Am I the only one disgusted by these combo deals? It's essentially AT&T saying that "we are ripping you off, but we feel kinda bad about ripping you off so hard on two difference services, so we'll give you a little bit of a discount, cuz you know, we can afford to do that." They might as well just say that their prices aren't fair.
You aren't the only one, but my mom and I aren't among them. She's been using an old RAZR V3XX for years, one I bought myself in 2006, but ATTWS is shutting down the "2G" network this year - and she's in a fringe area (look up Skamokawa, and you'll get it!

). I sampled MVNOs, including Cricket, but there were too many service holes. And, I wanted ATTWS service again as my VZW service doesn't go everywhere, despite their blather to the contrary - so we ended up with two identical 64GB iPhone 6S handsets on ATTWS's BOGO deal that ended on 12/31 but purchased at a local Best Buy, which added in a $200 gift card (used to pay for most of AC on both handsets). Got the 5GB data plan, which we're still on, but for a few more bucks we can sign up for UL data - we can always go back to a shared bucket...
Mom's already with DTV - no cable, no fiber (again, Skamokawa...), and she needs her Antiques Roadshow and NCIS out there. I may pop for a third line, and get the "free" fourth to go along with it.
I had UL data with ATTWS in Portland until I couldn't take all of the call dropping a few years ago but it's much improved. What you wrote - I get it, and the deal works for us right now. I've written in MR's forums about T-Mo's service - we're in AK, WA, OR, ID - and there's holes out here bigger than most of the Eastern states. That, and I'll use the data - Mom will love this newfangled "Apple Music" thing (she went to Aerosmith with us twice, so get that "Glenn Miller" thing out of your head!

).
So, discounted "free" iPhone and AC, great coverage, UL data/text/voice. Yep, sign us up - mainly since we don't have many alternatives!