Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Attention All iphone 3G Users With Reception And Data Problems
- Thread starter a1016neo
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It's obviously not a network issue when you can take another 3G phone (Blackjack II for me) and set it next to an iPhone and have full signal on the blackjack and 1-2 bars on the iPhone. You can argue overloaded network or AT&T coverage, whatever...you can't argue with 2 phones side by side with 1 at full bars and the other 1-2. Not sure if it's hardware or software, but Apple needs to deal with it.
AT&T reception/coverage
I came from Verizon and I live in the very populated Hampton Roads area of Virginia. AT&T coverage is not nearly as good as Verizon. More bars in more places by butt!
I'm sending feedback to Apple and AT&T. I love my iPhone but it sucks to have 1 little bar in my house now when I had full coverage with Verizon anywhere and everywhere I went.
I came from Verizon and I live in the very populated Hampton Roads area of Virginia. AT&T coverage is not nearly as good as Verizon. More bars in more places by butt!
I'm sending feedback to Apple and AT&T. I love my iPhone but it sucks to have 1 little bar in my house now when I had full coverage with Verizon anywhere and everywhere I went.
Yes I love my iphone but I the cell phone reception is bad and 3G is SLOW.... My Blackjack 2 from AT&T get's faster 3G data than my iphone 3G... So I don't think it's the network, but I think it's a combination of both!
Send in your feedback to Apple:http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphone.html
I wish someone could explain why "testmyiphone.com" always shows my iPhone 3G as being slower than EDGE, but surfing web pages on my iPhone 3G is way quicker than my original EDGE iPhone. Way quicker...
That doesn't make sense, unless AT&T is deliberately slowing down large file transfers while letting smaller things fly through more quickly.
Well you can't blame Apple for bad battery life... 3G sucks up battery life quite fast... I advise you to turn off 3G when you are not using it or when you are on WiFi... All phones are like this and quite frankly the battery life is quite good on the iphone 3G compared to other phones. Hopefully Apple (or AT&T) can fix the slow 3G network and dropped calls.
SUBMIT YOU FEED BACK TO APPLE.... TELL THEM HOW YOU FEEL!
http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphone.html
SUBMIT YOU FEED BACK TO APPLE.... TELL THEM HOW YOU FEEL!
http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphone.html
This is strictly an AT&T problem.
Apple is stuck with them for years to come... like it or not, it won't change.
Apple is stuck with them for years to come... like it or not, it won't change.
I guess you are ignoring or think a post like this is a lie. I've seen multiple accounts of people comparing two phones BOTH on the ATT network and the iPhone having reception and data speed issues. Some stories also mention returning the iPhone for a new one and then everything was equal. So maybe a large number of phones are somewhat defective.
I think the 3G speeds are fine. Saturday night, after my iPhone purchase, I ended up at a demolition derby in Campbell County Kentucky. Out of curiosity (between rounds of playing "name that smell" coming from those around me) I ran a few speed tests. I was getting about 1MB. Hell, there were more kbps in the air than there were teeth in the entire grand stand.
Regardless of the comparison of bars on various phones, the proof is in the actual performance. Last week, my Moto Q (3G AT&T) was getting better than 1 Mbps consistently. This week, the best I could do as of this morning was 430 kbps or so. Guess what the iPhone I just picked up this morning gets...about 430 kbps. It also shows one less bar than my Moto did, but it's got the same throughput. I don't know how bars are calculated, but my WM phones all had four bar segments maximum while the iPhone has five segments in theirs.
What the iPhone has over the Moto, though, is way faster page rendering in the browser. My Moto would spend about 60-90 seconds to render this forum, even when my 3G speed was near 100%.
Unless Apple somehow sabotaged my Moto Q, I'm blaming AT&T's network overload for this speed issue.
What the iPhone has over the Moto, though, is way faster page rendering in the browser. My Moto would spend about 60-90 seconds to render this forum, even when my 3G speed was near 100%.
Unless Apple somehow sabotaged my Moto Q, I'm blaming AT&T's network overload for this speed issue.
Are any of you defending the data capability of the network comparing voice quality/dropped calls?
i just ran the inetwork test here in japan and got only 152kbps so this is a problem for the whole world not AT&T so apple does need to release a software update to fix this. i hope that it is just software and they didnt change to cheaper hardware
You gotta think Apple devs have known about the problems and have been working on them since before the iphone 3g release they just were rushed to release so they released the 3g with the latest firmware they had even though it was buggy. As i understand it the 1st gen iphone was a mess up until the last month before release.
ATTENTION ALL IPHONE 3G USERS:
After reading many post from here and other websites this is what I found out:
It seems that an iphone 3G with 1 - 2 bars seems to make pretty good calls compared to other AT&T phone or on EDGE with the iphone 3G with 3 - 4 bars..
So Bars from one phone may/may not be different from another phone...
EDGE get's 3 - 5 bars
3G get's 1 - 2 bars
3G get's better quality sound and fewer dropped calls than EDGE despite fewer bars???
Please share your experience
Interesting Indeed!!!
After reading many post from here and other websites this is what I found out:
It seems that an iphone 3G with 1 - 2 bars seems to make pretty good calls compared to other AT&T phone or on EDGE with the iphone 3G with 3 - 4 bars..
So Bars from one phone may/may not be different from another phone...
EDGE get's 3 - 5 bars
3G get's 1 - 2 bars
3G get's better quality sound and fewer dropped calls than EDGE despite fewer bars???
Please share your experience
Interesting Indeed!!!
FWIW:
Don't compare signal bars. They're relative to the manufacturer.
On your iPhone, if you dial *3001#12345#*, it will put it into Field Test mode. You'll notice that your bars of signal has been replaced by the actual signal strength RF reading (where the lower the number, the stronger the signal).
If you're comparing phones, google how to put the other phone into its Field Test mode and then compare the two actual RF readings.
If kdarling were here, he'd be able to correct all of the lingo above with correct terms, but you should get the basic idea.
My experience:
Original iPhone = 1 bar of GSM/EDGE reception in my house. Indoors, could only make calls from one spot in living room. Calls were often garbled for extended periods of time and dropped almost every time. Safari would not work, even though the E showed up. Sending text messages sometimes failed.
iPhone 3G = 1 bar of UMTS/HSPA reception in my house. Indoors, can make calls from anywhere. Calls rarely garble, and if so, only for a second. Calls don't drop. Safari works fine and seems faster than a good EDGE signal. Text messages never fail.
This matches what I've read over at Howardforums for the last year+ ... 3G (UMTS) voice sounds better on 1 bar than GSM does.
Don't compare signal bars. They're relative to the manufacturer.
On your iPhone, if you dial *3001#12345#*, it will put it into Field Test mode. You'll notice that your bars of signal has been replaced by the actual signal strength RF reading (where the lower the number, the stronger the signal).
If you're comparing phones, google how to put the other phone into its Field Test mode and then compare the two actual RF readings.
If kdarling were here, he'd be able to correct all of the lingo above with correct terms, but you should get the basic idea.
My experience:
Original iPhone = 1 bar of GSM/EDGE reception in my house. Indoors, could only make calls from one spot in living room. Calls were often garbled for extended periods of time and dropped almost every time. Safari would not work, even though the E showed up. Sending text messages sometimes failed.
iPhone 3G = 1 bar of UMTS/HSPA reception in my house. Indoors, can make calls from anywhere. Calls rarely garble, and if so, only for a second. Calls don't drop. Safari works fine and seems faster than a good EDGE signal. Text messages never fail.
This matches what I've read over at Howardforums for the last year+ ... 3G (UMTS) voice sounds better on 1 bar than GSM does.
so I finally got an answer from ATT this morning about my 3G getting only one bar of reseption and speeds slower than edge.
according to them, a lot of areas are in medium to low coverage for 3G that doesn't show in their coverage map.
they also claim a high volume of calls and data using the network, while she didn't say it was a problem; she mentioned that ATT will improve the coverage area in the next 12 months at least for the portland area.
what do you guys think? I don't buy it, I have an ATT tilt 3G; and right next to my iphone gets full signal on 3G and speeds of over 1mbps. netx stop, APPLE
according to them, a lot of areas are in medium to low coverage for 3G that doesn't show in their coverage map.
they also claim a high volume of calls and data using the network, while she didn't say it was a problem; she mentioned that ATT will improve the coverage area in the next 12 months at least for the portland area.
what do you guys think? I don't buy it, I have an ATT tilt 3G; and right next to my iphone gets full signal on 3G and speeds of over 1mbps. netx stop, APPLE
