Pro Photo Matte Preference...
I encourage all those, like myself, who can't use glossy displays [as a photographer, one must realize that matte is the only way one can do accurate color calibration as you stated], to please e.mail Steve Jobs and/or leave feedback on Apple's website, asking politely for a matte option on the MacBook Pros. While consumers may be happy with glossy, those in the photography/print/graphics world rely on matte displays.
We can always buy 3rd party displays, but we can't replace the displays built into laptops. As a photographer, I carry my MBP around with me with my cameras and use it in the field or at the hotel, etc, etc. I do not want to lug around a 3rd party external monitor with me!
Hmmm...I am sitting here in front of my 20" iMac/White/Core 2 Duo 2.16 GHz/Matte Screen with my graphics tablet to my right, multi-card reader under display and my Nikon D80 to my left. I am wondering why I have been lusting after a new Glossy 24" iMac and 13" MacBookPro(obviously Glossy). No, I am not a "pro shooter", but just a hobbyist, amateur photographer, but am consistently asked by friends and acquaintances that have seen my work, to shoot for them, and I do. At last check I had over 20K pics in iPhoto. No, they are not all "keepers" and I am constantly trying to catch up on deleting the less than good shots, but overall, a large percentage of my photos are loved by myself, family and friends. I am the 'go to' guy when anyone in our circle of people(co-workers, friends, family, friends of family, etc.) needs advice on a new camera, VidCam, Computer, TV, etc. I love helping out as much as I can and have even been given cash and a 'list' and picked out and purchased gear for my circle dwellers. Enough of the 'credentials', if you will, but I am just saying I love photography, have an eye for composition and color/lighting and would go pro if not being compensated extremely well at my career, and having a wife and two young boys, do not want a second career.
My loooong-winded point??? I feel that my 'matte' screen washes out the colors that I remember that I shot, and when I shop the new glossies and open up iPhoto at the store, I am taken aback at how the images pop. The color, saturation, perceived depth, contrast, sharpness, etc. They just seem to blow my 'matte' screen away, especially the iMacs. Reflections....yes, they are there, when I look for them, but my eyes seem to see the photo until I tell them to look for other stuff. I don't own Photoshop or any other photo editor, but for iPhoto, and I rarely use it to do anything other than straighten, crop, turn into B& W, red eye removal if shot with my wife's Canon PowerShot SD 450(5MP, a good 5 years old, I think, but takes quite excellent pics for a P&S). I have never calibrated my screen and have had great success with nearly all of my prints. They come out just as I remember them when I composed them and look better than they do on my monitor and close to my 52" Samsung Glossy LCD that I stream my photos to via my PS3 in HD. "Pop" they go on the on the GLOSSY screen, Blah(not really blah, I love my Mac and everything Apple) on the 'matte' iMac. OK, I am exaggerating, but I always thought and read somewhere that Glossy Screens, despite the glare, give a more accurate representation of photos, especially colors. Sorry for babbling on, but, I am in a babbling mood.
I guess I will find out for myself when I make my purchase.
Cheers,
lar