You forgot the choice of people who seemingly cannot walk, wait in line (or at a stop light), or "just be" without staring at their phone. Once you become aware of everyone around you staring at their phones instead of just being aware of what is going on around you (or god forbid, conversing with someone next to you), you realize that people use their phones "too much".
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Battery Case Showdown: Apple's Smart Case vs. Mophie's Juice Pack Access
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You forgot the choice of people who seemingly cannot walk, wait in line (or at a stop light), or "just be" without staring at their phone. Once you become aware of everyone around you staring at their phones instead of just being aware of what is going on around you (or god forbid, conversing with someone next to you), you realize that people use their phones "too much".
Yeah it is weird how you could need that much juice on the court slate of phones that last so long. Though if you have bad cell service or if you are a reporter who does a lot of their work on their phone (pictures, video, monitoring the news, etc.) you can go through a lot of juice.
But I also think there is a group of folks out there that just enjoy having a fully charged phone. I think they have anxiety when their charge goes down and seeing their phone always fully charged gives them comfort. It is like PTSD from years ago when it was pretty common for your phone to run out of juice if you had a late night on the town. Seems weird to me, but I think that is part of the market for these battery cases.
The mophie case has an open bottom. Inexcusable as they're not Apple.
I fear your usage. I thought I was a heavy user, and I easily make it through a day on my XS. You suggesting that the battery on the Max needs improvement is terrifying, lol.
I fear your usage. I thought I was a heavy user, and I easily make it through a day on my XS. You suggesting that the battery on the Max needs improvement is terrifying, lol.
How often do you strike up conversations with strangers in the supermarket checkout lane or on a commuter train?
But there is a deeper element in this, people who use their phone a lot probably are also often people who spend a lot of their time alone (or alone among strangers).
That’s not true. The MFi program has allowed this since 2014.
https://9to5mac.com/2014/11/18/apple-mfi-summit-third-party-products-lightning-port-new-accessories/
Apple specifically mentioned battery cases with lightning input as something they were planning to see happen:
https://9to5mac.com/2015/01/12/deta...tning-port-specs-for-third-party-accessories/
The clear majority of my battery usage comes from fitness apps which I use to monitor my exercise regime on which I spend a couple of hours every day. That is the reason why on some days I use 150% of the iPhone's battery capacity (via charging it more than once per day). It's when I go on long hikes when map usage (incl. GPS) amps that up further without a convenient way to recharge the phone (if need be I do so via a power bank but that is less convenient than a battery case).
That's very easy to do, if you're willing to accept the consequence of compromised cellular reception/transmission. And as a result, greater battery discharge.
Why wouldn’t you be able to? The Lightning port on the Apple case is a complete pass-through port, it’s not just a charging port.
My biggest complaint and why I went with Mophie over Apple is the fact that Apple doesn't have a case for the iPhone X. It's meant for the newer iPhones even though the X and XS have the same dimensions the speaker/microphone is blocked if you were to use the case on the X. To add insult to injury you'll get a message stating this accessory isn't supported.
Newest iOS update supports the case. Been using the XS case with my X for a couple of weeks now. Works like a charm.
I don't like it the look...the Apple Smart Battery case is way better, and I'm glad I bought it...I can go almost 3 days without charging.
These cases are for two different types of people/customers in my opinion. This depends on where you live and how you use the external battery to charge your smartphone. If you live in Asia and carry a sling bag,purse,man’s purse or little back pack then many will prefer the portable battery like the ones from Anker. If you carry no purse or any form of bag then you may want one like the one from Apple. Ideally it would be best to have one of each for different situations. Like having running shoes and casual shoes. There is no one is better for all people and all situations. Each has its advantages over the other. Depending on the scenario you are in for the day or two depends on which one you will want to bring along with you.
If you lived in a city like Hong Kong and you bought the iPhone battery pack you would have two choices: 1) leave it on all day 2) Put it in your bag or purse until batter runs low then put it on. Option 2 would mean that you would also need to carry a smartphone case with you as well all the time and leave smartphone case on when not using iPhone battery case/charger until you need to recharge your iPhone.
Those in Asia that carry around an iPhone and iPad prefer to carry a portable battery bank that allows them to charge both or either one of them when needed.
In the US those that use a smartphone holder in a car would run into issues with the iPhone case as it would not be too suitable for all car smartphone holders. I have one though that will work with a good magnetic smartphone holder provided you add the plate on the back of the iPhone charger case.
If you lived in a city like Hong Kong and you bought the iPhone battery pack you would have two choices: 1) leave it on all day 2) Put it in your bag or purse until batter runs low then put it on. Option 2 would mean that you would also need to carry a smartphone case with you as well all the time and leave smartphone case on when not using iPhone battery case/charger until you need to recharge your iPhone.
Those in Asia that carry around an iPhone and iPad prefer to carry a portable battery bank that allows them to charge both or either one of them when needed.
In the US those that use a smartphone holder in a car would run into issues with the iPhone case as it would not be too suitable for all car smartphone holders. I have one though that will work with a good magnetic smartphone holder provided you add the plate on the back of the iPhone charger case.
Ain’t this the truth. In Hong Kong I see everyone and their mother walking around with a cable coming out of their pocket, purse or backpack and plugged into their phone. It’s pretty crazy. In cities in the US you sometimes see people with battery packs charging their phones but it’s usually with a little six inch cable plugged in while they’re sitting at table at a bar or restaurant. In Asia everyone is charging all day every day.
When in Hong Kong I also carry a sling pack from Safepack and I leave my battery pack inside it. When battery runs low I attach it to my smartphone. In places like Hong Kong and other big cities people spend most of the day outside and don’t want to walk around with everything stuffed in their pockets. In America people do not walk around (they drive around ) so they throw everything in their cars or keep them in their cars. Different customers have different needs based on where they are at and how they get around.
Why do they propose that these are the only choices in a battery case? I opted for a $35 Swaller case from Amazon for my iPhone Xs...same concept, same form factor. It works great. I can't think of a reason why I would ever drop 3x - 4x more for either a Mophie or Apple case.
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Nope. I've had two mophie cases warrantied by the company. Maybe I just had some bad luck.
Gotcha. I’ve had decent experience with them, but maybe I’m the outlier lol. Checking Amazon, they seem to be rated 3 to 3-1/2 stars. Since they’re relatively expensive, I’d expect better.
Agree. And I'm one of those people that likes name brands (i know lol). I wish Incase would make battery cases.
I bet if you read a lot of those reviews people knocked a star or two off because of the price. Pretty common to see in Amazon reviews of quality products that cost more than the cheapo competition.
I think with these battery cases, they should add in some other functions. There was a mophie at one point that had a storage expansion card with I think 32GB of space. I've seen another with an extra SIM slot. I think with a little creativity, there could be other ideas for making these cases more than just a battery.
I took a look at the juice pack for the 7 Plus. 2.9 star rating overall, 36% of reviews are 1-star—yikes!
I only skimmed through the first couple pages of the 1-star reviews; complaints seem to be mostly about the quality.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/cr/B01..._mb_hist_1?filterByStar=one_star&pageNumber=1
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
The SD card slot was basically a gimmick. It didn’t give you additional storage space. It just let you offload pictures from your system storage to the SD card so you could delete them from the system storage. If you wanted to view them you had to use a proprietary app. In other words there’s a reason they stopped making it. It sucked.
That only case I could find with an additional SIM was basically using some, again, proprietary, clunky, software. It didn’t give you real dial SIM functionality like the XS series iPhones.
Started with Mophie on my iPhone 4 and have used their products on every generation of iPhone since that time. I have had one battery issue with both the iPhone 6+ and Mophie case due to lithium battery failure in both units (they both became very pregnant). I have had a handmade leather belt case made for each model as it came out. Since the 6+, I am still using the same leather case that looks well worn. A silicone case that attracts dust and stuff off of fingers would rapidly look terrible from rubbing the inside of the leather case in no time.
I have the new XS Max Mophie case on order and it will work for me as the others have.I like the fact that the microUSB connector I had to carry for the prior design Mophie batteries is a thing of the past. I will have the ability to choose either a lightening plug for the iPhone or the "C" connector for the Mophie battery or wifi charge the combination. I carry an Anger Power Port PD2 power plug that has the capability to have both of those power cords plugged in a the same time.
I have the best Zagg screen guard in place just like on all prior iPhones and have had free replacements over the years with no questions and no damage to the Apple display.
We all still get to make choices.
I have the new XS Max Mophie case on order and it will work for me as the others have.I like the fact that the microUSB connector I had to carry for the prior design Mophie batteries is a thing of the past. I will have the ability to choose either a lightening plug for the iPhone or the "C" connector for the Mophie battery or wifi charge the combination. I carry an Anger Power Port PD2 power plug that has the capability to have both of those power cords plugged in a the same time.
I have the best Zagg screen guard in place just like on all prior iPhones and have had free replacements over the years with no questions and no damage to the Apple display.
We all still get to make choices.
Ugh.
They're both awful. Why would either company think I would want a big bulge on the back of my phone? Run the case all the way to the top, Mophie.
They're both awful. Why would either company think I would want a big bulge on the back of my phone? Run the case all the way to the top, Mophie.