Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Sean76

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Feb 10, 2013
665
406
NYC
Ok so I've been using apples silicone cases since they first came out, I've always liked the quality feel of them, and the bottom cut out never bothered me since I thought it gave off a pretty cool contrast between the color of the phone and the case color (especially Product Red) against a black iPhone.

We'll move to the iPhone X were I purchased quite a few colors of Apples pricy silicone cases to go with my pricey new phone.

Black is always a great choice, product red, midnight blue, dark olive, and the ever clean looking white for when I'm in full panda mode with my space gray X.

I have no idea what Apple has done here with the materials of these cases for the X, but I think I'm kind in saying they are pretty dam horrible. The material is very different than that of what has been used before. A simple way to describe it would be high quality vs cheap!!!

I noticed after only a day of use with any of the colors except the white that it feels as though the color wears right off and shine begins to show! I thought I was just going crazy! But when I put a fairly used 6 months or so very much used iPhone 7plus product red silicone case next to my brand new iPhone X silicone case the differences scream cheapness. The new X case has a considerable amount of shine coming through, and you can basically see the print of my 2 fingers where I hold the phone almost imbedded into the case, where the older after all it's use still looks and feels new. Same for the black in a big way, the dark olive, and midnight black. All the mid to dark colors show a considerable amount of use and wear in a very short period of time.

In the past, a damp paper towel with a lite whipe across the case would have it looking brand new again? Now it looks as though Apple has changed its materials, as you will be able to see and feel with the Apple logo as it looks to be printed on and you can't feel the raise anymore as you would in the older cases.

It's apparent Apple has gone in a direction of using a lesser material, and to me that's not cool when these cases cost a cool $39 each.

I'm all for charging a premium for a premium feeling product, but I'm not for changing materials and still charging those premium prices. The $39 honestly doesn't bother me, it's the $39 for an inferior product!
 
I went with the leather as the material has far too much dust and feels weird in the hand when sweaty
 
I used the silicone case from Apple and my biggest complaint was the amount of debris that migrated between the case and phone. I highly suggest that you take it off often as the debris will scuff/scratch your phone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WSPAN1C
I don't think they're horrible. But I feel as though they are overpriced. I have an apple silicone case and I brought a 3rd party silicone case and it's the same exact quality. But the 3rd party cost me only $10 vs the $50 I spent on the apple version . The only difference is logo at the back.
 
I got one for my X, and replaced it with a Spigen tough armor. I sadly missed the return date for the case, so now its collecting dust until I decide what to do with it (if anything).
 
  • Like
Reactions: eltoslightfoot
I got black one. I'm not a fan of bottom cutout otherwise I like the overall fit and finish of the Apple case.

I got one for my X, and replaced it with a Spigen tough armor. I sadly missed the return date for the case, so now its collecting dust until I decide what to do with it (if anything).
Can you post pictures of the iPhone with case. I want to see how much bluk it adds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BradCN
I never thought much of the silicone cases but have always liked the Apple leather case. The X model is similar to the previous models. Very nice quality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CharlesShaw
I got the black one and love it. I think it makes the phone look — and feel — even more stylish. Works very well with my grey iPhone X.
 
Have black silicone and tan leather Apple cases for 8 Plus. The silicone does attract dust but the grip is really good and the all black looks really good.

The leather case looks good, less grip and no dust sticking to it.

I have noticed the silicone black is changing color ..getting darker..at the top 25%.

Depending on what I’m doing each has a role.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbital~debris
I got one for my X, and replaced it with a Spigen tough armor. I sadly missed the return date for the case, so now its collecting dust until I decide what to do with it (if anything).

How do you like the tough armor? I got a ultra hybrid S and love it.
 
How do you like the tough armor? I got a ultra hybrid S and love it.
Its good, a bit bulkier then the silicon case, but I've gotten used to it. Unlike the Slim Armor from Spigen this case has edges and I find those helpful in that it increases the grippiness (if that's a word). Overall I'm happy with it, and definitely enjoy the extra protection this offers over the silicon case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jordan921
In the past before the X silicone cases, yes pretty much all the dark colors would be dust magets. After a day or two that would stop and honestly the cases would just look good and do the job of staying fairly grippy.

For my 7plus I rotated a product red, midnight blue, and black for the better half of 6 months and they all pretty much kept their color and stayed looking new!

The best part of the apple cases, and this matters in the long run. Any chips, wear and tear, or ripping in the case would just result in me dropping by Apple and handing of the old one and them replacing it with a brand new one. Apple is awesome for stuff like that with accessories.
 
Its good, a bit bulkier then the silicon case, but I've gotten used to it. Unlike the Slim Armor from Spigen this case has edges and I find those helpful in that it increases the grippiness (if that's a word). Overall I'm happy with it, and definitely enjoy the extra protection this offers over the silicon case.

Since I came from a 7plus I didn’t mind the bulkier cases.
 
I would never put a case on the $1000 fashion icon that is iphone 10. You don't like fashion then get samsung.
 
Since I came from a 7plus I didn’t mind the bulkier cases.
I got used to the increased bulk, its not a huge deal imo

I would never put a case on the $1000 fashion icon that is iphone 10. You don't like fashion then get samsung.
Because I paid 1,000 dollars I'm putting a case on the phone. I'd rather not take a chance and incurring any damage. Also, I opted to buy the iPhone X for reasons other then making a fashion statement or showing off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mofly_9 and tkukoc
The best part of the apple cases, and this matters in the long run. Any chips, wear and tear, or ripping in the case would just result in me dropping by Apple and handing of the old one and them replacing it with a brand new one. Apple is awesome for stuff like that with accessories.

Not me. When I experienced a cut in the Apple silicon case and tried to get a replacement Apple refused, saying it was normal wear and tear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mofly_9
Not me. When I experienced a cut in the Apple silicon case and tried to get a replacement Apple refused, saying it was normal wear and tear.

Really? I've replaced like 3 of them over the last few years. I do go in with the original packaging though and pretty much explain I'm looking to exchange it for the same exact case, same color and all and have never had a problem.

I have the dark olive on now and I can't believe the amount of dust this thing collects.
 
I’ve had the white silicone case for just over two weeks. No complaints! Super high quality Apple product. Great fit and feel. I love the grippy silky feel. No discoloring. It doesn’t collect major dust. I’m a huge fan of the bottom cutout because it shows off some of the band.
 
Last edited:
Really? I've replaced like 3 of them over the last few years. I do go in with the original packaging though and pretty much explain I'm looking to exchange it for the same exact case, same color and all and have never had a problem.

I have the dark olive on now and I can't believe the amount of dust this thing collects.
Not me. When I experienced a cut in the Apple silicon case and tried to get a replacement Apple refused, saying it was normal wear and tear.

Don't the apple cases have a one year warranty? Although it's clearly passed this point, if you ever experience that again, maybe you could speak with a different rep, the manager (or even a different store if you're in an area with multiple stores)

There's so many stories of people getting exchanges, etc, that I'm guessing it might simply be the rep you speak to.

I'd always try again (or even reach out to customer service).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sean76
Don't the apple cases have a one year warranty? Although it's clearly passed this point, if you ever experience that again, maybe you could speak with a different rep, the manager (or even a different store if you're in an area with multiple stores)

There's so many stories of people getting exchanges, etc, that I'm guessing it might simply be the rep you speak to.

I'd always try again (or even reach out to customer service).

Even if the damage is from your user neglect or a drop?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.