Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is incorrect. The previous aTVs did not support (e)ARC. In the default configuration, the aTV would send the audio signal to your TV. if your TV supported (e)ARC and you had a compatible soundbar (or receiver) the sound would routed to the soundbar/receiver. The aTV didn't care.

What I am reading, the newest aTV supports acting as an (e)ARC receiver. You plug the aTV in the (e)ARC port on your TV. Now the TV will route the sound from any of the inputs to the aTV, which will then send the sound output to the HomePods. (Previously only sound from aTV could be redirected to HomePods.)

Pretty cool feature. I don't have any Homepods (prefer my Sonos ARC), but that eliminates one of the limitations of using Homepods with a TV. Unless you were a 100% aTV users, you still needed separate speakers for any other video device.
I’m not sure where you read that the previous version supported eARC. I didn’t read that from his post. Just ARC. theres a difference between ARC and eARC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
This is all very new to me, and I think I must be misunderstanding something. I have a stereo pair of original HomePods. If I follow the instructions here, would I be able to use the stereo pair of HomePods as speakers for a connected TiVo? Also, if that were to work, would the stereo pair of HomePods still function as "normal" when not being used as speakers for the TV, responding to Hey Siri, playing music, etc?
No Idea if a Tivo supports eArc, I did not hear you mention AppleTV at all. so here is a generous re-interpretation of your question. If your TV supports eARC and your Tivo supports eArc and your Tivo supports Airplay 2, you can probably get the HomePods to play though the Tivo. Many newer TVs now support Airplay 2, so you could use your Tivo to connect to your TV and connect your TV to the HomePods or other Airplay 2 speakers. If your Tivo and TV do not support Airplay 2, then no.
 
No, ARC=Audio Return Channel. That is send audio BACK from the tv to a device capable of outputing sound.
Ie a receiver, a device capable of outputting sound. Therefore the previous version supported ARC. Not eARC. ARC. My 4K Gen 1 outputted sound to my A/V receiver. (And no it wasn’t directly connected to the receiver. It was connected to the TV. It was returning audio back to the receiver to play on that device)
 
This is incorrect. The previous aTVs did not support (e)ARC. In the default configuration, the aTV would send the audio signal to your TV. if your TV supported (e)ARC and you had a compatible soundbar (or receiver) the sound would routed to the soundbar/receiver. The aTV didn't care.

What I am reading, the newest aTV supports acting as an (e)ARC receiver. You plug the aTV in the (e)ARC port on your TV. Now the TV will route the sound from any of the inputs to the aTV, which will then send the sound output to the HomePods. (Previously only sound from aTV could be redirected to HomePods.)
That's not entirely true. The ATV4kv1 wouldn't send Dolby Atmos over a regular ARC connection (and it's a little inaccurate to be putting the (e) in front of ARC - they're not equally supported). It turns out, even with the ATV4k1, you needed the bandwidth of an eARC port. (which is likely why mine has been providing Atmos since I got my new TV and Sonos Arc). If you have an eARC port it would work. Maybe some of the other ARC connections are higher performing and worked regardless. As I said, the manufacturers have been inconsistent with complying with the HDMI specs in their implementations.

References:


Per that support article, the ATV needs more bandwidth than a regular ARC connection for the high bandwidth Dolby Atmos signal it sends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Does this mean that you can use both homepods and tv speakers for regular broadcast tv (in sync) or do you have to choose one or the other?
Should be able to use both, I do. There is an audio synch tool in AppleTV. It works on the Samsung TVs I have seen, but there is weird echoing on the LG (but its an LG, so that might explain everything). Also you need to turn off any audio enhancements coming from TV, because they add delays themselves
 
  • Like
Reactions: Topfry
Heh, it's ok. Journalists make LOTS of mistakes. :) Yes, the prior ATV4k supported ARC (how do you think all of us have been using the Sonos Arc currently? :)

For the most part, only newer TV's with HDMI 2.1 ports will have eARC support - but a lot of the manufacturers have been playing "fast and loose" with compliance to the HDMI specs. You could have HDMI 2.0 ports with eARC support and HDMI 2.1 ports WITHOUT eARC support (which, obviously, should NOT happen). :) People need to be careful and confirm what their TVs support when making their purchases. (it shouldn't be that complicated...)
OK, that is new to me, I was not aware Apple TV supported Arc. It is not working on mine. I have the HDMI cable through the Arc port of the TV. Its not my cable so I am not sure if the cable supports ARC, I will check. Please illuminate me!
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
That's not entirely true. The ATV4kv1 wouldn't send Dolby Atmos over a regular ARC connection (and it's a little inaccurate to be putting the (e) in front of ARC - they're not equally supported). It turns out, even with the ATV4k1, you needed the bandwidth of an eARC port. (which is likely why mine has been providing Atmos since I got my new TV and Sonos Arc). If you have an eARC port it would work. Maybe some of the other ARC connections are higher performing and worked regardless. As I said, the manufacturers have been inconsistent with complying with the HDMI specs in their implementations.

References:


Per that support article, the ATV needs more bandwidth than a regular ARC connection for the high bandwidth Dolby Atmos signal it sends.

I was using (e)ARC just as a shorthand understanding there is a difference. I am just trying to make sure everyone understands that ARC or eARC support is not required on most devices to use with a TV. Sorry, I could have been more clear.

But, to be clear, the 1gen aTV 4K does NOT support ARC or eARC.
 
Ie a receiver, a device capable of outputting sound. Therefore the previous version supported ARC. Not eARC. ARC. My 4K Gen 1 outputted sound to my A/V receiver. (And no it wasn’t directly connected to the receiver. It was connected to the TV. It was returning audio back to the receiver to play on that device)

Simple question, which device is connected to the ARC port on your TV? Your aTV or your receiver? That is the ARC device.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Wait, what? Is it possible to get other hdmi inputs on the tv that an Apple TV is connected to, to play their audio via a stereo HomePod pair with a gen 1 4K Apple TV? How? This is what I wanted.
Nope, the article states that it was a feature only for the Gen 2 ATV4k. It could be part of the feature set of eARC that allows them to do this. We'd need someone from Apple to publish how they're taking control of the eARC audio channel (that typically the TV does).
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
I was using (e)ARC just as a shorthand understanding there is a difference. I am just trying to make sure everyone understands that ARC or eARC support is not required on most devices to use with a TV. Sorry, I could have been more clear.

But, to be clear, the 1gen aTV 4K does NOT support ARC or eARC.
Yep, and that's where we disagree. Apple's infamous for not stating all of the specs that are supported.

Edit - as ARC was included in the HDMI 1.4 spec, do you really think companies need to rhyme off all of the features included in their HDMI 2.0 devices?
 
Last edited:
I take it this will also work with a Blu-ray player? (Not sure why it wasn’t mentioned, but also not sure why it wouldn’t work.)
If so, this is outstanding. Not being able to output sound from my Blu-ray player was the major downside of using homepods as home theater speakers for me. No longer.
Now I have a great reason to buy the new atv.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
If it’s like the current set up with the HomePod playing the audio from Apple TV expect frequent disconnections, the HomePod to instead play random music that was on your iPhone a few weeks ago, randomly switch off the AppleTV music, etc. with fiddling you can always get it to work. Just remember never use the HomePod for anything else or it will take another 5 minutes to get it reconnected. Usually it will only take 3.
?? I don’t have any of these issues at all! Are you sure you turned on home theater audio mode in atv settings after you updated to 14.5? It’s not automatic, you have to turn it on manually, I found out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Just to be clear - if your tv has an inbuilt tuner and youre watching broadcast tv - even tho youre not using the atv directly, you can still send audio to homepods? So watching a film on a network channel and can use homepods for sound?
If thats the case it solves several problems for me…
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Thank you for this. I'm still confused on the whole HomePod experience in relation to the Home App and why the Homepod would disconnect, play random music, or just make the audio go away suddenly. I guess what I don't understand is why would the Homepod depend on an internet connection for Airplay to work. Shouldn't it work like a bluetooth device, where if a phone senses another apple device that would make the connection? There's really nothing on the Home Pod other than the speaker and the volume level which you control on your phone so why would it need an internet connection?

Also, I use the older generation 4K but is there a way to connect the Homepod to something like a Blu Ray Player or just use it as your main speaker for everything or does it need to be tied directly to apple devices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
I use Homepods everyday. This is huge if it passes audio from anything like a Nintendo Switch to the Homepods. Not sure how it would account for delay though. Afaik the ATV delays it's video ever so slightly to sync with the audio no?

btw, almost skipped this because of title. I think it would have been more eye catching to scream, 'play audio from your PS5 etc thru your ATV to your Homepod.' But maybe that's just me.
 
You know something’s not quite right when Apple keeps releasing new features for discontinued hardware.
What is frustrating and confusing is if Apple had these features from the get-go and advertised them so people actually knew maybe Homepod wouldn't have failed. I never bought one because I was going to exclusively use it as speakers for my AppleTV but they didn't integrate it as they do with other Apple products made it the same as any other soundbar or speaker array with no benefits. Now they add all the features I wanted at the beginning and with the bundle services it made sense for me to now subscribe to Apple Music. So I now own it along with their One service and I have to admit I use them a lot and really love them. Glad they are continuing to support them and I do believe there is something else in the Homepod category future that will go along with Homepod mini and having to support Homepod mini and any new products I do think they will support the Homepod for a long time even though it is now discontinued.
 
I'm still confused on the whole HomePod experience in relation to the Home App and why the Homepod would disconnect, play random music, or just make the audio go away suddenly.
I use my HomePod as my default speaker for my Apple TV. I dont have any disconnection problems, but what some users experience is that if they want to use the physical HomePod volume controls on top of the home pod, they can accidentally trigger music to play. it can be clunky, but I just gave up on using the touch panel to control volume (if I happened to be near it).

I guess what I don't understand is why would the Homepod depend on an internet connection for Airplay to work. Shouldn't it work like a bluetooth device, where if a phone senses another apple device that would make the connection? There's really nothing on the Home Pod other than the speaker and the volume level which you control on your phone so why would it need an internet connection?
In theory yes you should be correct in that assumption, however the HomePod is a Siri device, and relies on internet for some of that function. the HomePod does function without internet as my default speaker for my Apple TV, but since the Apple TV is a streaming device, the content without internet is very limited to begin with.
Also, I use the older generation 4K but is there a way to connect the Homepod to something like a Blu Ray Player or just use it as your main speaker for everything or does it need to be tied directly to apple devices.
If I understand you correctly, what you're asking is actually what this article is about. The short answer is yes, there is, but only with the newest Apple TV4K that was just released. it supports an audio return channel apparently (this is awesome) and that means you can pipe audio to your tv and then to your Apple TV, and finally your HomePod. This means I could finally have xbox audio on my HomePod, (however I have doubts about latency for gaming).
 
  • Like
Reactions: sjsharksfan12
This is all very new to me, and I think I must be misunderstanding something. I have a stereo pair of original HomePods. If I follow the instructions here, would I be able to use the stereo pair of HomePods as speakers for a connected TiVo? Also, if that were to work, would the stereo pair of HomePods still function as "normal" when not being used as speakers for the TV, responding to Hey Siri, playing music, etc?
Maybe this might help.

If your television has Arc or eArc you can direct the sound from your television to the AppleTV which then uses the signal and puts it through the Homepods. What is connected to your television doesn't matter they use consoles as an example but it'd apply to your TiVo as well as any bluray or DVD player.

I'm gonna try this with my Bluray player, I was a little disheartened that I wasn't going to be able to enjoy my Homepods with my Bluray player but now it seems I can.
 
Or you could just buy a Sonos Beam sound bar (that supports ARC, Alexa, Google Home) and be done with it.
I actually just sold my Sonos beam to utilize my two original HomePods as a stereo setup. The HomePods sound soooo much better than the Sonos which I used for several years. Really night and day difference. The Sonos has horrible issues projecting speech. I could never hear what the characters were saying. HomePod changed everything for me. Bye subtitles!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.