Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The mouse was small for most hands, was not ergonomic for prolonged use but it looked great in marketing material and it was fine for light usage. I used it to basically rest a couple fingers on it and it was fine, resting the entire palm would have been problematic. I am not sure if it was people who were accustomed to cupping or testing the palm on it and didn’t know or had difficulty adapting it it was designed to rest a couple fingers on top of it with its single button use. The biggest flaw was not having a second button for contextual menus but that was Steve Jobs simplicity to the new user, children and elderly level of interaction.

Nothing stopping anyone from upgrading the mouse to multi button as many people I knew did for graphic design and video editing.
Reading this while one hand is on my mousepad, index finger lightly resting on my Magic Mouse II and my other fingers resting on the mousepad, not needing to grip the mouse. The index finger strokes the mouse and voila, scrolling happens... When I do need to do something more, the thumb and second or third finger hold the mouse and the either the index finger or the other finger clicks to create more action, such as right-clicking to bring up a menu.... I have no need for some big bulky mouse bristling with buttons and some sort of doohickey taking up one of my ports, as the MM II and its BT work perfectly fine for me.
 
AppleView
Released in late 2023, the AppleView was Apple’s first attempt at a VR/AR headset. Although there was a lot of excitement leading up to its release, people found it bulky, unwieldy, and uncomfortable to wear - and its starting price of $2,499 was prohibitive for many. Although it was an ambitious product with some handy features, ultimately it couldn’t compete against the Oculus and other headsets that were cheaper and had more support from developers.
 
Reading this while one hand is on my mousepad, index finger lightly resting on my Magic Mouse II and my other fingers resting on the mousepad, not needing to grip the mouse. The index finger strokes the mouse and voila, scrolling happens... When I do need to do something more, the thumb and second or third finger hold the mouse and the either the index finger or the other finger clicks to create more action, such as right-clicking to bring up a menu.... I have no need for some big bulky mouse bristling with buttons and some sort of doohickey taking up one of my ports, as the MM II and its BT work perfectly fine for me.

I am glad it works for you. Me, I liked the Mighty Mouse much more than the Magic Mouse.
 
I laughed when the Apple III was first shown. The 6502-based Commodore PET with 80 column display had been used in a few businesses but mostly computers running CP/M-80 had that role for small businesses.
 
I am glad it works for you. Me, I liked the Mighty Mouse much more than the Magic Mouse.
That was the one which had the narrow metal cover which went over the batteries? I definitely had no problem with the reusable batteries, but I was not happy when at least two times that metal cover cut me or if I dropped the mouse, which happened once when I was about to change batteries, the darned cover all-too-easily bent and was never as effective again. When the Magic Mouse I and later the II arrived I was more than happy -- no more metal cover to slice an innocent finger!
 
I nominate iPod Shuffle 3rd Generation to the club.
08a7b7bc-1f28-4e28-b72b-cbc3e1a5b66a_1.bc6a115e16f76adce5049a251af2d7da.jpeg
I got this waterproof and hooked onto my goggles and would listen to music/podcasts while swimming. Was a great solution!
 
Looking back, Jobs felt that Apple had lost its way. "First of all, it was too expensive — about ten grand," he said in an interview with Playboy in 1985. "We had gotten Fortune 500-itis, trying to sell to those huge corporations, when our roots were selling to people."
Imagine that... an Apple product being too expensive
 
Jerry Seinfeld, the character, owned a 20th Anniversary Mac. The show never showed us what he used it for, probably listening to music and streaming Nick At Night.
 
This article was nice.

Made me think through all my Apples:
- 1993 Apple Centris 650 (Got this to celebrate college graduation and getting my first corporate job.)
- 1997 Apple 1400CS laptop (I would say the Apple 100 -> Duo -> 1400/2400/3400 laptops were flops in terms of being terribly under-specd in terms of memory, CPU power and upgradability.)
- 2001 Apple PowerBook G3 Pismo - LOVED IT!!!!!! Work of Art!!! I stare at it as much as I stare at my 1966 Mercedes 230 SL roadster and my 1966 Ford Mustang - both white with black interior. Simply beautiful.
- 2001 Gen 1 Apple iPod - loved it! (Got my 2001 Pismo and iPod when I moved to Japan for Job #3.)
- 2003 Apple PowerBook G4 12-inch - too heavy and too thick
- 2007 Apple MacBook Pro 15 inch - the first Intel Apple I owned. Still use it. (Got this when I went to work for Dell!!!)
- 2007 Apple white MacBook - bought for my parents. Still use it.
- 2013 Apple iPhone 4 - took me a while to warm up to my 1st iPhone. I need my phone to be a phone, not a camera!
- 2013 Apple iPad Air - nice go-anywhere media tool.
- 2013 Apple wireless keyboard - LOVE IT!!! Still use it. (Got the 2013 products when I went to work for the NBA.)
- 2013 Apple MBP 15 inch - I am typing on it now. It is my current Apple notebook. Still runs and looks like new. To me, it has been the most perfect Apple product I have ever owned, perhaps aside from the Gen 1 iPod.
- 2014 Apple iPhone 6 - HATED IT!!!!! HATED IT!!!! Never felt such hate for an Apple product. Nearly divorced Apple.
- 2017 Apple iPhone SE - this is still the iPhone I use today. Though it is basically dead. Need a new phone ASAP. (Got this when I went to work for Amazon Web Services. AWS gave me a new MBP for the job.)

I have purchased other Apple goods. Can't recall the rest right now.

But I will say the worst of what I have owned by far:
1) 1400CS laptop - terribly underpowered
2) iPhone 6 - the worst... bad product design in every respect in my opinion.

The most "magical" Apple I have owned:
1) PBG3 Pismo
2) 2013 Apple wireless keyboard
3) Gen 1 iPod

The Apple product that has been the closest to perfect for me thus far:
1) The Apple I am typing on now: 2013 MBP 15 inch
2) Gen 1 iPod
3) 2013 Apple wireless keyboard

My relationship with Apple... it's been more extensive than I thought. And Apple has been the tool I have used to activate / accentuate / punctuate so many periods in my life. Magical indeed.
I bought a used G3 Pismo and you are 100% Right! Sleek, the bronze keys, the grippyness of the exterior, the glowing Apple. Oh, and fast! I too had a 140… POS😎
 
I genuinely do not understand the issue some people have with the Magic Mouse. I’ve been using one for years and have never had anything but excellent experiences with it. Can you tell me in what ways it disappoints?
I use mine Monday - Friday 7-8 hours a day… about every two months as I’m leaving Friday, I plug it in… Really not a big deal. Plug in the Magic Keyboard then too

Coachingguy
 
I always used a Logitech because I like to feel a wheel and like to have real buttons for Mission Control.
For 30+ yrs have used kensington then logitech solutions on the Mac because there have been very few usable mac mouses, and when there were some usable designs, they were not included in the box so I brought my own, or were offered in model years where I hadn’t purchased a new computer.

I have a magic mouse and trackpad but I don’t use them, because the logitech trackball is just more precise and less tiring for CAD work.
 
You guys missed a few honorable mentions:
The 4gb iPhone
Ipod hifi
Geoport (more a technology than a product)
Centris 610 & 650
OSX-only G4 MDD
 
Maybe not flops, but most (all?) of the Mac Classic models where just shadows of the models they replaced, for example SE/30 turned into Classic II that was just worse in almost every aspect.

Apple did a lot of questionable cost cutting in the 90's.
True. SE/30 (SEX) was the pinnacle of the original AIO design.

But the Classic II was a high volume seller.
 
You could add iPod HiFi, the Quicktake 200 Digital Camera (ahead of its time but too expensive and lacking software support) and eWorld to the list. I think by Apple’s standards the original HomePod would be considered a failure too.
I totally agree with everything on your list except the original HomePods, they are amazing!
 
That was and is probably my most favorite Mac of all time
Mine too. I always wanted one and was selling them. I used to go to it first before the others each work day. I just could never afford it....not on $9.65 an hour pay at the time. Just seeing it everyday caused my heart to race.
 
Also, this is one of the biggest hardware
failures of all time too. 🖱️

Why do we have to charge a Magic Mouse 2 like this in 2023? 😣

View attachment 2142068
Lol. What a non-issue. I can't believe people complain about this. Plug the mouse in before bed and it's charged for you in the morning. Plug it in and cook dinner or watch a TV show or any number of other things you do when you're not at your computer. It doesn't take long to charge up. Geez.

The whole point of a wireless mouse is that...it's not attached to the computer via a cable! I honestly can't understand people who want to use the mouse while charging. If a charge only lasted for a few hours, I'd understand. But it lasts for weeks. How hard is it to just plug it in once every few weeks? 🤯🤯🤯
 
Honestly the iPad is great at what it does. My mom has one and has had one for a number of years now. She can chat with people (Zoom/FaceTime etc), check her email, play games, post to social media etc. For her, anything more than that is overkill. She doesn't need a desktop or laptop when her iPad does what she needs it to do.

That to me is the genious of the iPad - simplicity
Then wants the deal with iPad Pro?
 
Power Mac G4 Cube

apple-g4-cube.jpg

I still have my Cube G4, upgraded with a dual Powerlogix CPU of some description. My Sonnet 1.4GHz Cube died during a hot summer about 10 years ago due to a common power regulator failure.

I replaced the HDD with a 64GB SSD and added a 500 RPM fan in the base. I still use it at my culture school here in Tokyo, since it runs the original SpongeBob SquarePants typing software faster than the current repackaged Intel version on sale in the App Store and still manages Pages and Keynote without breaking into a sweat.

Of course the kids are oblivious to just how iconic the machine is, but plenty of their dads remember seeing one or even owning one back in the day and often tinker around with it between their kids' lessons. It was actually quite successful over here and they can still be picked up s/h in near mint condition super cheap from time to time. The monitor is toast, though, so I use it with a regular LCD panel, unfortunately.

For me, the G4 Cube will always remain, along with the G4 Lampshades and to a lesser extent the Trashcan Pro, icons of industrial design, often pushing the designs of then contemporary machines well beyond the comfort zone, even at the expense of practicality: Style over Substance, if you will.

It's ironic, then, that today, given how low-power Apple Silicon is, that any of these form factors would actually be entirely usable and maybe even practical. A sign that perhaps they were just far too ahead of their time.

RIP Steve Jobs.
 
One could also argue that the Mac IIfx was kind of a flop.

I think I have read that Apple shipped it with A/UX and tried to compete with the UNIX workstations from HP, Sun etc.

As a regular Mac it was just way too expensive and contained specialized hardware that Mac OS didn't take advantage of.

Also it was produced for only 2 years before the Quadras came and took over.

But It was a very nice machine and I appreciate the no holds barred approach Apple took and made the fastest computer they could.
I think the Mac IIfx was a very niche product. It was extremely fast (for it's time), and the price was extremely high ($10K USD in 1992 for the max out version). It may have been developed for the US Government, and I'm guessing they were happy with that machine.

SourcE: https://www.apple-history.com/iifx
 
I loved the Cube. I passed on purchasing one though. As the Cube would heat up and oool down repeatedly, tiny cracks would form on the rounded corners at the top of the acrylic case.

Just an anecdote from Y2K, Japan:

This heat defect was a common misconception, an urban myth, if you will, since most of the heat was contained within a thick, interior metal casing that shielded the acrylic from most of the heat.

The tiny cracks in the rounded corners of the case were actually caused during the moulding process... Apple faced a distinctly high number of returns here in Japan, where people expected their premium products to be basically flawless in appearance.

At least over here, the "cracks suddenly appearing" was attributed to an article in a popular Mac magazine that first pointed out the defects. Many people hadn't even noticed them... But once they saw them, they couldn't unsee them... and so they started to take their boxes back to Apple stating "suddenly appeared overnight", who ended up having to replace a whole bunch of cases. It was then that an internal memo was apparently released which stated that unless the cracks were physically detectible by running a finger over the affected area, they were merely natural, inevitable manifestations of the moulding process and were not to be covered by the warranty.

This lead to a lot of angry folk and negative press which caused sales to slump.

But by then, the Cube's writing was already on the wall anyway, and the plug was pulled within the year.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.