I see a lot of negative comments about Max pricing, but I’ve not heard a better pair of wireless headphones. It almost rivals my wired AKGs but with the convenience of wireless and startlingly good ANC. The design is also pure genius; I don’t get ear/head fatigue the way I do with every other headphone. So for me, it’s worth the asking price. At $449, I think it’s a great deal.
What people are missing is the build quality not only justifies but likely imposes a pricing threshold. It really is built in a manner that, inside and out (modulo the Fisher Price coloring) seems worthy of the "machine" moniker. It is not a toy.
My 2 theses on the APM and the usual "what Apple should do" armchair **** below:
1's:
Pretty damn good audio quality after EQ of some sort
No ear sweating
Supreme ear pad enclosure, deep and not shallow
Solid ANC
Bluetooth connectivity (for apple users, I get it)
Spatial Audio (First time I really appreciated it for a movie. Really was awesome)
0's:
Number one thing: Heavy as ****. Man, they just shouldn't have done this with the design, while objectively remarkable it defeats the utility and drives the price up. This further decreases the value proposition.
Lightning. ****ing. Port. What the **** Apple. Just give us USB-C with proper PD support and USB-C audio.
No jack and, again, lightning port that requires the use of a special lightning adapter to input 3.5 or corded audio whatsoever. So they rub it in by rendering it useless for digital audio and requiring another conversion in the chain from analog (3.5 input cord) >> digital (lightning port on APM)
Price, which is in tandem with some of the other benefits or downsides.
Convoluted attempt at simplicity with the lack of off button reminiscent of the Third-gen iPod Shuffle debacle, or Windows 8 and the start menu. A smaller scale, but still. Just put a ****ing power button on the device, Apple.
Codec limitations. Yes, AAC is itself good enough to be reasonably transparent after repeated conversion and indistinguishable from lossless to 99.5% of the population, but the bluetooth implementation of this codec is a separate matter, and the performance is notably inferior on most non-Apple devices and even Apple's own devices display some noise floor issues.
I'm sure I missed some things but really, I'd said this before:
What Apple should have done is created an XM4 clone, plain as can be, with their stupid colors and all but importantly, their integration and custom ear pad implementation, light body at 270-300 grams, and charge a premium of $50-80, $349-429. If it had 85% of the Max's sound in a lighter plastic profile, it'd be worthwhile at that price, especially after sales. Then we'd really have something. It would''ve been a totally different conversation.
Feels like this ends up another HomePod, the difference being this had real potential.