Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

Apple's iPhone 6s Battery Case: iOS Integration Is Nice, but Better Options Exist

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
51,479
13,107



Apple's new first party iPhone 6s Smart Battery Case launched quietly overnight onto the company's online store, and now this morning a handful of sites around the web are publishing reviews for the new accessory. Most reviewers agree that it's time Apple acknowledged the lesser battery life of the 4.7 inch iPhone 6s, when in comparison to its 5.5 inch iPhone 6s Plus alternative, but some still aren't convinced that the case's design, power, and price point are justified.

Image via Engadget

The Verge appreciated Apple's attempts at expanding the case's functionality beyond a simple battery extension, like its built-in antennas to improve cellular performance or the iOS integration that showcases the accessory's current battery level. Still, the site had issues with the protruding lump on the back of the case and the fact that it doesn't fully charge a dead iPhone from 0 to 100 percent due to its slightly weaker (when in comparison to comparable third party cases) 1,877 mAh battery.

The Verge also noted that the Smart Battery Case doesn't allow users to choose when the case begins or ends charging, it just starts the moment you plug the iPhone 6s into the case's Lightning adapter, perhaps a downside for more intensive iPhone users. In the end, they noted that casual, passive users who want to stay within the Apple family will get what they need out of the case, but that there are cheaper alternatives with more battery life selling points on the market.

Apple's smart battery case is good, then, if you want a softer case or a "passive" battery charging experience, with zero control over or understanding of how the case actually charges your phone. Maybe that's what Apple is hoping: that buyers of this thing will slip it on and never take it off, charging their iPhones entirely through the case's Lightning port going forward, forgetting about its big ol' bump in the back. They will be pleased, finally, with their iPhone 6's or 6S's battery life, and the memory of spending an extra $99 for it, rather than having it just work that way in the first place, will eventually fade away.

It's fine if you don't want exterior indicator lights, or a even a case that gives you a 0 to 100 percent charge. After all, this one was designed for the iPhone, by the same company that made your iPhone. For some people, that's a big draw.
As opposed to The Verge's dislike over any lack of outward LED indicator lights regarding the Smart Battery Case's charge level, The Wall Street Journal appreciated Apple's attempt at discreetness. The site was overall more positive on the new product, noting that while the case's fully charged battery only brought an iPhone from 0 to 83 percent, it still provided about 5 hours more use time in a standard looping video battery test and alleviated most battery life quibbles the reviewer had with the iPhone 6s previously.
After five days of living with the Smart Battery Case wrapped around my iPhone, I no longer feel so powerless. Even better, Apple fixes many of the issues I've had with cases over the years. It uses the same Lightning cable as the iPhone to charge, and it tells you how much power is remaining right on the phone's screen. Besides, the case doesn't feel like the stuff plastic forks are made of.

For all its virtues, the Smart Battery Case is still a Band-Aid for Apple's iPhone battery problem. We need longer-lasting batteries and easier ways to charge them--not silly battery backpacks. I plan to spend the $99, but I hope one day the Smart Battery Case will just be an artifact from a time before iPhones could run for days.
Engadget admitted to disliking the design of the case's battery bump upon initially viewing it, but grew to become familiar with the battery protrusion. The site noted that while some may dislike the visual design of the accessory, it "isn't cumbersome" to hold for extended periods of time and is "actually pretty comfortable," although the usual stickiness of silicone in tight jean pockets will remain an issue for some. In a similar vein to other reviews, Engadget ended with stating that those tied into the Apple ecosystem will benefit from the Smart Battery Case's iOS integration, but most others can find cheaper alternatives.

Image via Engadget
Apple's first battery case works, and it works well. Here's the rub, though: There are plenty of cheaper, more capacious options, and some of those are prettier too. What the Smart Battery Case offers over its rivals is a sense of cohesiveness that stems from Apple controlling both the hardware and software experience. The convenience of a Lightning pass-through for easy data transfers and power reminders in iOS might make the case's $99 price worth it for some of you, but everyone else could spend half that on a third-party case.
Those interested in trying out the iPhone 6s Smart Battery Case for themselves, or purchasing it for someone as a Christmas present, can visit the Apple online store to order the new accessory. Shipping estimates currently sit at 1-3 business days, and those who live near an Apple Store will be able to select a personal pickup option, as well.

Article Link: Apple's iPhone 6s Battery Case: iOS Integration Is Nice, but Better Options Exist
 

Digital Skunk

macrumors 604
Dec 23, 2006
7,997
656
In my imagination
It really is nice of Apple to try, but yes, there are better options out there. The title of the thread is the understatement of the century.

Such drama.

Such truth. Steve would've never made the case for a case like this . . . . . questionable.

I have a good feeling he would've at the very least, made the case to be one solid battery all around like the Mophie options. The wart in the back is a bit odd and unsettling.
 
Last edited:
Comment

puma1552

Suspended
Nov 20, 2008
5,559
1,945
I have no need for this as my 6 is usually above 80% by the time my 18 hour waking day is done, but I think it's pretty lame you can't get a full charge out of this. Clearly there is enough space for them to have put a battery in big enough to charge the phone completely.

But I have a suspicion that the reason they didn't do this, and allowed the hump to protrude rather than just having a uniformly fat case, is again, thinness - they don't want people to think the phone is fat, so they want people to see that the extra bulk is indeed, extra.
 
Comment

jayducharme

macrumors 68040
Jun 22, 2006
3,931
3,995
The thick of it
I guess I'm fortunate in that I've never experienced that "battery problem" that everyone seems to be complaining about. My iPhone 6 easily lasts me about two days on a single charge. What I've found kills the battery fastest is actually talking on the phone, which I don't do that often. For data usage like texting, e-mail, browsing, games, I find that the iPhone has plenty of power for what I do.

And I can't imagine Apple making an uglier case. Really. It's just awful.
 
Comment

KPOM

macrumors P6
Oct 23, 2010
16,018
4,784
Full-blown review units were sent in advance. Interesting. I'm surprised they didn't have this ready for the keynote. Maybe they are just testing the waters on a line of first-party accessories.
 
Comment

loby

macrumors 65816
Jul 1, 2010
1,149
761
Steve Job's Apple is officially dead...


Ivy probably did not design it....Probably in England and let his "boys" do it as he transitions out...

I know everyone is getting tired of the "Steve would never..." thing, but this time it is true. When the designers brought this to him, he would have said, "It sucks...bring me back something that is amazing.."

This is ugly and not in-line with the usual esthetics and eye pleasing designs we have been seeing from Apple for the last ten years or so. Sigh...
 
Comment

barkomatic

macrumors 601
Aug 8, 2008
4,159
1,959
Manhattan
Perhaps this is part of Apple's strategy to make an even thinner iPhone in the future. They can make an iPhone 7 at half the current thickness of the 6s but giving it a battery that lasts 2 hours without an Apple external battery pack.

This is ridiculous. Fix the internal battery and make the iPhone a little thicker if necessary but don't use these crappy workarounds.
 
Comment

friedmud

macrumors 65816
Jul 11, 2008
1,320
1,081
I think it looks decent, and I like the simplicity. I think many of you are overthinking this one.

I like what Apple is doing here. Provide a thin, light phone for the 90% of us that don't have any issues with battery life and a battery case for those that need more. Much better than saddling us all with a thick phone.

For me, I haven't run out of battery on my phone since I upgraded to a 6+.
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.