Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Professionals are (rightfully) complaining, but that won't stop the flashy Starbucks crowd from wanting the latest shiny toy.

You guessed it. Purchased two new Pro's to sit nicely at my usual table in Starbucks, while conducting business, with my flashy stainless Apple Watch, along with my flashy new iPhone 7 Plus. I love having the newest shiny Apple toys. (Oh, almost forgot to mention my flashy Starbucks drink I order daily, I ordered a Venti soy latte non-fat, with no whip cream, steamed, not frothed, no sugar.)
 
If everyone is hating the new MacBook pro, then who's buying it.


It's like the predictors of doom for the iPhone 7 because it wasn't compelling enough and, worst of all, not having a legacy 3.5mm plug would be an insurmountable challenge. At the end of the day, people love em and Apple can't build em fast enough. Despite the trolls on MR, over just the next 12 months, well over two hundred million people throughout the world will buy the iPhone 7 and tens of millions will buy the new MacBooks .
 
It's the best macbook that has ever been made. ACTUALLY! the best laptop ever made.
 
The hate for the new MBP is coming from the kind of people who spend time on sites like this and tend to have a much better knowledge of the products and what they want in them. To the general computer consumers the new MBP has a cool factor and will sell great, even with the high price tag.

You're absolutely right !
 
As your main OS ? I could understand it for games. But other then that why would you buy a Mac then and not go for a regular PC. Acer makes fine machines for example.
There were times when I've used to liked apple hardware (it is changed now, but I only migrated from iMac to proper gamer's desktop, MBP & MB Air still in use), but I never liked it software - I'm booting in Mac OS once in a year: to upgrade it :) Mac OS is fine if you only using browser & X Code, but I don't need X Code and games and Visual Studio are better in Windows, and I have Linux in docker and VM for everything else.
 
Well, you can't really blame Apple for that, but I think there other intel laptops with 32GBs of Ram.

Also, I thought I read an article on MR saying that Apple didn't go with the 32GB Ram due to potential battery life issues.

Right. Currently they are desktop chips. You can get a laptop with anything in it really but it's not much of a laptop.

i don't know why intel is dragging it's feet here but alas.

Now this does not excuse apple from updating it's desktop machines :-/
 
  • Like
Reactions: ImaxGuy
First off, you have (for all intents and purposes) a brand new maxed out 2015 machine....other than form factor and weight why in the world would you be in need of an upgrade so soon?

Second....do you really think a regular headphone jack and one with an optical interface at the end are the same size? o_O

Of course I don't need to upgrade, but for various reasons I thought it might be economical to try to get a good price on a 1-year old machine with AppleCare that Apple still charges a (freaking) lot for. I also have a temporary cash problem that will (hopefully) be resolved in a month when the new ones ship. So I thought I could kill two birds with one stone.

Second, I'm genuinely interested in the new screen and its potential for pro-level photography work.

And finally, it's not the biggest piece of circuitry inside the port. Given how much else was cut they could've certainly kept it if they wanted to. I believe they didn't want to in part because they want to kill it off entirely. This may be why they moved the jack further away from the user as well.

I'm sure not many people use optical, but for those that do it's a major drawcard to the Mac platform and one I frequently lauded in audiophile forums.
 
Last edited:
Probably because a majority of the people who buy iPhones don't own a mac or a usbc capable device yet and anyone who is buying a $1,500 -$3,000 pc can easily afford to buy a $25 usbc to lighting cable and it would be silly to remove the headphone jack from a laptop this year especially since these macs where supposed to launch earlier this year before the iPhone 7 and there is no space contstraint. It really seems like they are pushing customers toward Bluetooth and not lighting headphones anyway


It's nice to see the occasional well reasoned post on MR.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ErikGrim
People in this forum (and others) have a seriously twisted (or at least seriously lazy) idea of what "professional" means.

add 110+ dollars or more to the base price.....:). seriously, what ive been told by apple tech support and in stores, unless you buy the macpro 15" with discrete graphics or imac i7 it wont do what you want it to do very well... and thats edit photos and some basic video editing. yes, thats what im was told, so dont flame the delivery boy!!!:(
 
Seriously, am I the only one who, 90% of the time, has the Mac on a stand and uses an external keyboard? What's the point of a touchbar unless they produce a full size external keyboard with one... and no, if I wanted a laptop-sized keyboard with no key travel, no number pad and scrunched-up cursor keys I wouldn't be using an external keyboard...
Yes, if Apple thinks so highly of the Touch Bar then they should have done a "just one more thing". Picture Phil saying, "The Magic keyboard gives you the same amount of Touch Bar as the notebooks, but the Apple keyboard gives you 55% more Touch Bar. Look at how many more emojis you can see."

What I find to be the biggest slap in the face, ignoring the slower RAM, is the inability to CTO the 3.3 GHz Core i7 in the model without a Touch Bar.
 
True 'pros' don't use laptops as their main machine.

You've got to be kidding me. I'm running 250 + tracks in ProTools HD for an Imax Immersive 12 channel mix here on a (tired) 2013 15" MBP - I can plug my system into the monitoring system of a mixing theatre or cut at home in my back room. I do this for a living, but now I'm surprised to find out that I'm not a professional. Thanks internet.
 
I can understand people being angry about Apple axing the audio optical out. It may not be used be "über"-pros. But I know quite some musicians who use it when playing in smaller venues like bars and pubs etc.

Having said that I guess demand is big in china. Chinese people only care about the image - hell most of the Chinese even run MS Windows on their Macs. But show off value is more important.
That is why There is Bootcamp. They just need apple hardware.
 
I must have missed something then. From memory, the only reasons I remember were waterproofing and courage.

The waterproofing doesn't make sense. Many other technologies are waterproof and include the a headphone jack.


Dear Miss a Lot, in addition to waterproofing, there was a 14% bigger battery, duo speakers and larger Taptic engine--three significant improvements you missed.

As far as "waterproofing," you should use the correct term, "water resistance." None of the phones are waterproof. Removing the headphone jack leads to improved water resistance. Apple never said having a headphone jack means you can't have a water resistant phone, but it makes it more difficult and you have to cut other corners to deal with it, and is a potential failure point. It's one of the reasons the new Google Pixel can't meet the same standard for water resistance as the iPhone. It's also why Samsung phones have performed poorly in some tests, e.g., Consumer Reports, on water resistance.
 
Are you serious? Even on the 15"? Please say it ain't so! I use and love optical as an interface to my DAC.

I was seriously considering an upgrade from my maxed out 15" 2015 Pro but that could be the straw that broke the camel's back. I could handle losing the SD slot, I could handle losing HDMI. I thought I could even handle the flat keyboard and loss of Magsafe. But this one stings.

Why Apple? How much did you save by cutting a feature that made no difference to the form factor and which some users really loved?

I'm so seriously!

:eek::(

I guess we don't know for sure; the 13" non-touch does not have optical out. Suppose there's still a chance, but I find it unlikely. Like you it was my preferred output for my DAC (Creative E5); it freed up a USB port too. Hope it's kept, but not counting on it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: simonmet
That's somewhat exaggerated: all you do is replace the Lightning-to-USB-A cable with a Lightning-to-USB-C cable, and you can charge your iPhone from your MacBook Pro or direct from the MBP's USB-C power supply.

But, yeah - Apple could have knocked themselves you and included both USB-A and USB-C cables with the $700 iPhone... and, of course, the main problem was dropping the 3.5" jack from the iPhone in the first place (the fact they left it in the MBP shows that it certainly isn't obsolete yet).

And what about those headphones that you plug into the Mac? You can't plug them into the iPhone. And the ones that plug into the iPhone? They don't plug into the Mac.
 
I was afraid of this - there's so much pent up demand that anything they released would have been a success. Apple will miss the lesson they need to learn - price hikes and gimmicky tool bars do not a pro machine make.

The dongles are annoying, but that's temporary. The mediocre performance and price increase are the real issue.
 
And what about those headphones that you plug into the Mac? You can't plug them into the iPhone. And the ones that plug into the iPhone? They don't plug into the Mac.
WHAT!?!?!

Oh my god the room is spinning, the ground is opening up in fire and brimstone!

How does this matter, at all?
 
True professionals don't care about the price or dongles. All they want to know is if the machine can expedite the work they do daily. That's all that matters.

Which these can't and won't. There's no significant performance improvement over the 2013/4/5 models.
 
I'm a professional and I'll be buying the new MBP.

I develop massively parallel, scientific simulation code that runs on the worlds largest supercomputers.

I don't care about dongles. I've already been carrying DP->DVI and DP->VGA with my current MBP for connecting to projectors, USBC->DVI and USBC->HDMI and USBC->VGA will only add one dongle. Other than that I never plug _anything_ into my MBP (everyone using USB sticks: haven't you heard of Dropbox?)

I use my MBP all day, every day. I have 3 Mac Pros that I don't even have hooked up to monitors. I use them over SSH for small compute jobs and for distributed compiling (using distcc).

I'm looking forward to the Touch Bar for better contextual menus in my favorite programs (I hope there are some good Emacs extensions!). I'm also drooling over the huge Touch Pad with 3D touch, faster SSD speeds and faster graphics cards.

True professionals don't care about the price or dongles. All they want to know is if the machine can expedite the work they do daily. That's all that matters.

True professionals don't care about the price or dongles. They don't. But they hate having to use them.

Everyone's computing needs are different. Yours, as far as the laptop is concerned, seemingly could be met with a $300 Windows laptop (SSH and small compute jobs). Your work horse is a supercomputer. People without access to those may have legitimate beef with Macs falling behind Windows counterparts in performance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: simonmet
One other thing about the keyboard: I actually use the F-Keys quite a lot. My favourite file manger supports F2 for Rename, F5-Copy, F6-Move, and one Key is dedicated to show the Desktop, just like the good old Norton Commander ;-)

I am not sure how I would get by without these keys. External keyboard?
You can just switch the Touch bar to always show the function keys. You might have problems to touch type them but my guess would be that most touch typists cannot touch type the function keys (to rarely used to bother learning).
 
How would a lightning port be useful on the MacBook Pro? Are there a lot of accessories you plug to your iPhone that you would also like to plug in to your laptop?

Because, according to Apple, they designed the Lightning connector to be "a great digital audio connector" and there are "over 900 million Lightning-enables devices" making it "perhaps the largest digital audio connection in the world".

So, according to Apple, it would be very useful.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.