Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Soc7777777 said:
I NEVER IN THIS ENTIRE POST SAID THAT I THINK APPLES ARE POOR COMPUTERS OR THAT THEY NEED AN "IMPROVEMENT", I JUST SUGGESTED AN ADDITION

-Soc7777777

Ah. I see the issue here. Your points are valid. But when you start a thread with anything that could be taken as inflammatory, persons can immediately go into defense mode - and have difficulty listening to your words as they will feel them to be just as biased.

By the way, you didn't suggest an addition overtly. Mac users are so used to disdain that that will be the feeling they get given the opportunity to make the assumption.

You made some good points, but they were buried in strong emotions, of yours and others. I would suggest you aproach your posting with a measure of diplomacy. Then your points would be considered with a more even hand.
 
patrick0brien said:
You made some good points, but they were buried in strong emotions, of yours and others. I would suggest you aproach your posting with a measure of diplomacy. Then your points would be considered with a more even hand.

so true... my first post was very factual... (well in a sense that it wasnt emotion based) and i got emotional responses, and i responeded with more emotion... haha... easier said than done when talking about a subject that you have so much passion for...

haha btw my strategy for naming the post such an insulting name was to draw attention... i just didnt know that people considered the name of the post more than the content... if i named my post bush sucks, then posted about how good bush was, then bush supporters shouldnt get defensive, but just see that the name was to draw attention (and it did, 80 posts is really good for a thread started by a user and not based on news, rumors, or any type of facts, just opinions)
 
You have to understand that since you dont use a cd drive, doesnt mean that everybody doesnt use one. I personally dont know of one person who could live without one. People who buy laptops usually want it to be there portable work station. having to carry around a cd or dvd drive doesnt seem to fit in with the portability.

Im sure it would be great to see lighter and thinner 12" 15" and 17" powerbooks (and ibooks), but i doubt that apple is going to take steps backwards like putting in a tiny hard drive, lowering the amount of ram that can be put in, taking out the cd/dvd drive, and removing ports just to make an as light as possible laptop. I think as time goes on and technology increases, apple will slowly update there lines to be more powerful AND light...

Why dont you call up apple, write a letter, or write an email and ask about your idea. It would get alot more done then just complaining on a message board alone.
 
I think the original poster is trying to suggest that choice and flexibility are a good thing. I accept that the R&D for Apple would be too expensive but I reject the arguement that a CD drive is absolutely necessary to take with you (as either built in or external), it's not, once you've installed your programs it's quite possible to leave the thing at home and just take the main unit, without any of the additional peripherals, docking stations or the power supply unit.

I'm a student, in the UK, Apple's portables are too expensive for me to purchase but my ideal laptop would be small, light, with a docking station, with a good battery life when travelling, nice screen resolution to make up for the small screen size and built in WiFi on all models . No internal optical drive, no modem.

I may be a niche market but, at least for the moment, a PC is my only choice.
 
Soc7777777 said:
so true... my first post was very factual... (well in a sense that it wasnt emotion based) and i got emotional responses, and i responeded with more emotion... haha... easier said than done when talking about a subject that you have so much passion for...

Actually, you had very little factual content. The only things you said that couldn't be disputed are that some companies have tiny notebooks, that Apple could (in theory) make one, and that they could call it a certain name. The final part of that last point was pretty insulting to Steve Jobs and the Apple corporation, but I think it was more a failed attempt at humor.

Most of what you've done so far is baseless opinion and saying that Apple needs to do something because you want it. Par for the course, but hardly impressive.

haha btw my strategy for naming the post such an insulting name was to draw attention...

It's called trolling, and it's technically against the rules. Read the TOU for the site before you do something like that again.

i just didnt know that people considered the name of the post more than the content... if i named my post bush sucks, then posted about how good bush was, then bush supporters shouldnt get defensive, but just see that the name was to draw attention

I've read the content and I'm not impressed. Others have already done the work of breaking you down and countering your shaky argument, but I thought that I'd chime in and tell you that there's a lot more to presenting a case than doing the equivalent of standing on a street corner and yelling inflamatorry things, only to act surprised when people don't like you. Honestly, did you expect people not to react a certain way when you throw that title up and then proceed to do nothing but attack the PowerBook line's path, with a single line to the contrary?

Later on, I can see that you were pushed towards admitting that you thought the current line was okay. That's great and all, but you could have structured the argument differently and avoided it to begin with. This whole thing has read as if you wanted people to be angry.

(and it did, 80 posts is really good for a thread started by a user and not based on news, rumors, or any type of facts, just opinions)

Wait a minute...

"so true... my first post was very factual..."

Which is it? Factual or opinion?
 
thatwendigo said:
Wait a minute...

"so true... my first post was very factual..."

Which is it? Factual or opinion?

all i was trying to say in the first quote was that it was factual in the sense that it wasnt all emotion... but the overall idea was an opinion and was based on some facts... like dell sony toshiba and those companies are all doing better than apple (in a business sense)

so it all comes down to one fact... apple makes a superior product, but has poor poor sales... thats doing a bad job in marketing whether my suggestion would help or hurt... and you cant say its because people inherently look down upon apple due to the past because people have embraced the ipod quite nicely (b/c apple promoted it)...
 
ginner said:
I think the original poster is trying to suggest that choice and flexibility are a good thing. I accept that the R&D for Apple would be too expensive but I reject the arguement that a CD drive is absolutely necessary to take with you (as either built in or external), it's not, once you've installed your programs it's quite possible to leave the thing at home and just take the main unit, without any of the additional peripherals, docking stations or the power supply unit.

I'm a student, in the UK, Apple's portables are too expensive for me to purchase but my ideal laptop would be small, light, with a docking station, with a good battery life when travelling, nice screen resolution to make up for the small screen size and built in WiFi on all models . No internal optical drive, no modem.

I may be a niche market but, at least for the moment, a PC is my only choice.

i agree. give people the option

if you say "i dont need an ultrathin" or "i need an optical drive" or ".5"/lbs is no big deal" then the ultrasmall laptops are not for you

also, these laptops are not aimed at the student market.

they are intended for people who already have desktops and need a really small machine to do simple tasks on the road. students usually dont have a desktop from which to load apps via lan.

i have a 8x10x1" thinkpad that weighs 2.5 lbs. i use it for presentations, slides, showing movies, word, excel, distilling pdf, light pshop, itunes, and internet. i love it and i think even ibooks are too big. the lack of weight is noticable on my thrice fractured collarbone. but if it were my only machine, it would not work out

im sure im not the only person out there that appreciate these machines
 
Soc7777777 said:
ok since everyone here seems to love the idea of an optical drive, i just wanted to know WHILE TRAVELING, what do you do with your internal drives that a program like alcohol 120 percent woulndt fix (and maybe with a small removable flash drive)????

i say this because with alcohol 120 i never use my cd drive except to install stuff... so i dont need cds for games or anything like that.... and a 60 gig hard drive is plenty to store a bunch of cd images on (use about 10-15 gig for that)

so what does everyone use it for?
well when im on a plane or trip i dont get to excited about spending a day ripping 9gb dvd's onto my 40gb hard drive, i would rather just slide them in and watch them, WOW what an awesome idea. you mean instead of dedicating my life to alcohol 120 (wtf) i can just use the dvd rom. also, does alcohol 120 burn cd's without the drive, that would be pretty cool as well.

iJon
 
Ultraportables have always been meant to appeal to the executive who wants to show up the other people in the office and to take on the road with a plethora of marketing materials.

Does it matter that the keyboards are too small? No, because he can only type with two fingers.

Does it matter that the optical drive is an external add-on? No, because he has a docking station at home and at work so he barely has to connect anything, which is good because he's usually lost doing that.

Ultraportables have been popular in Japan and there was a PowerBook once that fit that niche, made by IBM Japan. If it sold well, would Apple still have one in the market? Of course they would. It would just need to be profitable.

For most of us though, simplicity is the answer. If you have everything in one box, it's certainly more appealing. It is intruiging to me that people who would normally complain about 12 inch LCDs can cope with 10.4 inch LCDs. For executives this is rarely an issue because they don't really work on the machine--they simply present the material. I'm surprised that anyone else would try to use one.
 
Soc7777777 said:
so it all comes down to one fact... apple makes a superior product, but has poor poor sales... thats doing a bad job in marketing whether my suggestion would help or hurt... and you cant say its because people inherently look down upon apple due to the past because people have embraced the ipod quite nicely (b/c apple promoted it)...

No, that is not the only fact that keeps Apple from growing. I will not argue that Apple could do more for marketing, but there is more to it than that.

Take Toshiba for example, have them spin off a new company under a new name without anyone knowing it. Have them sell all of the SAME computers, this time running OSX. Now give those computers the same marketing that Toshiba now enjoys, heck, give them MORE marketing. Do you really think that the same Toshiba's, under a new name running OSX are going to sell just as well as the current line up running windows?

There are a few other facts that lead to Apple not growing.
A: One of the things that Makes Apple so great is also a downside, OSX, it aint Windows.
B: Many people not in the "know" don't know Apple exists, and people not in "the know" are the ones currently buying the bulk of computers.
C: People still have MANY misperceptions concerning Apple computers.

Example: Many people on these boards have told stories about how people commented on their Powerbooks ect on airlines and such. These people thought the Apple computers looked awesome, but preceded to ask - "Which IBM model is that?". They didn't even know what to think of the Apple symbol on the back. Same thing has happened with the iPod, but not so much.

My Girl Friend who happens to not be blond, is one of those people that enjoys knowing lots of stuff, and knows at least a little bit about everything. She isn't a nerd when it comes to computers, but she knows her way around Windows fairly well. She herself thought that Apples could only use a 4 button mouse when I first met her. Today, after letting her use OSX on my PB, she is more than willing to get a Mac the next time around.

It's pretty easy to think that the world views the tech world the way we do, but in reality, they don't. They will buy what they're friends have, and they won't take risks. If they don't see it, they won't buy it. The internet is bring about huge market research before a purchase, but most people don't use that yet. I think with the next generation, and the introduction of the iPod (some of the best marketing money can by IMHO) will will see a slow change in market share over the next 10-30 years.

The fact is most of the major companies could STOP marketing and the user base and word of mouth would carry them for a long time. Anyone ever see Microsoft adds on TV? no. Because they don't need it. The user base carries it's self. When billy joe goes to buy a computer, he's going to buy what timmy down the street has, and more than likely, that is going to be a Widows based machine.

Tyler
Earendil

ps
anyone care to give numbers on what the individual PC manufacturers actually hold in laptop user base? I know Apple has like 7-9%, and I can think of 6 other laptop manufacturers off the top of my head (IBM, Sony, Toshiba, HP, Fuji, Dell) And I know there are many other minor ones (AlienWare?). So if we put Apple at 8% market share, that leaves the other 6 (not counting companies I'm forgetting) at 15.33% a piece. That's not even twice Apples market share. I'd say that seeing as Portable sales are looking up for Apple (not down) that they are doing QUITE well considering mind share and past history. But does anyone have real numbers?
 
Apple //e said:
i have a 8x10x1" thinkpad that weighs 2.5 lbs. i use it for presentations, slides, showing movies, word, excel, distilling pdf, light pshop, itunes, and internet. i love it and i think even ibooks are too big. the lack of weight is noticable on my thrice fractured collarbone. but if it were my only machine, it would not work out

im sure im not the only person out there that appreciate these machines

But for the very reason you state is why I don't think it would work out for Apple, where they stand today. As easy as they could try and make it for Windows users, no one is going to by an Apple ultra thin and take it home to their windows box. Why would you do something like that? So that leaves only people in the currently installed Apple base to purchase ultra thins, which I don't think would generate all that many sales.

And does the dress up class of business man really work with anything but black windows notebooks? noooo (at least none of the ones I've seen).

Tyler
Earendil
 
Earendil said:
But for the very reason you state is why I don't think it would work out for Apple, where they stand today. As easy as they could try and make it for Windows users, no one is going to by an Apple ultra thin and take it home to their windows box. Why would you do something like that? So that leaves only people in the currently installed Apple base to purchase ultra thins, which I don't think would generate all that many sales.

And does the dress up class of business man really work with anything but black windows notebooks? noooo (at least none of the ones I've seen).

Tyler
Earendil

box an external fw powered superdrive with it

a matte black anodized xbook would be sexxxy.

its a small market, but its aimed at the people who make top level decisions
 
Earendil said:
Anyone ever see Microsoft adds on TV? no. Because they don't need it.

Really? I see about five a DAY. Maybe it's because I watch thing like CNBC but every single day I am treated to tv ads with people hugging in offices and having meetings on the top of mountains.
 
DGFan said:
Really? I see about five a DAY. Maybe it's because I watch thing like CNBC but every single day I am treated to tv ads with people hugging in offices and having meetings on the top of mountains.

I see many adds for Dell, Intel, and HP, but not Microsoft. Interesting... Maybe because I'm in the NW they don't bother :D

Tyler
 
tamara6 said:
My Pismo's dvd drive went out about a year ago, so I know what it is like to have a portable with no optical drive. I didn't think it was much fun. Either I had to tote my external combo drive along (bleh!) or explain to people that I'd have to take their cd home and load it there. I felt like a fool.

I'm glad the no optical drive solution works for some people, but for me, the primary reason I bought my new PB was so I'd have a functioning optical drive again.

Just my point of view.

some life for your pb:

http://store.mcetech.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=MTOS&Product_Code=XP2KDVDR2


look at a powerbook then look at a dell if you dont think: wtf i dont want that ugly peice of crap dell you are mentaly unbalenced goodbye
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.