Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Reading that text (and to repeat, I am not a lawyer, and definitely not a European lawyer, so I could be wrong) I would assume any hardware/OS maker would be able to request the ability to create a competing feature on their computers/OSes (e.g, Meta for their VR headsets, or your Windows computer) - and Apple would have to let them. I would assume Apple considers that an absolute non-starter for privacy reasons.
Thank you. I can see why Apple would take issue with this paragraph. On the other hand, if they would really mean it, wouldn't they also have to disable the old Siri? Otherwise, it would seem to only be an excuse in my opinion.
 
Hard to disagree honestly

Apple are trying to play the wag the dog

Screenshot 2024-06-21 at 1.55.18 PM.png
 
100% true. I don't know any iPhone user that uses iMessage, FaceTime etc. Not sure why you've received so many downvotes. Never met any iPhone user that'd use Messages or FaceTime.
I suppose it's mostly US users who can't believe it but I'm also very strong in my wording. The market here is a lot more flexible, regardless of whether the EU is the problem or Apple in this case. I believe they share blame and nobody is really guilty - Apple has a right to defend their interests that should be treated with respect, regardless of whether they're an European, American or Chinese company.

If the Android is the better offering when it comes to features, capabilities, display, battery, storage, etc. people are just going to go for the Android in most of Europe. At least in my country, iPhones are largely a Gen Z thing because older people think it's 1. way too expensive for a phone, and 2. that it's hard to use, which I believe is because Apple didn't even care to add OS-level language support for many countries outside of western Europe until very late in the game, so the stereotype stuck. We're a market that's very used to Android and everyone who has an iPhone comes from an Android as their "ok-now-i'm grown-up phone" so nobody here is confused navigating Androids. As for iMessage, FaceTime etc... I'd dare say most activity on there from Europeans is an accidental tap.
 
I find it hilarious that the American Apple fans on here are quick to blame the EU while Google who they insult daily on here can release Gemini features with zero fuss in the EU and UK.

That tells me that Apple is doing something dirty and you’re all treating this like a sports game, USA v EU when you should be more worried.

Remember all those people saying “pull out of the EU” because of USB-C, well they won’t need to because they’ll be dead in the EU first just like china.
 
"Many would agree with me" isn't a very solid argument. But now you want to change your term from monopoly to duopoly? Apple is not a monopoly.
You are refuting a straw man argument. No one is arguing that Apple is a monopoly in the strictest sense. A company does not have to be a genuine monopoly to get impacted by antitrust legislation.
 
I find it hilarious that the American Apple fans on here are quick to blame the EU while Google who they insult daily on here can release Gemini features with zero fuss in the EU and UK.

So far as I'm aware, Google Gemini isn't as tightly woven into the OS as is Apple Intelligence. Nor has Google concentrated on building "on-device" AI with strong privacy features. You're making a comparison that simply doesn't hold. That they both deal with AI isn't the issue.
 
In the EU customers will turn to Android… Trust me, we really are not attached to the iPhone as people in the US are. People here think iMessage is like SMS so they think it costs money. We text, call, etc. on WhatsApp and FB Messenger.
Exactly

Said it so many times but Americans can’t comprehend it.

We don’t care about iMessage or green bubbles.

Samsung, oneplus, Google and nothing will clean up.
 
Honestly my favorite thing about all of this is that the emperors clothes have come off

We are finally getting an international discourse about what Apple actually is at this point in time, as opposed to the nostalgic view of them so many of us have held onto and hoped was still somewhat there.
 
Exactly

Said it so many times but Americans can’t comprehend it.

We don’t care about iMessage or green bubbles.

Samsung, oneplus, Google and nothing will clean up.
How do we not comprehend it? I'm well aware that Apple has only about a 23-27% MarketShare in the EU.

And that's part of the point. There's no need to try to hobble Apple in the EU. As you keep saying, Apple is a small time player in the EU.
 
I suppose it's mostly US users who can't believe it but I'm also very strong in my wording. The market here is a lot more flexible, regardless of whether the EU is the problem or Apple in this case. I believe they share blame and nobody is really guilty - Apple has a right to defend their interests that should be treated with respect, regardless of whether they're an European, American or Chinese company.

If the Android is the better offering when it comes to features, capabilities, display, battery, storage, etc. people are just going to go for the Android in most of Europe. At least in my country, iPhones are largely a Gen Z thing because older people think it's 1. way too expensive for a phone, and 2. that it's hard to use, which I believe is because Apple didn't even care to add OS-level language support for many countries outside of western Europe until very late in the game, so the stereotype stuck. We're a market that's very used to Android and everyone who has an iPhone comes from an Android as their "ok-now-i'm grown-up phone" so nobody here is confused navigating Androids. As for iMessage, FaceTime etc... I'd dare say most activity on there from Europeans is an accidental tap.
Honest question: why does it seem most of Europe have such trust for Meta/Facebook? While of course popular in the US to varying degrees, there is also an underlying “Do NOT trust Meta” vibe here. In the US if you asked me to use Facebook anything (Messenger, WhatsApp) I’d laugh and ask what cut Zuckerberg is giving you.
 
So far as I'm aware, Google Gemini isn't as tightly woven into the OS as is Apple Intelligence. Nor has Google concentrated on building "on-device" AI with strong privacy features. You're making a comparison that simply doesn't hold. That they both deal with AI isn't the issue.
And yet everyone is quick to say Google can’t be trusted yet Apple can’t comply with the EU rules while Google does just fine.

Both AI require access to your information but only one complies with the EU.

you should be concerned about what Apple is hiding with OpenAI from the EU.
 
If that’s the case, then I think Apple is overestimating EU customers’ general interest in Apple Intelligence features.
So now what? By all accounts, Apple has full control over the smartphone market. So I guess this will eliminate the last intelligence in the EU? ;)
Or are you saying that there are in fact other wares to purchase? Whaaaa?!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexMac89
And yet everyone is quick to say Google can’t be trusted yet Apple can’t comply with the EU rules while Google does just fine.

Both AI require access to your information but only one complies with the EU.

you should be concerned about what Apple is hiding with OpenAI from the EU.
Again, Google Gemini is NOT integrated into the OS in the way Apple Intelligence is.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.