Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
2) Flash based media is much faster and much more resilient than optical media (ever had a disk rendered unreadable by scratches? It especially sucks if you don't have a backup)

Nope, never had. But I have had a few usb sticks die, which really sucks since they are so much more expensive than a DVD disk,
 
By that logic the USB stick should allow you to install Snow Leopard then ;)

In addition, that just backs up the fact that Lion is really NOT a new OS. Its a patch for Snow Leopard that adds 1 application (Launchpad) and apples a few (pointless/minor) tweaks to the UI.

We're really all just running Mac OS X 10.6 Service Pack 1 :D

You must be joking.

By that logic you are, and notice everybody, because what I'll be writing is "fact," which is to be distinguished from opinions and beliefs, that, you are NOT really a new person but a patch to your father that adds a few pointless tweaks to the genes.

We are really all just speaking to your-father service pack 1.
 
This IS NOT about the flash drive price. This is about the LICENSE!!

Think, folks. THINK!!

According to the Apple Store, the requirements for "OS X Lion USB Thumb Driver" are

System Requirements

Mac computer with an Intel Core 2 Duo, Core i3, Core i5, Core i7, or Xeon processor
2GB of memory
OS X v10.6.6 or later (v10.6.8 recommended)

That means you need to own SL on the machine you are upgrading (or performing the fresh install on), so we are back at the $29, and Apple charging you $30 for a thumb drive.

Think, folks. THINK!!
 
Edit: Interestingly if you read USER reviews on neutral websites (I.E not on Apple fan sites because they are understandably bias) you'll find most people are very underwhelmed with Lion. A quick google search for OS X Lion review threw the following link up as the first result. Read the USER reviews in the comments section. http://www.techradar.com/reviews/pc...ng-systems/apple-os-x-10-7-lion-982954/review

When you take your head out of the iClouds its actually a pretty poor update, not worthy of a complete new OS. Apple boasts 250 new features. What they don't tell you is that those features include the most minuscule of changes, like increasing the font size by 1pt in Finder results, and widening the spotlight search bar.

Don't bother arguing back to me about how awesome it is until you've pulled your head of of your....


Yeah, so it's pretty standard "neutral" story i can read by going back to any of Mac OS X release. That's first.

Second my head is not in the clouds, i have no use for it today.

Third i already noted about going off-course. Don't do that.
 
why usb and not on DVD?

The Future has no DVD.

New-Apple-Mac-Mini-2011-1.jpg


Lion-Installed-Thunderbolt-Macbook-Air-2011.jpg
 
In addition, that just backs up the fact that Lion is really NOT a new OS. Its a patch for Snow Leopard that adds 1 application (Launchpad) and apples a few (pointless/minor) tweaks to the UI.

We're really all just running Mac OS X 10.6 Service Pack 1 :D

God, we have "one of those" here again.
Come on, Lion is not just an SL + Launchpad, nor a new "Vista".

A lot has changed; but not all necessarily in the UI (New expose, launchpad, fullscreen apps, iCal and I can go on and on) but a lot of work has been done behind the scenes. Apple isn't focussing on that: a LOT of improvement in security, better Time Machine, Versions, Resume, Instant quit for apps and the list is going on and on here as well.

Get the facts straight; a SP is about fixing bugs and adding small features. Lion has a lot of new features and every structural changes. Not even close to a SP.
 
According to the Apple Store, the requirements for "OS X Lion USB Thumb Driver" are



That means you need to own SL on the machine you are upgrading (or performing the fresh install on), so we are back at the $29, and Apple charging you $30 for a thumb drive.

Think, folks. THINK!!

Not true, at least not with the dl version (which I would bet is the same). I've personally installed Lion on a blank partition with no problem from the DMG extracted from the dl (and Restored to a USB stick).
 
Yeah, so it's pretty standard "neutral" story i can read by going back to any of Mac OS X release. That's first.

Second my head is not in the clouds, i have no use for it today.

Third i already noted about going off-course. Don't do that.

Firstly, I'm in no way trolling. If you read back our little tiff, you'll see that you went off on one when I pointed something out that was blatantly obvious. Just because you disagree with my OPINION it does not make me a troll. Calling someone a troll is really pathetic and childish. Grow up for goodness sake.

This argument is never going to result in a resolution, so its pointless continuing. At the end of the day, you have your views, I have mine. In my opinion I'm right. In your opinion you're right. I respect your views, however disagree with them and vice versa. End of.
 
By that logic the USB stick should allow you to install Snow Leopard then ;)

In addition, that just backs up the fact that Lion is really NOT a new OS. Its a patch for Snow Leopard that adds 1 application (Launchpad) and apples a few (pointless/minor) tweaks to the UI.

We're really all just running Mac OS X 10.6 Service Pack 1 :D

I know it doesn't look like a lot of huge changes on the surface but under the hood there was a lot done on Lion. There was some nice advancements with the UI, such as Air Drop, Launchpad (which I surprisingly love), Mission Control (I like my spaces better but Mission Control isn't bad), and a few others; but the real stuff comes from the implementation of a lot of the newer core technologies. The new OpenGL implementation is huge since according to everything I've read it will allow Apple to move to higher versions much easier.

There is a slew of changes listed on Apples website. Its a really good update.
 
Not true, at least not with the dl version (which I would bet is the same). I've personally installed Lion on a blank partition with no problem from the DMG extracted from the dl (and Restored to a USB stick).

Yep. Since Installer is not set to look for Snow Leopard i see this just as standard safe guard Apple has put in. Nothing else.

You can install either version (download or USB key) to any supported Mac running any Mac OS X (Tiger, Leopard or Snow Leopard).
 
God, we have "one of those" here again.
Come on, Lion is not just an SL + Launchpad, nor a new "Vista".

A lot has changed; but not all necessarily in the UI (New expose, launchpad, fullscreen apps, iCal and I can go on and on) but a lot of work has been done behind the scenes. Apple isn't focussing on that: a LOT of improvement in security, better Time Machine, Versions, Resume, Instant quit for apps and the list is going on and on here as well.

Get the facts straight; a SP is about fixing bugs and adding small features. Lion has a lot of new features and every structural changes. Not even close to a SP.

Ok, I accept that Lion has a few more bits and bobs than a standard Service Pack (in comparison to the MS ones). The biggest upgrade is obviously the new API's, which I do agree are very useful. But from a users perspective, not a lot has changed. If anything its slowed down the OS, and has added a few features that weren't really needed or wanted. Launchpad for one seems fairly useless in its current iteration, hopefully that'll change with future updates.

My main gripe was that Apple lists 250 new features. What they don't tell you is that those 250 new features include silly little things like widening the spotlight search bar. Hardly a new feature, I'm sure you'd agree.

Don't get me wrong. I like Lion, but it does feel very minor (again from a user/frontend perspective) compared to previous updates.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_1 like Mac OS X; pt-pt) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8G4 Safari/6533.18.5)

Yumunum said:
I just want that USB drive... because it looks pretty awesome. Anyone else agree?

Has someone else pointed out I'm considering getting one for the collectable value down the line.
 
Firstly, I'm in no way trolling.

That's opinion or a fact?

Calling someone a troll is really pathetic and childish.

I didn't call anyone a troll YET. I said off-course to the…

Mac OS X is very mature OS now and it doesn't need to have flying sourcer detector to it to FEEL right.

It has plenty of changes both visual and under the hood to justify calling it a MAJOR release, so your OPINION you started this whole thing with is kinda …


Ok, I accept that Lion has a few more bits and bobs than a standard Service Pack


What else are you going to agree to along the way?
 
I'm buying a couple of these they look so gorgeous and sexy. I have no need for them really because I created my own USB Thumb Drive installers but if you're a real Apple fan you need these devices in your collection.
 
This USB device contains OS X Lion. I see a lot of people falsely saying you can make one yourself, but you can't. You can put the OSX Lion installer on a USB drive.

A couple years ago I was TDY in a location with crap for internet. Let's say I had to go back there, or let's consider the other Mac users who have to go.

If they read the false info telling them to make their own recovery USB drive with Lion on it, and do so, they'll be in big trouble when they get there and realize they're self-made USB drive only has the installer and they still need to download Lion itself.

However, if they buy this drive, they can install Lion without connecting to the internet.

I'm not sure why the downloadable Lion can't be put on a USB drive, maybe it's a piracy issue. If the app store version could be copied to USB and distributed freely, it wouldn't take long before the .dmg was on every torrent site. maybe the store-bought drive has DRM measures.

Personally, I think it's good to have this option. I downloaded Lion and don't have a need for this installation so far, however being an indie game developer who's thinking of making commercial arcade games with mac hardware, it would be nice to be able to install Lion on the many machines I will be putting out in public without having to enter my Apple ID and password into each.
 
Don't get me wrong. I like Lion, but it does feel very minor (again from a user/frontend perspective) compared to previous updates.

Sure a lot of the changes are minor, but then, so is the price. I would argue that for most users, there are 1 or 2 features that make it worth it to upgrade. For me FileVault2 and Mission Control (w/ Full-screen) meant that it was a no-brainer to fork over my $29. I probably still would have upgraded at $129 because Full Disk Encryption is worth at least that (a PGP subscription for WDE ran about that price).
 
why usb and not on DVD?
'cause the MBA and the MacMini don't have DVD, and probably 'cause discontinuing the optical drive in the future has been announced since the whole iTunes, AppStore, etc started to be realy big.


naughty naughty Apple - that seems a load way too much - you can make your own for less than £30
true, however if you have SL, why wouldn't you want to download it.

there selling it for so much because this is primarily aimed at Leopard users who before this needed to upgrade to Snow Leopard (~$35) then buy Lion of the AppStore. For those select few this has been the only way since about 2 weeks before Lion was launched

makes perfect sence.

I think most of us want to buy this awesome little USB drive with the :apple: on it to show off to our friends and colleagues. The question to Apple should be: "please sell us this little gadget!" and not "can i remove the the Lion from this?" :rolleyes:
 
This USB device contains OS X Lion. I see a lot of people falsely saying you can make one yourself, but you can't. You can put the OSX Lion installer on a USB drive.

A couple years ago I was TDY in a location with crap for internet. Let's say I had to go back there, or let's consider the other Mac users who have to go.

If they read the false info telling them to make their own recovery USB drive with Lion on it, and do so, they'll be in big trouble when they get there and realize they're self-made USB drive only has the installer and they still need to download Lion itself.

However, if they buy this drive, they can install Lion without connecting to the internet.

I'm not sure why the downloadable Lion can't be put on a USB drive, maybe it's a piracy issue. If the app store version could be copied to USB and distributed freely, it wouldn't take long before the .dmg was on every torrent site. maybe the store-bought drive has DRM measures.

Personally, I think it's good to have this option. I downloaded Lion and don't have a need for this installation so far, however being an indie game developer who's thinking of making commercial arcade games with mac hardware, it would be nice to be able to install Lion on the many machines I will be putting out in public without having to enter my Apple ID and password into each.

You are wrong.
 
This USB device contains OS X Lion. I see a lot of people falsely saying you can make one yourself, but you can't. You can put the OSX Lion installer on a USB drive.

A couple years ago I was TDY in a location with crap for internet. Let's say I had to go back there, or let's consider the other Mac users who have to go.

If they read the false info telling them to make their own recovery USB drive with Lion on it, and do so, they'll be in big trouble when they get there and realize they're self-made USB drive only has the installer and they still need to download Lion itself.

However, if they buy this drive, they can install Lion without connecting to the internet.

I'm not sure why the downloadable Lion can't be put on a USB drive, maybe it's a piracy issue. If the app store version could be copied to USB and distributed freely, it wouldn't take long before the .dmg was on every torrent site. maybe the store-bought drive has DRM measures.

Personally, I think it's good to have this option. I downloaded Lion and don't have a need for this installation so far, however being an indie game developer who's thinking of making commercial arcade games with mac hardware, it would be nice to be able to install Lion on the many machines I will be putting out in public without having to enter my Apple ID and password into each.

The downloadable Lion Installer App contains a fully bootable DMG containing Lion. Disk Utility must be used to Restore it to whatever partition you would like - be it on a USB stick, a small HD partition, or a DVD. All of them are bootable and contain Lion.

It's only the Lion Recovery HD that requires the the internet to download Lion.

I think you're confusing the two. The Recovery HD is about 650MB. The DMG from the installer app is 3.74GB.
 
This USB device contains OS X Lion. I see a lot of people falsely saying you can make one yourself, but you can't. You can put the OSX Lion installer on a USB drive.

A couple years ago I was TDY in a location with crap for internet. Let's say I had to go back there, or let's consider the other Mac users who have to go.

If they read the false info telling them to make their own recovery USB drive with Lion on it, and do so, they'll be in big trouble when they get there and realize they're self-made USB drive only has the installer and they still need to download Lion itself.However, if they buy this drive, they can install Lion without connecting to the internet.

I'm not sure why the downloadable Lion can't be put on a USB drive, maybe it's a piracy issue. If the app store version could be copied to USB and distributed freely, it wouldn't take long before the .dmg was on every torrent site. maybe the store-bought drive has DRM measures.

Personally, I think it's good to have this option. I downloaded Lion and don't have a need for this installation so far, however being an indie game developer who's thinking of making commercial arcade games with mac hardware, it would be nice to be able to install Lion on the many machines I will be putting out in public without having to enter my Apple ID and password into each.

This is quite wrong..when you download and before you install you get the .dmg (install ESD) and either put it on a thumb drive or burn it...works like a charm and does clean install with no internet connection..I did it with my MP and will do it again on the MP after I install the new logic board..

It's all over the net on how to do this
 
It's all over the net on how to do this

Well, every article I've read on this says you can put Lion onto a USB but the article itself spells out the steps to put on an installer. Even in this thread people have been saying you could create a USB Lion drive exactly like the one being sold, but the links they provide go to tutorials that create what I described.

So, the ones that you guys are referring to that don't need internet, do they require the Apple ID to install? That's what I need to avoid for my games.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.