How is listing 20 or so links without any context being "owned"?
It's more like "electronic intimidation" - it will take some time to follow each link, determine its strengths and weaknesses, and come up with a response.
Posting a long list of URLs is a bullying tactic, not a discussion. I don't follow naked links - if you can't tell me why I should click on a link - I don't. If you can't give me an analysis of how a link supports your position, I'm not going to do it for you.
At least quote a paragraph or sentence from each link that supports your argument.
This link is an answer to the link he provided.
http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/09/02/28/japanese_hate_for_iphone_all_a_big_mistake.html
Add to that the fact that the iPhone was #1 in Japan in July and August.
The rest of the links just demonstrate he's been living under a rock since 2007.
Downplaying the iPhone - its impact, its significance, its overall feature set, what it brings to the table, how the industry has received it, etc., is really a losing game. It's getting to be like downplaying the iPod: Either you're aware of a new device that no one else is aware of (or you've got a working crystal ball), or you're crazy.
What, you seriously think you'd have an HTC hero, WinMo 7 (LOL), the Pre, Android, etc., without the massive shakeup the iPhone brought to the market?? Sure, you'd have them. Years later and in who knows what condition. And in two years, the rest of the half-asleep also rans can barely approach the iPhone, never mind "catching up." Thanks to the iPhone, Motorola is in a position now where they're on they're last legs. Yeah, I'm really sure they saw THAT coming three years ago! So where do you think they'd all be WITHOUT the iPhone, when even WITH the iPhone as an example they can barely get their act together after all this time?
The iPhone "isn't that great", yet it's already breathing down RIM's neck and Nokia's in a steady downward spiral. Apple, a new player, in only two years, managed to utterly embarass the "big" players who have been at the game for years. And continue to do it! Not bad for "not great." So then, what actually IS great? Telepathy?
No, you don't need to click the links. But they're all there and they certainly beat anecdotal "I think this/I think that" nonsense. Dodge the links all you like. Others, however, *will* click the links. They're pretty self-explanatory. Even cursory, basic, Google research will state the obvious - what everyone already knows.