anthony11 said:
In the real world, only a very small number of people have any idea what Santa Rosa is, and even fewer care.
Yet regardless of whether they know about it or not they could have benefited from it.
So? Very VERY few people care about the insignificant differences in "chipsets". Shipping graphics have been plenty for 99% of users for years - the same for CPU.
Exactly, the CPU is more than enough for the MB. Why not address it's glaring weakness a little bit?
And you're forgetting that SR would bring better battery life and better I/O speeds along with the better GPU and CPU bump.
Apple sells two lines of notebooks, a casual/entry model at a certain pricepoint for the hipster coffee-swilling / student set, and a "pro" model at a higher pricepoint. They aren't price-competing with the likes of Dell.
Funny, being a student and knowing students I can tell you they ALL play games of some sort or another. Even the girls play The Sims or Second Life.
But regardless, if your neither a "hipster" nor a "pro" do Apple not want your money? The MB's CPU was already more than it needed, and HDD and memory can easily and more cheaply be upgraded outside Apple. What
needed updating was the chipset to keep parity with everything else for the next six months. A sub 10% increase to the MB's strongest feature is meaningless and will make little or no difference to consumers. The RAM boost on the base is nice, but the combo-drive is a little cheap.
If it was too soon for SR then Apple should have waited to update the MBs until later (after WWDC and after updating the Pros?) IMO. This is nothing more than a bump and a minor one at that. Is it good enough to carry the MB for the next 6 months? SR would have brought benefits across the board and been much more future-proof than the quick 'n dirty upgrade Apple plumped for.
If an MB doesn't fit your ego, then buy an MBP.
I just don't like paying money for out-of-date tech, maybe there's something wrong with me? And I don't want/need a MBP. Apple have lumped the MB with integrated graphics (after slagging them off), fine, but at least keep up with the current integrated graphics. All I ask. The X3100 looks like it has the potential to play WoW at decent settings (when it's T&L are enabled) which is all I need it for.
Then again, the next update will be shortly after Leopard is released, so maybe Apple are doing us all a favour and helping us wait until we can get "the full package": A MB with a recent chipset, GPU, CPU as opposed to having old, outdated ones and a fantastic new OS to take advantage of it. I think that's worth waiting for rather than what they're offering now.