I've been thinking about this for the last three days (amongst doing other things, naturally), and it seems that folks are arguing along four lines:
1. a remote control
2. the new iMac
3. a video ipod
4. a small 'tablet'.
I think that 1 and 2 are ridiculous. Remotes are small devices, and the batteries last forever. How many people honestly need a remote control for their Macs? Also, the idea that a 10" device is the detachable screen for the new iMac makes me wonder what variety of crack the proponents of that suggestion have been smoking. No comment needed.
So, could it be a video iPod? Why? I don't need to carry my movies with me, and I'm certainly not going to watch them on a 10" screen. I've got a television, and it's big and loud and doesn't run on batteries, so it won't run out on me when I'm half-way through a movie. And I'm never sitting on a bus when I think to myself, "I'd like to see that scene from Spiderman 2 right now'. I think a video iPod is a non-starter. You can listen to music in many situations, but there are few situations where you can watch a movie/TV program and do something else at the same time.
So that leaves suggestion number 4, which is 'a small tablet'. At first I dismissed this idea, but it's grown on me in the last couple of days. A lot of the suggestions got mashed together in my head, and now I'm a believer: it's the iPad, a portible ebook reader, and much more.
As someone said, it's the size of a paperback. And many people carry books with them. So it could be a proper ebook reader, with the ability to make/take notes.
But it's also a sketch pad, for notes and doodles. And it's got voice recording for recording meetings.
Perhaps it'll run MS Office, or perhaps Appleworks X?
It should dock with your Mac, syncing automatically, and have a wireless capability, for surfing the internet and rendezvous-ing with your Mac on your local network and and and...
Arguments against this have ranged along the data entry model. But there are applications like 'Dasher' which when you get used to them, allow very fast data entry, with only a pointer.
We can all admit that we mostly don't utilise the full power that our Macs have, it's just nice to have it for those times when you're ripping a DVD or doing intense Photoshop work, or whatever. So, a pared down computer geared specifically towards being a notepad/book/dumb terminal, well, that would be interesting.
I suppose that we'll all know the answer come August 31, this year or next.