Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
surface pro exists with a detachable screen, and goes into tablet mode When you detach the screen.

why couldn’t Apple release a “macbook“ size hybrid, which is a regular Mac OS when in laptop mode, but when you detach the screen, it switches to IOS only.
 
  • Like
Reactions: apolkowski
An iPad and a Mac are two different products that just happen to have overlap in some functionality. There is little reason to complain that the iPad might be getting a track pad because it does not make the Mac any worse but it might make the iPad a bit better. And I don't believe that the MacBook will ever be discontinued regardless of how functional the iPad may become.
 
it's really beyond me to understand why so many people are against this. There are very basic productivity tasks that are a pain in the ass with touch. If you ever had to work with a spreadsheet or edit a long text you would understand this. And no, I don't want to get a laptop to be able to do it. I want to use a touch interface when is ok and comfortable to do so and switch to a cursor when is more convenient. Why is this a problem?

who are these “so many people?”

I’m 7 pages in and haven’t seen anybody who is against it.
 
Mention "trackpad" or "mouse" in the same sentence as "iPad" and you can expect what the responses will be. This thread didn't fail to deliver. :D

Unless Apple is going to expand mouse/trackpad support in iOS to reach parity with how Android supports it, I don't see the value in a keyboard case that includes a trackpad.


who are these “so many people?”

I’m 7 pages in and haven’t seen anybody who is against it.
You haven't read this thread carefully then. "If you want a mouse get a macbook" type posts are implicitly against the idea.
 
Mention "trackpad" or "mouse" in the same sentence as "iPad" and you can expect what the responses will be. This thread didn't fail to deliver. :D

Unless Apple is going to expand mouse/trackpad support in iOS to reach parity with how Android supports it, I don't see the value in a keyboard case that includes a trackpad.



You haven't read this thread carefully then. "If you want a mouse get a macbook" type posts are implicitly against the idea.

no, they aren’t. They are pro-trackpad.
 
This is awesome. I hope they really do this! If they made a version for the non pro iPads I’d buy that in a heartbeat. I also hope this means they’ll finally allow support for the Magic Trackpad.
 
Gotta love the Internet. People getting angry over a product becoming more functional.
Yeah, now that you think of it, every angry post is essentially “THIS ISN’T FOR ME!” :) You can always try to spin it another way, but what’s driving it is that something in the world is not for them!
 
If this really happens, I’m going to laugh at all those ”true ipad experience” philosophers who are so opposed to mouse pointers in ipad.

Well take that! Apple’s gonna do it lol
 
If this really happens, I’m going to laugh at all those ”true ipad experience” philosophers who are so opposed to mouse pointers in ipad.

Well take that! Apple’s gonna do it lol
I think they’re just opposed to mouse pointers when using a device as a tablet. And they were afraid apps would start making very small tap targets, thus requiring a mouse.

The good news is that we know, from the addition of pencil, that developers (prodded by App Store review) won’t be able to screw it up. Using a trackpad will probably be just like using the pencil, but with a visible cursor.
 
Might as well get a laptop instead of this.

Then you'd be stuck with Windows, macOS, or otherwise. iOS with a trackpad/keyboard combo is perfect for me.
[automerge]1582902799[/automerge]
This is exactly what I have been waiting for. iPad has been my only computer for a while now and I want the built in capability to quickly utilize a pointer if I want to. This will be much better than having to bring a mouse when needed. Can't wait, just hoping it can be used with the previous Pro as I won't be upgrading this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smulji
surface pro exists with a detachable screen, and goes into tablet mode When you detach the screen.

why couldn’t Apple release a “macbook“ size hybrid, which is a regular Mac OS when in laptop mode, but when you detach the screen, it switches to IOS only.

That's a really good idea. But I bet that will take years to finish as currently macOS Catalyst is a clean cut off of legacy iOS with deprecated APIs. It doesn't looks like Apple want to merge the ABI of iOS and macOS.

For me I just want iPad to have slightly better multitasking UI and runs Xcode and have python runtime locally.
That's all I need for a iPad to replace my MacBook.
 
I’m hoping they will offer this smart case for 2018 iPad Pro. If not, the Brydge option is very nice, albeit a bit bulkier.
Due to how expensive these iPads are now I’m assuming most 2018 Pro owners would likely not upgrade for an incremental refresh. However, this would be a brilliant way to extract another $200 out of many of us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jmgregory1
Due to how expensive these iPads are now I’m assuming most 2018 Pro owners would likely not upgrade for an incremental refresh. However, this would be a brilliant way to extract another $200 out of many of us.

Agreed. I’m not currently needing more power with the 2018 Pro 12.9”, and although I have used it for some work photography (product stills), I can’t see upgrading to the newest version...unless there are some really compelling features we don’t yet know about. Even if Apple does release a trackpad equipped keyboard folio that only works with the 2020 iPad Pro’s, I don’t think I would bite on upgrading.

But as is often the case with Apple, they can surprise me and make a compelling reason for me to upgrade. I know one of my kids would be happy to get my current iPad Pro, so it is something I’ll at least consider. But as you note, if I can spend just $200 for an updated keyboard / trackpad folio, I’ll do that without thinking twice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smulji
If you ever use an iPad with a keyboard, you'll soon find the lack of the touchpad annoying. The problem is having tap (drag, pinch, etc.) on the screen doesn't work well when typing. A touchpad simply replicates the screen touches at the keyboard.
This is one of the reasons why I believe an iPad could not replace my laptop yet.

I'm actually trying to decide if an iPad would be enough for me (since I don't need to do pro work with my personal machines).

Given that I don't draw, a (better) MacBook Air is actually better for me, and in a similar price range to a comparable iPad Pro.

A built-in stand, keyboard, trackpad, and a more powerful OS make it a no-brainer.

However my daughter, who is a graphic artist, THRIVES on an iPad. She still has an MBP though.

All this said, I think getting a trackpad for iOS would be nice, but only like sracer said. It needs to be supported like Android does.
 
This is one of the reasons why I believe an iPad could not replace my laptop yet.

I'm actually trying to decide if an iPad would be enough for me (since I don't need to do pro work with my personal machines).

Given that I don't draw, a (better) MacBook Air is actually better for me, and in a similar price range to a comparable iPad Pro.

A built-in stand, keyboard, trackpad, and a more powerful OS make it a no-brainer.

However my daughter, who is a graphic artist, THRIVES on an iPad. She still has an MBP though.

All this said, I think getting a trackpad for iOS would be nice, but only like sracer said. It needs to be supported like Android does.

I can share my personal experience. I've gone from working and traveling with a 15" MBP, to a 13" MacBook Air, to a 15" rMBP, to now using the 12.9" iPad Pro (2018 version purchased almost exactly a year ago).

I LOVED the MacBook Air, because it was such a departure from the old 15" MBP in both weight savings and speed. But as I got used to the higher resolution screens on my iPhone and iPads, the low-res Air was just too hard to continue working with, so the jump back to a retina MBP was great - not to mention the added screen real estate was nice.

But the weight and amount of space required to carry it and the charger became more than I could handle - plus I really didn't need the horsepower the rMBP had while on the road. So I picked up the iPad Pro last year and have been extremely satisfied since.

One great thing about the iPad Pro, vs any of the MacBooks, is that I can pull it out and start working immediately (I recommend getting the cellular model because of this), without needing to find wifi or connect to my iPhone for service. The negative of the smaller size compared to the 15" rMBP is a non issue, as I can zoom in anytime I need and obviously when holding it you can put it right up to your face if need be.

I did just start using the Pencil with it, specifically for note taking. If I can fully stop writing in my favorite Field Notes journals, the benefit of taking notes in the Notes app on the iPad is that I don't have to try to remember what journal I wrote any specific note in, since I can categorize and search more easily in a single spot.

I'm even finding myself emailing on the iPad even when I'm sitting at my desk in front of the iMac, which I didn't used to do. It's just so easy to use and I kind of like the limited keyboard travel more than the Magic Keyboard.
 
This would be cool. But they need to make the cursor different than their big nasty circle. I get they’re trying to indicate a finger but it’s still ugly. Maybe allow for some customizations?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.