In a weird way, it gives me iPod nano vibes which I like.
I don't know that I'm getting one but they're all kinda cool this year
iP17 - weak colors overall, remarkably weak.. except green looks cool, the black looks even more faded ugh.
But 120hz/AOD/better battery 6.3 and bezels. Pretty much a better iP16Pro in every way at $200 cheaper than last year's offerings. Hope they've addressed battery life bc it wasn't pretty in my limited testing with 16Pro. That's one of the main reasons I got rid of mine within the return policy.
Air - the value prop was already shown, it's thin and 'new model' and plus model on a diet with faster screen. And supposedly strongest. But if you dont care about any of that, you can stay put or move up/down the upgrade latter from this middle ground pricing wise (negating 16e existing in this take)
iP17Pro - seems to address thermal throttling, but I wonder if people are going to like going from SS-Ti-aloominum again. Nice cameras and yea yea, but I dunno the gap seems less wide between 17 and Air and the Pro counterparts, from what we've seen marketing wise. Unless you're really into mobile gaming or making a full feature film on your phone. I kid but. I thought between 16 and 16Pro's the gap narrowed quite a lot, but here even more.
The takeaway for me is non-pro's are even more compelling this year. The pro does look nice though, and I dont know how orange would settle with me over time, but I appreciate the boldness. Weird that black pro models got nothing! it's white blue or orange. But I like seeing the bleu return. And I personally think aluminum is probably going to be the right choice, SS looked cool but was prohibitively heavy, and I dunno the titanium never really felt all that premium to me lighter than SS but not aluminum light and you feel that in hand.
my quick reaction always subject to change.