Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I feel sorry for the investors on this. what a dumb business model.
I don't because they should have had common sense. If anything these people literally preyed on the desperation of Android users to profit off their desire for blue bubbles and made some quick cash.

It's predatory yet i commend them for it at the same time.
 
I'm all for iMessage being on Android. And it's awesome that Beeper tried. But they really need to quit while they are ahead. This will be a game of cat and mouse, and the cat always wins.
 
You do know that more users tap into system means that will take up resources on Apple infrastructures. Nothing is free. If that will put more load on their servers which in turns make the infrastructures overload and make my service slower, or increase whatever monthly payment I am paying to Apple due to this reason, I would go against whoever use these hack.
So you’re saying Android users also shouldn’t be sending emails to iCloud Mail addresses, for risk of overloading Apple’s servers? Yeah, that totally makes sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: knirirr and alexiaa
Why would an Android user care enough about iMessage to jump through all these hoops?

I get that Beeper's parent company is trying anything they can to keep their product alive, but it's pretty clear that any workarounds they do find will be short lived. Apple doesn't want it, so this product is already dead. At some point they are going to have to accept that reality instead of continuing to light their VC $$ on fire.
I'm pretty sure they're not VC funded.

This is going to be a niche service for sure, but some number of people will really want it, and for them it's a great product. I have an iPhone at the moment, but I may switch to Android in the future (I have some serious gripes with iOS), and if I did I would 100% be willing to jump through whatever hoops I had to in order to keep iMessage working, because that's what all my friends, family, and coworkers use.
 
Why would an Android user care enough about iMessage to jump through all these hoops?

I get that Beeper's parent company is trying anything they can to keep their product alive, but it's pretty clear that any workarounds they do find will be short lived. Apple doesn't want it, so this product is already dead. At some point they are going to have to accept that reality instead of continuing to light their VC $$ on fire.
Tech enthusiasts who are either Mac+Android users (they exist, for some reason), or are in majority iPhone families. But I can't imagine that is a pool of customers large enough to justify this nonsense.
 
9a45cc6b93988add1e6da425c21b5ddf.gif

Honestly it's time to let it go. Bleeper is starting to act like that ex who cant let go.
 
This is getting ridiculous. Buy a used iPhone and then jailbreak it?! They just need to give up and end this service. The more "hacks" they attempt the less appealing this is to users.
 
  • Like
Reactions: strongy
It's 👏 not 👏 just 👏 about 👏 the 👏 blue 👏 bubbles.

I don't understand why this stupid narrative keeps repeating.

It keeps repeating because there are certain iPhone users who are obsessed with blue bubbles. If you realize that blue bubbles exist ONLY on an iPhone screen then it becomes obvious that only one group could care about the color of their bubbles. Speaking of living in a bubble, I've began to realize that many iPhone users feel they're part of an exclusive club. Comments here lead me to believe these particular users think an open system would somehow take away their ability to feel unique. An iPhone owner who needs blue bubble exclusively is like the Porsche owner who has to wear a Porsche jacket to the office every day. It's just not a good look.
 
it's like apple doesnt want you to use iMessage at all and commenters here will support that by telling you to use whatsapp/messenger/signal/etc for the apparently earth shattering feature of up to date interoperability
 
Can we stop giving beeper mini free press please? This is getting ridiculous. Just let it die. You’re now attracting the eyes of legislators because of how much coverage this desperate company is getting.
This is MacRumors giving them coverage based on a deleted blog post.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Dj64Mk7
I'm all for iMessage being on Android.

Can you please explain to me why you guys feel you are Obligated to iMessage? Like seriously. And please dont give me the same tired arguments about E2EE (half of you guys dont even know what that is or better yet use google and you are worried about privacy) and sending compressed videos (when they have a multi-tude of apps to send videos on).

Outside of all those same arguments, why on earth are you entitled to imessage...a feature made for IOS devices.

I can tell you why I hate the idea of Beeper (well one of them). It's simple. I use a lot of apple specific products and services and features that CANT work with Android (Apple pay and reservations for example. Sharing my location is another).

How am I supposed to know if I am talking to a legit Apple customer or a Fraud? Now you could argue that Apple should bring Apple imessage to Android and I'd argue why? Why do you feel you need something from another company because your preferred company can't make anything compelling that people want to use. Because RCS is one of Google's MANY attempts to control messaging over the last 20 years. Literally.

I can make a good point about RCS that i recently. Google doesn't even allow its RCS Apis to be utilized by 3rd party messaging apps thus forcing all android users who want to use RCS to use google's messaging app or not have RCS. Meaning Google is literally doing the same exact thing that Apple is accused of doing: Locking people into their apps.
 
Can you please explain to me why you guys feel you are Obligated to iMessage? Like seriously. And please dont give me the same tired arguments about E2EE (half of you guys dont even know what that is or better yet use google and you are worried about privacy) and sending compressed videos (when they have a multi-tude of apps to send videos on).

Outside of all those same arguments, why on earth are you entitled to imessage...a feature made for IOS devices.

I can tell you why I hate the idea of Beeper (well one of them). It's simple. I use a lot of apple specific products and services and features that CANT work with Android (Apple pay and reservations for example. Sharing my location is another).

How am I supposed to know if I am talking to a legit Apple customer or a Fraud? Now you could argue that Apple should bring Apple imessage to Android and I'd argue why? Why do you feel you need something from another company because your preferred company can't make anything compelling that people want to use. Because RCS is one of Google's MANY attempts to control messaging over the last 20 years. Literally.

I can make a good point about RCS that i recently. Google doesn't even allow its RCS Apis to be utilized by 3rd party messaging apps thus forcing all android users who want to use RCS to use google's messaging app or not have RCS. Meaning Google is literally doing the same exact thing that Apple is accused of doing: Locking people into their apps.

oh dear pearl clutching christ lmao
 
the difference being the emails sent from Android phones aren't hacking into icloud mail to use icloud mail addresses.
SO that point you were trying to make doesnt make any sense.
No hacking, they are using Apple’s regular iMessage protocol. The only difference is that it is a proprietary protocol instead of an open protocol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alexiaa
Are they still charging people at this point for this terrible hack?
 
At this point, just use your old iPhone and be done with it. Or, if you don't have any iPhone yet, just buy a used one or buy an iPod Touch. Same thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: strongy
I'm waiting for the final version of this which Apple will not be able to block. It'll involve you buying an iPhone, copying and pasting your message from the Messages app into a Beeper Mini proxy app on the iPhone. This will then appear on your Android Beeper Mini app. To send a message you'll then just reverse this process, typing it out on Android and then copying and pasting from the Beeper Mini proxy into Messages to send it.

It'll be flawless and perfectly solve this problem once and for all...
 
This is becoming pretty damn comical. It's also incredibly nonsensical to me.

Pretty much all the Android users I know use Android phones because they dislike Apple and iPhones. Which is fine, that's their opinion and they're entitled to it.

But why would they be so desperate to use iMessage then? Seems a bit hypocritical to me. I mentioned this whole kerfluffle to my Android using friend and he was utterly perplexed as to why someone would go through so much trouble to use iMessage which "sucks", in his words.

If you're so desperate to use iMessage, just get an iPhone.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.