But under contract in the old plans you were paying for the cost of the phone with inflated plan costs. Now the plans are cheaper and you actually pay for the phone. The old way was less cost affective IMHO.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AT&T Doubling Data on Mobile Share Value Plans in Limited Time Promotion
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
But under contract in the old plans you were paying for the cost of the phone with inflated plan costs. Now the plans are cheaper and you actually pay for the phone. The old way was less cost affective IMHO.
Thanks for doing the math guys. Loving the competition from T-Mobile and Sprint. Too bad that for me (Family share plan of 5 lines with NEW 30GB pricing) AT&T still more expensive than T-Mobile. I bought my iPhone 6 Plus unlocked but three members of my family are buying two iPhone 6 Plus and one iPhone 6 with Next. With AT&T the total would be about $310 per month. Comparing this to T-Mobile (one line unlimited and the other four with 4.5GB each) it comes out to $278 per month. That is $32 savings every month or $768 in two years. That savings pays off a brand new iPhone by itself. Not to mention the other benefits that T-Mobile offers like unlimited data and free data for streaming music.
I wish Australia had something like this, or unlimited.
I'm going up with Vodafone from my $50 a month plan for a iPhone 5 32GB with 750MB Data, to $89 a month for iPhone 6+ 128GB with 3GB data. Rather not have to worry about data, but at least wifi at home I'll never run out of (unless I go over 200GB a month).
I'm going up with Vodafone from my $50 a month plan for a iPhone 5 32GB with 750MB Data, to $89 a month for iPhone 6+ 128GB with 3GB data. Rather not have to worry about data, but at least wifi at home I'll never run out of (unless I go over 200GB a month).
Just call in and get updated to the new plan. There is no penalty for changing plans anytime as long as you remain a customer.
I did, but from my phone so I am going to try the computer then call if needed. OK so it was there the whole time lol even on my phone but it was labeled as a 30GB plan so i overlooked it. I think if they had labeled it 15GB bonus x2 or something it would have been less confusing to me. Or maybe I was just sleepy, it was late. Choose 40 GB which is the 20 I currently am on. With 10 devices now we should always be good on data.. YAYA no more family data Nazi
Last edited:
The T-Mobile ETF credit requires you to turn in a device and then it only credits you the value of the device. Not worth it.
----------
Call and request new plan and your in.
I am also not telling anyone on my plan about the new cap. MWAAHAHAHAHA. IT'S ALL MINE ALLL MINE!!!11!11!!!111
I want to have the monthly access on the phones to only be $15.00. Since I am in a contract I am paying $80.00 a month for two lines. If I drop it to $30.00 a month it would pay the $650.00 ETF charge off in 13 months.
I just don't want to overpay on my phones for the next 2 years. I am going to call ATT and check options.
Just switched from AT&T (grandfathered unlimited plan from original iPhone) to T-Mobile last weekend. Went from $150/mo. to $100/mo. Here are all the places my plan is better than AT&T:
- Unlimited phone minutes (had rollover minutes w/ AT&T)
- Unlimited Texts (had 200/month)
- Personal hotspot included (not included w/ AT&T)
- Streaming from the major music apps (T-Mo says top 15) don't count towards your data (not w/ AT&T)
- 3GB data per line with only throttling if you go over => no additional charges
While I understand my last item would be a problem for some people, it isn't for me. I'm around Wi-fi probably 98% of my days and when I am traveling, I'm usually only streaming music/sports radio so this doesn't count against my data usage anyway. I'm fine with being throttled should I go over the 3GB from time to time as I know that my monthly bill will always be $100.
I've only ever been with AT&T since my first cell phone. I'm happy to have switched now. While my coverage may suffer some, again, I'm located in Atlanta and have solid coverage throughout. Wish I had made this change long ago. So happy for the competition.
Throttling on Shared Data Plan Question
Hey Folks,
Does AT&T throttle users that are on a shared data plan as they do for individuals on an unlimited data plan?
The throttling done at 5GB on my iPhone puts me back to 1995 dial-up speeds. It is quite annoying. If I could move to 30GB on a shared plan then that means that I wouldn't be throttling and have sustained performance through 30GB and save our family money in the process.
That is my logic anyway.
Dru
Hey Folks,
Does AT&T throttle users that are on a shared data plan as they do for individuals on an unlimited data plan?
The throttling done at 5GB on my iPhone puts me back to 1995 dial-up speeds. It is quite annoying. If I could move to 30GB on a shared plan then that means that I wouldn't be throttling and have sustained performance through 30GB and save our family money in the process.
That is my logic anyway.
Dru
These prices are just insane... People are willing to pay $2k / per year for cell data?!? A smoker with one of these plan could actually stop smoking, go WiFi and buy a car 
Did some math on the following use case
Note: The cost below does no include the plan one chooses. Only Smartphone Data Access charges and hardware costs.
Use Case - iPhone 6 64GB
AT&T Next - Smartphone Cost $749.00 off contract
AT&T Next - Access for Smartphone over 24-mth $360.00 ($15 per month)
Total = $1,109 over 2 years
vs.
AT&T 2-year Commitment - Smartphone Cost $300
AT&T Mobile Share Line Access over 24-mth - $960 ($40 per month for iPhone 6 according to AT&T)
Total = $1,260 over 2 years
Therefore, AT&T Next approach is cheaper for folks compared to do a two-year commitment.
If you want to upgrade to a new phone then you will be paying extra IF you don't sell your previous phone.
I sold my iPhone 5 on eBay for $250.00 and then went the 2-year commitment route. Therefore, over 24-mth it would cost me $1,260 - $250 = $1,010.
I should note that I currently have unlimited data and currently saving more money than what is stated above but I would like to have more data access at high speeds and being throttled does not work for me. Plus I can save more money by going Mobile Share with my wife and two other family members; combined they use about 5GB a month. I could potentially pay less and have access to 25GB.
Note: The cost below does no include the plan one chooses. Only Smartphone Data Access charges and hardware costs.
Use Case - iPhone 6 64GB
AT&T Next - Smartphone Cost $749.00 off contract
AT&T Next - Access for Smartphone over 24-mth $360.00 ($15 per month)
Total = $1,109 over 2 years
vs.
AT&T 2-year Commitment - Smartphone Cost $300
AT&T Mobile Share Line Access over 24-mth - $960 ($40 per month for iPhone 6 according to AT&T)
Total = $1,260 over 2 years
Therefore, AT&T Next approach is cheaper for folks compared to do a two-year commitment.
If you want to upgrade to a new phone then you will be paying extra IF you don't sell your previous phone.
I sold my iPhone 5 on eBay for $250.00 and then went the 2-year commitment route. Therefore, over 24-mth it would cost me $1,260 - $250 = $1,010.
I should note that I currently have unlimited data and currently saving more money than what is stated above but I would like to have more data access at high speeds and being throttled does not work for me. Plus I can save more money by going Mobile Share with my wife and two other family members; combined they use about 5GB a month. I could potentially pay less and have access to 25GB.
You want a 50GB Plan, they offer a 60GB Plan now for the price of the 30GB Plan. Go for it.... Or do you think it is only fair for you to pay $30 (the cost of the 2GB Plan) and then you get a 50GB Plan?
I think I would like to tell Apple I want a 2014 Macbook Pro retina for the cost of a 2007 Macbook.
LOL
To those still unsure of how the NEXT plans are BETTER for many I will show my usage.
We have 7 lines, 3 of which are smartphones, 3 are flip phones, 1 is a hotspot and we will ignore it.
With the NEXT and my original 10GB plan, I "lost" the 2 year upgrade at a discounted rate but gained a $25 per month discount on each line, which brings me from $40 per line to $15 per line.
Over the course of two years 25 * 24 = $600
If you only buy the base model iPhone 6, tack on $200. So, as it stands, you are now spending $600 (due to the $40 per month line fees) + $200 for the upgrade to the phone on the OLD non share plans. That means that $650 iPhone 6 16GB cost you $800+
On my NEXT plan I pay again $15 per line + the cost of the device over 24 months.
So I get a discount on my line of $25 per month, and I pay for the device (full price at MSRP) over 24 months. Considering that you HAVE to pay for service, there is no cheaper way of doing it unless you can switch to T-Mobile and go with the 4 lines for $100 thing.
So now, I pay $360 every two years per line + device cost (roughly $689 after tax for base model) which = $1049 for two years.
On the old plan you pay $960 every two years per line + device cost at $230 minimum for the base model (including that nice upgrade fee!) which = $1190.
Now factor in those numbers for each model and the higher end models will cost you even more.
Edit : And yeah I was beat above .. oh well, maths are still good.
We have 7 lines, 3 of which are smartphones, 3 are flip phones, 1 is a hotspot and we will ignore it.
With the NEXT and my original 10GB plan, I "lost" the 2 year upgrade at a discounted rate but gained a $25 per month discount on each line, which brings me from $40 per line to $15 per line.
Over the course of two years 25 * 24 = $600
If you only buy the base model iPhone 6, tack on $200. So, as it stands, you are now spending $600 (due to the $40 per month line fees) + $200 for the upgrade to the phone on the OLD non share plans. That means that $650 iPhone 6 16GB cost you $800+
On my NEXT plan I pay again $15 per line + the cost of the device over 24 months.
So I get a discount on my line of $25 per month, and I pay for the device (full price at MSRP) over 24 months. Considering that you HAVE to pay for service, there is no cheaper way of doing it unless you can switch to T-Mobile and go with the 4 lines for $100 thing.
So now, I pay $360 every two years per line + device cost (roughly $689 after tax for base model) which = $1049 for two years.
On the old plan you pay $960 every two years per line + device cost at $230 minimum for the base model (including that nice upgrade fee!) which = $1190.
Now factor in those numbers for each model and the higher end models will cost you even more.
Edit : And yeah I was beat above .. oh well, maths are still good.
Do you have a Mobile Share Plan? If so, I'm calling BS. You only pay the tax on the phone up front of you do a NEXT plan and then choose what term to pay for the phone.
If you did a 2 year upgrade on the Mobile Share Plan, you pay $200 plus tax (or whatever the contract price is) and then your monthly charge for the phone line goes from $15 to $40 a month.
If you did a 2 year upgrade on a regular rate plan you pay $200 plus tax and continue to pay more per month in service charges because the phone subsidy is included in the rate plan.
In essence, if you want a new phone every year or every other year, you won't save any money. The only way to save money on AT&T is to have a mobile share plan and have a fully paid for phone.
There's no throttling on the mobile shared plans. You also gain the ability to tether with the mobile hotspot feature, which is not allowed under the unlimited plan.
The only problem I've had getting the new cap is that I get the error message "changes are currently bein made to your account" on the app, online, and when I called in to AT&T.
The reason is that my iPhone's haven't arrived yet, so until they are activated I won't be able to increase my data cap for free.
The reason is that my iPhone's haven't arrived yet, so until they are activated I won't be able to increase my data cap for free.
40GB vs Unlimited (Throttled to .5Mb(b!)ps):
I hit 5GB within 7-10 days usually. I'm hoping that with the wife (who has only hit 5GB once, and was on the 3GB plan) and no other data users on my family plan (kids are data blocked with wifi only as their only means of web usage) it'll be better.
It's a TINY bit cheaper, and tethering will be nice on occasion too. Even if you JB, AT&T knows you are tethering, and at some point will threaten to take away unlimited. This way, that's a non-issue.
Does anyone know if there's a way to "allocate" data under this plan? Can I give my son's line 1GB and then have it stop for example? Or do I have to monitor it and shut it off (I know you can do that, I'd just rather divvy it up upfront). Possible?
40GB is a LOT for 2 people. I'll still probably come close, but I'll probably have to be trying to do so.
I hit 5GB within 7-10 days usually. I'm hoping that with the wife (who has only hit 5GB once, and was on the 3GB plan) and no other data users on my family plan (kids are data blocked with wifi only as their only means of web usage) it'll be better.
It's a TINY bit cheaper, and tethering will be nice on occasion too. Even if you JB, AT&T knows you are tethering, and at some point will threaten to take away unlimited. This way, that's a non-issue.
Does anyone know if there's a way to "allocate" data under this plan? Can I give my son's line 1GB and then have it stop for example? Or do I have to monitor it and shut it off (I know you can do that, I'd just rather divvy it up upfront). Possible?
40GB is a LOT for 2 people. I'll still probably come close, but I'll probably have to be trying to do so.
complain all you want about AT&T. I am now getting 60GB per month for the same price i paid for 30GB last month. Thats a win in my book.
so even if I trade in iphone 5 to tmobile I won't get a high value to be able then use my iPhone 6+ that I own? thx!!
----------
it's great for 15gb and up but those under not so great
So what's the difference between me using 10GBs and a person using 30GBs? Oh, they're paying $100 more. That's the difference? Got it.