Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
If I could get iCloud Photos just to sync the most recent 2000 photos, that would be great. But I’ve got several terabytes of photos. Completely different beast.

Your presumably don't have several TB of photos on your phone. So the answer is quite simple (I used this method to remove all photos from before a significant date from iCloud):

 
Your presumably don't have several TB of photos on your phone. So the answer is quite simple (I used this method to remove all photos from before a significant date from iCloud):

Thanks a lot. That is the best post in the whole thread. A great workaround For people with huge libraries.
 
My issue with people wanting something for free is how is it free? Nothing Google is doing for you is free. They had Google photos as “free“ for a while, just to train their AI. Now it’s not “free“ because they don’t need your data as much. Anything online is either going to be paid, supported by advertisements or supported by gathering your data. If I had the choice of those three options when it comes to my iCloud account, I would pick the one that’s paid. Perhaps someone else might choose to trade their data or watch ads for free storage but I don’t see Apple doing that
As the saying goes, “if you can’t figure out what the product is, it’s because it’s you”.
 
So now if I have a 200 GB Photos library I am forced to buy the extra 200 GB iCloud storage because it insists on storing every single photo... My Photo Stream was awesome in that it only stored the latest photos which would get transferred over, and then it would no longer have to store them since they were now saved on every device, no need to store them online forever.

Or alternatively if I don't use iCloud Photos then the only way to transfer photos over is to do it one by one with AirDrop.

iCloud is good and I am paying for the 200GB service but it's silly to waste it on Photos that are stored on my computer anyway, there is no need for them to ever be in the cloud, except for the 1 minute during which they get sent from the phone to the computer.
I am thinking of moving to another Cloud Storage platform OR buying NAS.
 
... why do I need/want images that I took 10+ years ago on every device?
I find it very useful to have access to all my photos on my devices. Very frequently when I am at a friends place for dinner or drinks a conversation comes up about a trip from years past or a restaurant or a group activity etc. and in less than a minute I am usually able to show them a photo or more about the topic under discussion. Just my opinion of course.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baywatchboy
I can back up my iOS device on Google, Amazon, Backblaze, etc? I can do a system level backup? Where it saves app settings, storage, messages, etc?
I mean, yes. You have to do the extra step of backing it up using a cable to a computer but you can set the target directory as something on cloud storage and toss your nice encrypted iPhone backup up there automatically every time you back it up
 
I'm surprised Photo Stream lasted as long as it did. Between being really helpful AND letting you (temporarily) store vast numbers of photos without it counting against iCloud storage limits, it was something that was almost too good to be true. 😅

This is kind of like when Google Photos stopped letting people back up all their photos to the cloud for free.
 


Apple's "My Photo Stream" service is set to shut down on July 26, 2023, which means customers who are still using that feature will need to transition to using iCloud Photos prior to that date.

icloud-photos.jpg

My Photo Stream is a free service that uploads the last 30 days of images (up to 1,000) to iCloud, making them accessible on the iPhone, iPad, iPod touch, Mac, and PC. It predates iCloud Photos and has largely been replaced by the iCloud Photos service at this point.

Going forward, Apple plans to have all customers use iCloud Photos instead of My Photo Stream. New photo uploads to My Photo Stream will stop on June 26, 2023, and images will remain in iCloud as usual for 30 days until the shutdown point.

Because all of the images in My Photo Stream are stored in their original format on at least one Apple device, there isn't a danger of photos being lost as part of the shutdown process. Apple recommends that users who want to have their images on a particular device save them to the Photo Library on that device prior to July 26.

macos-mojave-photos-my-photo-stream.jpg

Images in My Photo Stream can be saved to the Photos app on the iPhone by opening up Photos, going to the My Photo Stream album, selecting individual photos, and using the Share button to save them to the Library. The process is the same on the Mac, but you will need to drag images from My Photo Stream to the Library.

Apple suggests that iPhone, iPad, and Mac users turn on iCloud Photos to view their photos and videos across their devices. iCloud Photos is available on iPhones and iPads running iOS 8.3 or later and Macs running OS X Yosemite or later.

Article Link: Apple's 'My Photo Stream' Service Shutting Down in July 2023
**** them. Good. Now I won’t ever lose any videos because I’ll get back into the habit of connecting my iPhone to my Mac often and sync everything the old-school way. Or maybe I’ll get into the habit of manually syncing them via WiFi if that is still an option, we’ll see. Maybe I’ll even create some AppleScript or shortcut that opens Photos.app periodically to ensure that happens. I’m very happy with my enterprise OneDrive/SharePoint account and I’m not paying Apple a single cent for their overpriced cloud storage.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I can see giving a third-party app like dropbox access to system level settings would be a privacy and security nightmare. The back up on iCloud when it comes to that is pretty much the current state of your phone so it would be like them having access to everything on your phone or at least I would think so.

My only android phone is for work, so I don’t bother with the settings to see how I can back it up. I figure if there’s anything needing to be backed up, the system administrator will take care of it. I don’t even know if you can back up the complete state of an android phone and restore it like the iPhone does.

So here’s an idea that Tim will never let happen: make system backups not count against storage caps. Make iCloud storage purely photos, app settings, messages, etc.
 
5GB is paid for by the price of the device. 10GB would only increase the price of the device. Since I already pay for 2TB, I rather not increase the free storage. 10GB doesn't even change anything for most people. 5GB is more than enough for metadata and was never meant to host all of your photos or do full iPhone backups.
I’m just telling you what I have personally seen several times. It just seems strange that it goes straight from 5 to 50. For one dollar. So by that math it would increase the price of the device by twenty cents. I think it’s worth it.
 
I’m just telling you what I have personally seen several times. It just seems strange that it goes straight from 5 to 50. For one dollar. So by that math it would increase the price of the device by twenty cents. I think it’s worth it.
why are you calculating only by one month? device is going to live for at least 5, but your storage account lives for life even after you dump your iPhone for Android. we're talking 10+ years. even those that left iPhone 10+ years ago will get double the storage.

then there's opportunity cost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brucemr
Oh, great. Not only do I now have to upgrade my iCloud storage to 2TB to be able to store *all* my photos (since I can't tell it to only do a subset, as far as I know), but my internet data cap will be *killed* as my computer tries to upload everything at once.

Talk about an expensive change :(
Go where there is free Wi-Fi.
 
Gotta get those subscriptions numbers up!

Good point. I may buy more Apple stock as I'm pondering a supercycle surge in iCloud storage upgrades. If 100 million people upgrade to the $9.99 plan that's huge. It's a big if, and requires more thought before I make any new investments, but I see this as potentially very good news for APPL investors.
 
It might have been useless to some people, but I personally liked the fact that when I took a photo on my phone, it showed up on my computer - WITHOUT having to pay for the privilege of having all 18,000 photos in my library stored in the cloud.

Exactly this. Ironically I don’t mind paying for iCloud storage since I’m on 200gb plan but I already pay for google photos (2TB) and OneDrive (1TB). To me, photo stream was just an easy way to get newly taken photos across my devices without having to deliberately transfer or airdrop them.

From memory theres an easy way to copy paste content between devices on iCloud account so I’ll see if that works for photos somehow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: b17777
I have used this service for as long as I can remember on all my Apple devices. Since those are old (some of them are running as old MacOS as 10.7) this announcement effectively removes my ability to share photos between my devices that don't support shared streams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: b17777
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.