doesn't seem necessary.

There could be another reason. My understanding is that they wipe the phone and run test software on it. They then need to put new software on it and since the system does not support falling back to previous versions of IOS they have to put the latest version.
 
I wonder about the volume buttons, also. I had to have my iPhone 5 replaced because one of the volume buttons stopping functioning. It occurred about a month after iOS 7 was installed, but of course this was a coincidence.

It so happened that I had given the iPhone 5 to my daughter, having just replaced it with an iPhone 5s. That's the way our family does things. I get the best and greatest; my wife and daughter get my hand-me-downs.
 
I've had two iPhone 5's replaced for this very issue. It's the only problem I've had, but still. Quite annoying since I live a ways from an Apple store and need my phone every day. It's actually the only reason I bought AppleCare. I'm sure there were probably others like me who did the same thing and now we've subsidized Apple's replacement program. Yay.
 
18 months into my 5S and no issues. Use it every day. Too much.

Never had a home button issue, either (iPhone 1G, 3GS, 4, or 5). Lucky?
 
Great, now how about the poorly-designed home button on previous models? Easy for a tech to replace but not for Joe Sixpack.
 
Another possibility is that Apple might run a standard set of tests on the device while it is being serviced, and their test procedure could include updating it to the latest OS.

This is most likely. They do the same with display replacements. The software is calibrated for each model running the most updated software so they require you to update then as well.
 
One of my friends' iPhone 5 did exactly this.

What I need for myself though is a new Lightning Port. After plugging it in, I now have to pull the plug sideways for my iPhone to charge...

And now I can't update to iOS 7.1.1 without doing a lot of cleanup on my 64 GB because even though the update is 18 MB, I need 930 MB free to update OTA. If I do it via iTunes, it "proposes" me to put all my purchases on my iPhone, which would take an additional 3GB that I don't have, and I don't have a button to refuse the proposal and just skip to updating iOS.

I wouldn't mind if the Q/A department did a better job, both on software and hardware side.

GET A NEEDLE AND AND BRIGHT LIGHT AND CLEAN OUT THE LIGHTNING PORT, THIS HAPPENED TO MINE AND IT WAS JUST GUNK BUILD UP STOPPING THE PLUG FROM GOING ALL THE WAY IN AND CLICKING. Sorry about the CAPS, noticed to late and am not typing it all over.
 
Did you have to make a Genius appointment, or just walk in?

Always an appointment. Yeah you could get lucky with a walk in but why make the drive and risk it.

----------

I gather since Apple is recalling these, then its NOT due to a simple software update fix..

For some of these folks it could be wear and tear and not an actual defect. But apple can't really tell the difference so they will score PR points with some folks and resort it anyway

----------

I would like to know what constitutes a recall vs every just returning their phone to get it fixed ?

This would be covered under APP correct ? So, why not ? so Apple suspects that its big enough for a recall..

Recalls generally require every unit to be returned even if there have been no symptoms of a problem. And are generally confined to safety issues.

If the issue was exploding or leaking batteries due to a faulty batch that would be recall worthy

----------

I can't see how this is news.

Manufacturer offers free repair of faulty items that are due to manufacture.

1. It's Apple. Apple gets page hits

2. If it's just a small number of units they wouldn't be so broad. They would know exactly when this bad batch or two was manufactured and it would be more like a month or two tops. Like say all the serials from the launch week supply and first round of restock. They are covering very iPhone 5 that has gone out of warranty most of which were likely fine at manufacture and just wore out from excessive banging, got dropped etc

----------

I would call 1-800-MYAPPLE and ask if they'll refund you for the repair.

Third party parts put in by someone that isn't authorized. That's not a repair that's tampering. DIY like this voids all rights to service. Last thing you want to do is call Apple (and FYI it would be 1-800-APL-CARE, other number is for sales) where they can get your serial and file that you admitted to doing it so all the stores know to refuse to touch your phone
 
Because Apple needs to expedite their "record breaking" iOS 7 adaption headlines. So they've lowered themselves to using extortion tactics.

Not that most people aren't already on iOS 7, but it seems rather sleazy to force it on people (who don't want it) when it certainly doesn't seem necessary.

Actually, their internal diagnostic software requires iOS 7.
 
For those in the UK:

1. If you purchased your phone from Apple, you can have it replaced in an Apple store from next Friday, if you make a Genius appointment.

2. If your phone came from a mobile phone company, you can take it to a branch of that company and see what they can do for you. Under statutory warranty, you're covered for 2 years, so they can't complain (well they can, but stick to your guns).

Personally, I had my Genius appointment today (my phone came from a telco) and had he printed a work authorisation document. With this doc, I was told that starting from next Friday I can have my phone replaced by Apple under the sleep/wake quality program.

One good thing with Apple in the UK is that they will not send off your phone for repair and give you a loaner, they will just replace the phone itself with a new one there and then. I should then be able to restore from iCloud in-store and they can wipe device with the defect.

Hope the above helps other people :)
 
So wait if you have AppleCare+ should you not bother with this? My phone is eligible but has no or very few symptoms. But since this program and AC+ expire at the same time, it seems like it would be worth doing whether you keep it or sell it.

I can't tell if it's iPhone 5's that are out of the one year warranty or if it's some other factor. I bought mine in January 2013, and my boyfriend got his from T-Mobile in September. His isn't eligible. No way to tell if it will be later.
 
Or maybe because the tools they have aren't for the outdated iOS 6??

Logic, not even once.

back at ya :D

anyway I'd send it in with iOS 6 if I wanted to keep iOS 6. If they can't deal with a mechanical button issue with iOS 6 on they'll either send it back as is or update it.
 
My serial qualifies. Assuming my wife's does as well. Both are launch day iphone 5.

But both of our buttons are fine. The being with out the phone for a week is ridiculous. Swap it with a refurb and let me move on. Hopefully the button doesn't break before I get my new phone in the fall because I'm not sending my phone in for repair.
 
Think it started well before that. I had problems with my 3GS and 4S replaced the buttons myself. Unfortunately it has always been the weak point on the Iphone.

Agreed as far it being a weak point. I know several people that have had this problem. Usually the spring underneath goes bad.
 
GET A NEEDLE AND AND BRIGHT LIGHT AND CLEAN OUT THE LIGHTNING PORT, THIS HAPPENED TO MINE AND IT WAS JUST GUNK BUILD UP STOPPING THE PLUG FROM GOING ALL THE WAY IN AND CLICKING. Sorry about the CAPS, noticed to late and am not typing it all over.

Yup. Apple store techs actually use the SIM tool for this. It's the perfect shape & size for degunking the lightning port.
 
My serial qualifies. Assuming my wife's does as well. Both are launch day iphone 5.

But both of our buttons are fine. The being with out the phone for a week is ridiculous. Swap it with a refurb and let me move on. Hopefully the button doesn't break before I get my new phone in the fall because I'm not sending my phone in for repair.

It'll be 2 weeks for me, that's unacceptable but I don't want the button breaking on me later.
 
What great news!....

Except I just sold my iPhone for far under market value, a week ago, for this exact problem. The serial number qualifies too. Ugh, very frustrating.
 
After being told this repair was out of warranty and that Apple didn't do button repairs in Apple Stores, my only "official" option was to replace my whole phone with a refurb unit for ~$250.

That seemed really excessive just to replace one component (flex cable) that's dirt cheap.

I went to an unofficial Apple repair shop to get it fixed for $70.

I wonder if Apple will accept refunding this. I doubt it which kind of pisses me off :/.

I'll still give it a shot given that it says "If you believe you have paid for a replacement due to this issue, contact Apple regarding a refund." without mentioning authorized repairs specifically.

I'm not holding my breath though given that Apple can't keep track of all unofficial repair shops and it would be way too easy to fake a repair receipt to fraud this refund system.

I'm in the same boat as you. Up until now the only Apple-endorsed recourse was to buy an out-of-warranty replacement for $269, which was crazy. I went ahead and had it repaired by a 3rd party facility for $76, and of course Apple will never refund me that.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.