Timepass said:
Well that 200 limitation could be one moto put on there not cingular. As far as I can tell Cingalur doesnt force that stuff on the phone they carry. They didnt on sony's phones of any other that have the ablitly to take struff from computers.
Now sprint as far as I know does not carry any phones that can play Mp3 at all so that not an issue.
Verson well they are crap any how in the phone deparment and only run there own POS OS on there phones so yeah.
of the major cariar Verizon is the only one that forces those limition the others dont mess with the phone operation system and let the manufactor have free rein (minus locking the phone to one carrir and there respect logo splash at start up)
It's a 100 song limitation for both the SLVR and the ROKR, and it's imposed by Cingular. I know, I work for them (well, kinda, I work for RadioShack). It's only on the iTunes phones too, because Cingular's music store doesn't work so they need some incentive to drive people to their own store.
Sprint carries 3 phones now designed very specifically for music, the Blade (Samsung A900), the Fusic (LG), and the Samsung A920 (no catchy name). All three come with the cables for MP3 downloads from the computer, and all three have no cap on their music except the amount of storage available (both the A920 and the Fusic are expandable, the Blade is not).
Verizon's OS is actually superior to the Motorola one, and is only limited in the Bluetooth (which Verizon is infamous for), but is otherwise a very good phone. It's superior in other ways as well, and has fewer problems from what I've seen (one of our employees chose to keep his Verizon RAZR even after we no longer carried Verizon for that reason). On the whole, no, Verizon's phones are not the best, but the RAZR is probably the exception to that.
That said, there's no reason why any of this should factor into the decisions about an Apple Phone. They won't (or at least shouldn't) subsidize the phone through Verizon or Sprint, and probably not through Cingular or T-Mobile either, because no matter what limitations are put on the phone itself, the carriers won't allow music downloads without additional charges of their own, which Apple wouldn't want. No, it'll either connect only to the computer, or it'll be an MVNO, which I think is unlikely. SIM-free, Wifi and USB for loading music on, and the most simple and effective OS yet on a phone is what I'm expecting. It'll be good, for those of us who've embraced the future of GSM.
jW