@rstark18 your post was very interesting to read. In the past, the Caudabe Sheath was thinner than the Apple leather. This changed last year for the 12 Pro Max. In my initial review, I mentioned how the Apple leather was just as thin as the Caudabe Sheath but taller, so it gave the impression that the Sheath was thinner. It appears maybe Caudabe has made the case thicker this year. I'm wondering if the size and weight of the Sheath is similar to Ringke Onyx or the Spigen Thin Fit. I definitely felt the weight and size (and the discomfort) of those cases when I tried them last year. I had my suspicions when I was looking at some of the pictures that were shared in this forum. The sides definitely looked thick in those pictures.
I can answer part of this.
I’ve got both the Ringke Onyx and Caudabe Sheath for the 13 Pro Max and the Sheath is much heavier.
The Sheath is thicker all around as well.
Between the two, I prefer the Onyx, though I do love the Sheath. If Ringke would add MagSafe to the Onyx, it would be perfect.
The funny thing is, I’ve got the Synthesis coming soon, and if the 12 Pro Max version I had before is anything to go off of, it’s going to be a really heavy case combined with the heavier 13 Pro Max. I’m not sure it’ll be used that much because of the weight.